3-Star Hotels, Guesthouses, Hostels, Inns in East Rutherford NJ

U Hotel Fifth Avenue, Empire State Building 7.1 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $192

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryNestled in the heart of Manhattan, U Hotel Fifth Avenue provides a cost-effective lodging option for those seeking close proximity to the Empire State Building. Guests frequently highlight its prime location, making it an unbeatable choice for visitors focused on exploring New York City. The rooms, while often described as small and minimally appointed, adequately meet the needs of short stays. Comfort and cleanliness receive commendations, despite some noting old decor and occasional superficial cleaning issues.

Travelers appreciate the hotel's value-for-money proposition, especially given the typically high prices in Manhattan. Despite the lack of extensive amenities like minibars or breakfast services, the hotel stands out for its practicality and good maintenance. The staff’s friendliness and the comfortable beds contribute positively to the guest experience.

However, some guests feel the hotel falls short of the expected three-star standard. Complaints include room sizes being smaller than advertised, missing advertised bedspreads and non-functional amenities like an elevator. These criticisms suggest it might not be ideal for business travelers or those seeking a more comprehensive service offering.

In summary, U Hotel Fifth Avenue delivers a decent mid-range option with a stellar location, suitable for budget-conscious travelers prioritizing access to city attractions over luxury accommodations.
Show more

Nomad Design House 7.1 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

Info Categories

3-Star Hotel

Hotel with Free Wi-Fi

Small Hotel

Montclair Apartment 7.1 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in Montclair NJ

Info Categories

3-Star Hotel

Family Friendly Hotel

Hotel with Free Wi-Fi

Hotel Wolcott 7.1 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.2

Very Good

From $32

Info Categories

3-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

Robert Treat Hotel 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in Newark NJ

7.1

Good

From $134

3-Star Hotel

This hotel is steps from the New Jersey Performing Arts Center and offers a restaurant, a 24-hour fitness center, and a bar/lounge. It is a non-smoking property, ensuring a comfortable environment.

Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryThe Robert Treat Hotel has received mixed reviews regarding its three-star rating, facilities and services. Many guests noted that it does not quite meet the standard of a three-star property with some describing it as more aligned with a one-star rating. Comments often highlighted that the hotel offers basic amenities but lacks the polish and service expected of a higher-rated establishment. While there were positive mentions, such as the park situated in front of the hotel being very nice and some guests recommending the hotel, others were less impressed, citing the need for better-trained front desk staff and overall improvements to amenities.

Though some found the experience passable and even exceptional, many cautioned against expecting three-star quality, especially when compared directly to other similarly rated hotels in the U.S. and worldwide. Negative feedback emphasized that the hotel may not be suitable for families with children and suggested it be seen as a place geared more towards transient visitors. Overall, while the park and some aspects of the location received praise, the consensus is that the Robert Treat Hotel falls short of its claimed three-star status.
Show more

The Flat NYC 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.8

Good

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryThe Flat NYC offers travelers an unbeatable location at an affordable price, making it a fantastic choice for those visiting New York City on a budget. Centrally situated near transportation hubs like subway stations and Madison Square, the hotel provides easy access to all that Manhattan has to offer. Guests consistently praise its cleanliness and the friendly, polite staff who strive to make every stay enjoyable. The rooms, while small and occasionally noisy due to window air conditioning units, are clean and modern with all the basic amenities needed for a comfortable stay.

Despite the lack of an elevator and the occasional wait for shared bathrooms, most visitors find the value for money to be excellent, especially given the neighborhood and proximity to key attractions. The availability of essentials such as water bottles and the overall good quality-price ratio adds to the appeal. While it may not suit those looking for larger rooms or chain hotel experiences, The Flat NYC is recognized as a decent, mid-range option that delivers satisfactorily on the essentials, making it "perfect for a weekend break" and a place many guests would return to and recommend.
Show more

Heritage Hotel New York City 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.5

Good

From $200

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryHeritage Hotel New York City offers a compelling value proposition for budget-conscious travelers, particularly given its excellent central location near Madison Square. Guests frequently highlight the good price-quality ratio, describing the hotel as great value for money and worth the price, especially considering its proximity to Manhattan attractions.

