Melville Castle Hotel is a stunning retreat that offers a harmonious blend of historical charm and modern comforts, set in picturesque parklands close to Edinburgh. Guests are consistently impressed by the tranquil and beautiful grounds, complete with well-maintained gardens and scenic footpaths perfect for leisurely strolls. The hotel’s convenient proximity to Edinburgh and its transport links make it an ideal location for both relaxation and exploration of the Scottish capital, combining rural serenity with urban accessibility.
The hotel’s breakfast receives generally positive feedback with many guests praising the delicious, fresh and varied options available via both buffet and à la carte menus. The charming breakfast setting adds to the enjoyable start of the day for many guests, despite occasional issues with service organization and wait times. Dinner at the hotel's restaurant is similarly well-regarded for its exceptional food quality, elegant atmosphere and attentive service from staff members like Gill and Michelle, though some diners find the prices steep and service inconsistent at times.
Accommodations at Melville Castle are spacious, clean and elegantly decorated to maintain the historical ambiance of the property. Many rooms feature period-appropriate furniture, oversized beds and powerful showers, all contributing to a comfortable stay. Guests often appreciate the impressive views and unique features such as four-poster beds. While minor maintenance issues and occasional inconsistencies in cleanliness are noted, the overall room experience is overwhelmingly positive.
Staff at Melville Castle Hotel are frequently commended for their friendliness, professionalism and dedication to guest satisfaction. The team is described as welcoming and attentive with several staff members receiving specific praise for their exceptional service. While there are some instances of less efficient service, particularly at reception and during breakfast, the general consensus is that the staff significantly enhance the overall guest experience.
Regarding Wi-Fi, the connectivity is generally reliable and strong throughout the hotel, including public areas and some courtyard spots. The parking facilities are highly rated for their ample space, convenience and secure environment, adding to the stress-free experience for those traveling by car. The hotel is also noted for its family-friendly atmosphere, offering spacious accommodations and an enchanting environment that delights both children and adults. Outdoor enthusiasts and golf lovers will appreciate the expansive grounds for jogging and the nearby golf courses.
In summary, Melville Castle Hotel provides a luxurious, comfortable and fairy-tale-like stay that combines the best of Scotland’s natural beauty with the convenience of city proximity, backed by a welcoming staff and high-quality amenities.
Just 5 minutes from the Edinburgh city centre, James Thomson's Prestonfield House is Edinburgh's most exclusive luxury hotel, offering the privacy and seclusion of a country estate right in the heart of Edinburgh. Its ideal location right next to Arthur's Seat and its vast gardens transport guests back in time and make them feel like royalty. Each room is uniquely decorated with antique furniture and fully equipped with all the necessary amenities. Enjoy the luxurious experience Prestonfield House offers you.
Summary of reviews
Prestonfield House is a stunning and luxurious hotel located in a beautiful historic building close to Edinburgh City Center. Guests rave about the amazing location, which is both peaceful and accessible. The breakfast is a must-try with a fabulous selection of great food and excellent staff who remember dietary requirements. The dinner is also exceptional with first-class food and a brilliant wine selection. The sumptuous rooms are well dressed and immaculately clean, providing guests with a lovely stay. The staff is faultless, outstanding and couldn't do enough to help, making the stay special and unforgettable. The hotel is perfect for special celebrations and unforgettable experiences with luxury, peace and exceptional service. It's the epitome of luxury, comparable to 6 or 7-star hotels and perfect for a restful and luxurious honeymoon or a peaceful and relaxing getaway. The beautiful hotel is also perfect for any romantic stay with atmospheric furniture and lighting that make for a very relaxing stay. Overall, Prestonfield House is an exceptional and sensational five-star hotel that is definitely worth a visit.
'The Scott' hotel, located on the picturesque University of Edinburgh campus, provides travelers with a unique blend of comfort, convenience and charm, making it an ideal base for exploring Edinburgh. It boasts a prime position within walking distance of historic Old Town and Arthur's Seat, while still maintaining a serene ambiance away from the bustling city center. This setting, combined with excellent public transportation links, creates a tranquil retreat with easy access to key attractions. Guests appreciate the hotel's fairy-tale atmosphere, enhanced by its beautifully restored historic building and proximity to Holyrood Park and Pollock Halls.
The breakfast at The Scott is frequently praised for its quality, variety and the stylish dining room where it is served. Guests enjoy the hearty Full Scottish breakfast, both from a buffet and à la carte with attentive and friendly staff contributing to a pleasant dining experience. The experience is occasionally marred by minor criticisms, such as a lack of variety or pre-cooked hot food, but these issues are outweighed by the overall positive feedback.
Guests also commend the comfortable and stylishly renovated rooms, featuring modern amenities and tasteful decor. The spacious and clean interiors, combined with the cozy ambiance, provide a delightful stay. While some reviews mention small or cramped rooms, especially those with sloping ceilings, the clever design makes the most of the available space. The cleanliness of the hotel is consistently highlighted with spotless rooms and well-maintained common areas contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
The staff at The Scott earn high praise for their friendliness and helpfulness, creating a warm and accommodating environment. Guests appreciate the personal touch and exceptional service provided by the team, including the reception and breakfast staff. The free Wi-Fi, although generally satisfactory, has room for improvement in terms of connectivity and stability, particularly in certain rooms.
