Key West, 902 Whitehead Street24.55101,-81.800991(Show on Map)
8.4
Very Good
+5 Photos
+5 Photos
+ 3 Photos3
Checkin - Checkout dates
1 Room2 Guests
Info
Summary of reviews
The 'Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns' enjoys a prime location towards the quieter end of Duval Street, offering guests easy access to shopping, dining and notable Key West attractions, including the Ernest Hemingway House and the iconic lighthouse. The beautiful, green surroundings and historical charm of the older building create a welcoming and serene atmosphere, further enhanced by friendly and helpful staff.
The breakfast experience varies with some guests praising the well-presented, plentiful selection of continental breakfast items served on a cozy terrace. However, others found the breakfast timing and variety lacking, impacting their overall satisfaction.
Rooms at the Lighthouse Hotel are well-decorated and clean, boasting comfortable beds that many guests appreciated. However, space can be an issue with small rooms and occasional maintenance problems like inconsistent air conditioning and water temperatures. Cleanliness is generally commendable, though some guests noticed lapses in housekeeping and detailed cleaning.
The staff generally receive high marks for their friendliness and helpfulness with particular individuals noted for exceptional service. Nonetheless, there are occasional instances of less favorable interactions, suggesting potential improvements in consistency.
The pool area provides a pleasant retreat amidst lush greenery, complemented by poolside music. While enjoyable, the pool's small size, limited sun exposure and occasional cleanliness issues were highlighted as drawbacks.
Guests found the beds mostly comfortable, contributing to a restful stay despite a few reports of overly soft or lumpy mattresses and noisy air conditioning units.
Overall, the Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns offers a charming stay with a fantastic location and generally positive experiences, though it is essential for potential guests to consider the noted caveats, particularly regarding room size and breakfast variety.
Categories
Historic
Located near the Key West Lighthouse, this historic inn offers a charming and convenient base for exploring the island. Its architecture reflects the island's unique character, and its proximity to attractions makes it a desirable destination.
Dog Friendly
This hotel welcomes pets of any size for an additional fee of $50 per night. Both dogs and cats are allowed. Doggy beds, bowls, mats, waste bags, and 'Pet in Room' door hangers are provided.
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
3 Star
Golf
Sustainability Journey
Honeymoon
Nightlife
Accessible
Outdoor Pool
Heated Pool
Room Types
Snow White King Room This double room features air conditioning and flat-screen TV.
Pincushion King RoomThis room is also known as the Essential King Room.
Pincushion Mobility The spacious double room provides air conditioning, as well as a private bathroom featuring a hairdryer. This double room features a TV. The unit offers 1 bed.
Two Bedroom Loft SuiteThe suite has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom with a hairdryer and free toiletries. This suite features air conditioning and a TV. The unit has 2 beds.
Hemingway King SuiteThis spacious suite includes 1 living room, 1 separate bedroom and 1 bathroom with a hairdryer and free toiletries. This suite offers air conditioning and a TV. The unit has 2 beds.
Thimble Duo Offering free toiletries and bathrobes, this quadruple room includes a private bathroom with a hairdryer. This quadruple room offers air conditioning and a TV. The unit offers 2 beds.
Thimble Queen Room Featuring free toiletries and bathrobes, this double room includes a private bathroom with a hairdryer. This double room features air conditioning and a TV. The unit has 1 bed.
Guest Reviews
8.4
Very Good
Review Summaries
Location
Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns boasts an enviable location that guests consistently praise. Situated towards the quieter end of Duval Street, it is perfectly positioned for shopping, dining and exploring all that Key West has to offer. The hotel is directly opposite the Ernest Hemingway House and right at the foot of the iconic lighthouse, embedding guests in the heart of the island’s rich history.
The surroundings are beautifully green, creating a charming and cozy atmosphere. The property itself is a historic older building with a quaint and welcoming feel. The central location allows easy access to the main attractions, whether by foot or bike, making it exceptionally convenient for sightseeing. The distance to the bustling areas is just right to ensure both accessibility and tranquility.
Guests highlight the friendly and helpful staff, who add to the excellent overall experience. The hotel complex is well-maintained and clean and includes pleasant features like a nice garden and music at poolside. The charming decor and the cozy rooms enhance the welcoming and serene vibe of the property. This boutique hotel successfully combines historical charm with modern comforts, making it a fantastic choice for anyone visiting Key West.
Breakfast
The breakfast experience at the Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns received a mixed bag of reviews from guests. Many found it to be varied, well-presented and delicious, which helped them save on dining expenses. The continental breakfast, in particular, garnered praise for being plentiful and having a good selection of items including fresh options and proteins. The cozy terrace where breakfast is served was appreciated by several guests.
However, there were consistent criticisms regarding the timing and quality of the breakfast. A notable mention was the late start at 8am, which some guests found inconvenient. The lack of variety and basic options disappointed many with some describing the breakfast as rudimentary, poor and not fitting the standard of the hotel. Issues with cleanliness, insufficient utensils and unavailability of staff were also reported. For those expecting more from the hotel's breakfast experience, the feedback suggests it could indeed benefit from significant improvements to meet guests' expectations.