The hotel delivers on the basics with all necessary amenities to ensure a comfortable stay. Despite its age and outdated facilities, which are common in hotels of this category, the hotel maintains a satisfactory level of cleanliness and service. While tiny rooms and bathrooms may not cater to luxury seekers, they are typical for a three-star establishment.

Though some guests feel the hotel leans more towards a budget or two-star rating, the overall sentiment is that it meets expectations for a three-star accommodation. The room amenities and average facilities align with what one might expect from this classification. In addition, the environment and services are considered above average for a three-star hotel.

Overall, Heritage Hotel provides a decent stay for those prioritizing value and location over modernity and luxury. It serves as an appropriate choice for business trips or short stays in Manhattan, offering a fair balance of cost and convenience.
Show more

The International Cozy Inn 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Guest House in New York NY

7.8

Good

From $255

Info Categories

3-Star Guest House

Guest House for Honeymoon

Guest House near Nightlife Spots

Soul Food 'Mont Morris' 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Guest House in New York NY

9.6

Excellent

From $186

Info Categories

3-Star Guest House

Guest House with Free Wi-Fi

Guest House for Adults Only

TRYP by Wyndham Newark Downtown 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in Newark NJ

8.1

Very Good

From $129

3-Star Hotel

This hotel is centrally located in Newark. It's known for its excellent service and modern amenities, making it a great choice for visitors exploring the downtown area.

Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryThe 'TRYP by Wyndham Newark Downtown' offers a dignified and good value for money stay, standing out as a clean and comfortable three-star hotel. Its facilities and services are seen as good for its rating with clean rooms better than some European four-star hotels. The convenient location near Prudential Center and access to NJ Transit is a noted advantage.

While the hotel rooms are deemed okay, some guests felt that cleanliness could improve and others pointed out the absence of breakfast and a microwave as minor inconveniences. Though the cost aligns with what one might expect from a three-star hotel, there are varied opinions on whether the services and amenities match up to these expectations. Despite mixed reviews about how well the experience aligns with the three-star rating, some guests were satisfied, feeling safe and secure during their stay.
Show more

Best Western Premier Empire State Hotel 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.5

Very Good

From $216

3-Star Hotel

This hotel offers a prime location and consistently positive guest experiences. Its well-maintained facilities and comfortable accommodations make it a reliable choice.

Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryThe Best Western Premier Empire State Hotel offers a mix of experiences, largely characterized by its remarkable location and decent three-star amenities. Positioned conveniently in New York, this middle-class hotel is known for being good value for money, especially in a city notorious for high accommodation costs. Guests often remark on its reasonable pricing and describe it as a decent hotel room in NYC, citing the great value and well-maintained lobby and rooms as positive highlights.

The hotel staff has garnered positive mentions for being friendly and efficient, enhancing the overall guest experience. The efficient staff and central location are frequently noted advantages, making it a suitable option for visitors.

However, the hotel does have its shortcomings. Some guests have reported issues such as insufficient room cleanliness, unmade beds and overall service quality that falls short of typical three-star expectations. These problems suggest inconsistencies in maintaining the hotel's standards, leading to varied guest opinions.

Ultimately, the Best Western Premier Empire State Hotel delivers a decent experience that aligns with its three-star rating—offering great value and a prime location in New York, albeit with some lapses in service quality.
Show more

Manhattan Guest Suites 7.2 km from East Rutherford

Guest House in New York NY

9.5

Excellent

Info Categories

3-Star Guest House

Guest House for Honeymoon

Small Guest House

Chelsea Inn 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Inn in New York NY

7.4

Good

From $188

3-Star InnSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryChelsea Inn offers a practical and economical choice for travelers visiting New York City. Located in a prime spot in Manhattan, the hotel allows easy access to the city's attractions. Guests appreciate the facility for its unbeatable price-performance ratio, comparing favorably with other options in the area. Cleanliness stands out as a notable plus with many reviewers highlighting the well-organized and tidy rooms.

Although the amenities are simple, the keyless entry system adds a modern touch to the experience. The hotel operates on a contactless model, which some find innovative while others miss a traditional receptionist. Despite minor upkeep issues in certain areas, the overall structure is functional and clean.