Rooms
Nestled in a wonderful location with a charming atmosphere, the 'Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns' offers a mix of modern and retro-styled rooms. Guests appreciated the comfortable beds and the overall cleanliness and maintenance of the property. Many remarked on the well-arranged decor and beautiful rooms which made for a pleasant aesthetic experience.
However, the rooms are notably small with many guests finding it difficult to manage luggage and noting that the spaces did not match their expectations based on advertising. The bathrooms received mixed reviews, ranging from satisfactory to very small and occasionally lacking essential amenities like towels. Air conditioning and water temperature inconsistencies were notable issues, impacting overall comfort.
Despite its beautiful decor, the hotel seemed to fall short on some basics, such as cleanliness and addressing musty odors. Additionally, the pool area was described as small and often crowded with limited space for lounging. For the price, guests felt the amenities were insufficient and some expressed frustrations with customer service and booking discrepancies.
In summary, the 'Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns' offers an aesthetically pleasing stay in a prime location, but with significant caveats related to room size, cleanliness and amenities.
Beds
The Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns receives mixed reviews about its beds, but the majority lean towards positive sentiments. Many guests found the beds to be very comfortable with some even describing them as incredibly comfortable and the most comfortable bed and bedding they have ever experienced on vacation. The bedding is often praised for being very comfortable, although a few guests mentioned it was a bit warm for the season. The king-size beds also received commendations for their comfort.
However, there were a few negative remarks about the beds. Some guests reported that the mattresses were too soft, lumpy or very uncomfortable. Additionally, there were mentions of pillows being extremely soft and uncomfortable, which detracted from the overall sleep experience for some guests.
Despite these occasional issues, the rooms themselves were generally considered very comfortable and the linens were noted to be of high quality. Nonetheless, the location of air conditioning units next to some beds was cited as a problem due to the noise affecting sleep.
Overall, while there are mixed experiences, many visitors to Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns can expect a comfortable bed and restful sleep.
Cleanliness
The cleanliness of Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns has received mixed reviews from guests. Positively, many travelers complimented the establishment for being a very clean property with well-maintained facilities. Numerous guests mentioned that the rooms and common areas were quite clean. Cleanliness of the grounds and overall property also received praise, highlighting a generally well-kept environment.
However, there were several concerns raised regarding the cleanliness of individual rooms and specific amenities. Some guests noted issues such as stained fabrics, sand and toenails on the floor and a lack of routine cleaning during their stays. Complaints also included housekeeping's failure to replace dirty glasses or towels and occasional mildew and musty odors. Maintenance issues in the bathrooms and outdated decor also contributed to the less favorable reviews.
In summary, while the Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns excels in maintaining a clean and beautiful property overall, attention to detail in room cleanliness and housekeeping services appears to be inconsistent, leaving some guests dissatisfied.
Staff
The Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns has received mixed reviews regarding its staff, but overall there have been many positive comments worth noting. Numerous guests have highlighted the friendly, helpful and accommodating nature of the staff. Specific individuals such as Michael at the bar, Sonja at breakfast and Laura at the front desk received high praise for their pleasant demeanor and exceptional service.
The welcoming nature of the staff is frequently mentioned with additional perks like welcome cocktails enhancing the guest experience. Several guests appreciated the fantastic and kind service provided by team members, making their stays memorable.
On the downside, some reviews did point out issues like unfriendliness, indifference and confusion among certain staff members. A few guests noted that while individual staff members were wonderful and helpful, there were instances where others could benefit from customer service training.
Nevertheless, the positive feedback, especially the consistent mentions of the staff’s accommodating and friendly attitude, provides a reassuring impression of the overall service at the Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns.
Pool
Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns features a pool that receives praise for being a pleasant spot amidst lush greenery and offering a private, inviting atmosphere. Some guests appreciated the convenience of having a pool and sundeck, along with poolside music during happy hour. The pool's location allows for a quiet retreat away from the busy surroundings. However, the pool is consistently noted as very small and some guests mentioned issues such as it needing updates, a lack of sun exposure and occasional cleanliness concerns. Towels at the poolside were often in short supply. Despite these drawbacks, many guests enjoyed the tranquil environment of the pool area and found it a nice addition to their stay.
3 Star
The Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns has received mixed feedback from guests, primarily focusing on its facilities and services. Positively noted is the hotel's ideal location, making it convenient for exploring Key West. However, many guests found the rooms to be quite small with difficulties fitting a king-size bed comfortably. The high cost of staying at this hotel was a recurring point with some describing it as massively overpriced and not offering value for money, particularly for short stays. Additionally, there were concerns regarding accessibility, as the hotel is not ADA-compliant. Overall, while the location is beneficial, guests felt that the price did not match the level of service and amenities provided.
FAQ
Yes, Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Heated Pool, Outdoor Pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns.
Yes, Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns welcomes dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns.
No, Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns doesn't have a gym.