Chelsea Inn is particularly praised for its reasonable rates, making it excellent value for brief stays or short visits. This is especially important considering New York's often steep accommodation prices. For travelers seeking a cost-effective lodging solution without compromising on location and basic comforts, Chelsea Inn is a commendable choice.
Show more

The Historic Blue Angel Hotel Lexington Ave, an Ascend Collection 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.6

Very Good

From $232

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryThe Historic Blue Angel Hotel on Lexington Ave, part of the Ascend Hotel Collection, is praised for its appealing combination of affordability and location, making it a valuable choice amid New York's competitive hospitality scene. Many guests appreciate the helpful and friendly staff, which significantly enhances the overall experience.

While the hotel is described as a lovely boutique establishment with a charming atmosphere, some reviews point out the limited closet space and absence of a microwave as minor drawbacks. There's also mention of room sizes being on the smaller side and the occasional lack of windows in some rooms. Despite these issues, the hotel is frequently chosen by returning guests, indicating a strong level of satisfaction and loyalty.

Additionally, the convenience of luggage storage on both arrival and departure days is a notable perk. Although the price is considered high, as is common in Manhattan, the hotel offers good value compared to other local options. Overall, the Historic Blue Angel Hotel garners positive feedback for its cost-effectiveness, location and customer service.
Show more

Roger Smith Hotel By Suiteness 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

Info Categories

3-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Dog Friendly Hotel

Sonesta Simply Suites Jersey City 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in Jersey City NJ

8.5

Very Good

From $215

3-Star Hotel

As an aparthotel, Sonesta Simply Suites offers suites with kitchen facilities, making it suitable for longer stays. Its location provides convenient access to Exchange Place and other Jersey City attractions.

Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categorySonesta Simply Suites Jersey City offers a convenient location with a new and fresh interior that many guests appreciate. For those looking to stay in New Jersey on a budget, this hotel is often seen as a good option. However, some guests feel the price point is high, likening it to a two-star motel rather than a higher-rated hotel. While the hotel clearly aims to provide a budget-friendly option, there are some areas that fall short, such as limited room amenities, occasional housekeeping issues and a lack of views despite advance reservations. Overall, it is well-regarded for its fresh appearance and strategic location, though it may not meet all expectations in terms of value for money and service completeness.
Show more

The Bayard 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $341

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryNestled in a convenient location near restaurants and subway stations, Best Western Plus Hospitality House Suites offers a practical and accommodating stay for those visiting New York. The hotel boasts spacious apartment-like rooms, featuring a bedroom, living room, kitchen, and bathroom, making it a perfect choice for families or groups seeking comfort and functionality over luxury. While the decor is somewhat outdated, and some aspects like noisy air conditioning and limited towel drying space could be improved, the hotel compensates with its remarkable value for money.

Guests consistently praise the spaciousness of the accommodations, noting them to be a hidden gem despite the lack of opulence. Cleanliness and comfort are notable aspects, as housekeeping and cleaning staff are diligent in maintaining a good standard, though there have been minor lapses mentioned. The breakfast offers ample choices, enhancing the overall positive experience, even though the dining area is limited in size.

Service-wise, the staff stands out for their warmth and friendliness, contributing significantly to a pleasant stay. Reception and other staff members are highlighted as helpful and positive, enhancing the hotel's welcoming atmosphere. While the hotel isn't a luxury establishment, it meets essential needs for a peaceful and comfortable stay in New York, offering exceptional value in its category.
Show more

Hotel 27 by LuxUrban 7.3 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.1

Good

From $202

3-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '3 Star' categoryHotel 27 by LuxUrban is a well-situated option in NYC that meets expectations for a three-star facility. It's ideal for short, no-frills stays and is especially suited for travelers seeking a budget-friendly, centrally located lodging. The hotel offers good value for money, particularly given its prime location just a stone's throw from iconic landmarks like the Flatiron Building and the Empire State Building.

Visitors have noted that although the rooms are basic, they are clean and comfortable enough for a city trip. The pricing is considered reasonable compared to other hotels in the area with some guests highlighting it as an exceptional value during off-peak times, though rates can spike during high-demand periods like the Christmas holidays.

Overall, Hotel 27 provides a satisfactory experience for those who prioritize location and affordability over luxury. While it might verge on the quality of a hostel rather than a traditional hotel, it remains an acceptable choice for budget-conscious travelers exploring New York City.
Show more