Parking options are convenient with free parking and electric vehicle charging stations available, although the limited number of spaces can be a challenge during busy periods. The beds receive enthusiastic approval for their exceptional comfort with high-quality bedding ensuring a restful sleep.
As a four-star hotel, The Scott meets expectations with its elegant decor, lovely public spaces and attention to detail. Its historic architecture, reminiscent of a castle, makes it a picturesque and calming environment that enhances the overall Edinburgh experience. Despite minor concerns like the occasional initial cold reception or the need to check in at a neighboring facility, the positives overshadow the negatives.
In summary, The Scott offers a luxurious and exquisite stay in Edinburgh, combining historic charm with modern comfort. The beautifully renovated rooms, excellent breakfast, friendly staff and serene location make it a standout choice for travelers seeking both relaxation and convenience in Scotland's capital.
**The Scholar** at the University of Edinburgh offers a serene and comfortable lodging experience, celebrated for its blend of tranquility and convenience. Nestled within the lush, green campus, it serves as an ideal retreat for nature lovers and those attending university events. Guests appreciate its proximity to iconic landmarks like Arthur's Seat and Holyrood Park, as well as the ease of accessing Edinburgh's city center through a pleasant walk or efficient public transport options. The hotel grounds, surrounded by well-maintained gardens and ample parking facilities, are noted as immaculate, further enhancing its appeal.
The breakfast experience at The Scholar earns high praise for its variety, quality and service. Guests delight in the comprehensive buffet and à la carte options with particular appreciation for the Scottish breakfast. The fresh selection of fruits, pastries, cheeses and hot dishes caters to diverse dietary preferences, making breakfast a highlight of many stays. Despite occasional minor delays with coffee service, the overall ambiance and value for money contribute to a highly recommended breakfast experience.
Dinner at The Scholar also receives generally positive feedback. Dishes are noted for their delicious taste and beautiful presentation, particularly steaks and sea bass. While the dog-friendly environment and friendly staff add to a positive dining experience, some guests mention slower service and limited menu options as areas for improvement. Nevertheless, the bistro atmosphere and the overall quality of the food make it a delightful experience.
The rooms at The Scholar are another strong point, frequently described as spacious, clean and comfortable. Guests appreciate the modern amenities, including large smart TVs and luxurious teas. The cleanliness and thoughtful room design contribute to a pleasant and luxurious stay, despite occasional mentions of smaller rooms. The general consensus highlights the rooms' comfort and modernity, ensuring a satisfying experience.
Cleanliness is a standout feature at The Scholar with guests consistently praising the spotless and well-maintained environment. This attention to cleanliness is evident throughout the hotel, reinforcing its reputation as a top choice for travelers prioritizing hygiene.
The staff receives glowing reviews for their friendliness, professionalism and willingness to assist. Guests often highlight the super-friendly and efficient staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The positive interactions with the staff, from the reception to the dining areas, contribute significantly to the hotel's warm and welcoming atmosphere.
WiFi experiences at The Scholar vary with many guests enjoying fast and reliable connections, though some encounter issues with connectivity and setup. The hotel's prompt resolution of problems is appreciated, but there remains room for improvement to ensure consistent service across all areas.
Parking at The Scholar is generally hassle-free and seen as a significant advantage, especially given Edinburgh's usual challenges with parking spaces. The availability of free on-site and nearby parking, along with features like electric vehicle charging stations, adds to the hotel's appeal.
For families, The Scholar offers a welcoming environment with amenities that cater to both children and pets. Despite some mentions of smaller room sizes, the overall family-friendly atmosphere and thoughtful services make it a highly recommended option for family stays.
In summary, The Scholar is celebrated for its serene location, excellent breakfast offerings, comfortable rooms and attentive staff. The minor criticisms are overshadowed by the overwhelmingly positive feedback, making it a standout choice for those visiting Edinburgh whether for leisure, academic or family travel.
Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh – Royal Mile by IHG, excels in its prime location, central to Edinburgh’s key attractions, including Edinburgh Castle and the Royal Mile. Nestled quietly in the old town yet conveniently close to vibrant restaurants, shops and historical sites, it provides an ideal base for exploring the city. Proximity to Waverley Train Station and available parking further enhance its appeal, making it a top choice for both walking tours and travelers with cars.
The breakfast experience is generally favorable, featuring a good variety of hot and cold items, including gluten-free options. While some guests find it basic yet adequate, others appreciate the plentiful and fresh food offerings. The COVID-19 restrictions prompted a shift to grab-and-go breakfast bags, which received mixed reactions but were appreciated by some for their convenience.
Guest feedback on the rooms is varied. Despite their small size, rooms are noted for their cleanliness and comfort, equipped with necessary amenities and effective air conditioning. However, space constraints become apparent when accommodating families or when sofa beds are in use, leading to a cramped environment. Some rooms could benefit from better lighting and updating. Challenges aside, the rooms are generally well-maintained, ensuring a satisfactory stay.
Cleanliness is a consistent highlight with the hotel and its rooms described as very clean. Daily housekeeping ensures a tidy environment and contributes significantly to a positive guest experience.
The staff at Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh – Royal Mile receive high praise for their friendliness and professionalism. Notable mentions of specific staff members underscore the hotel's commitment to guest satisfaction with efficient and courteous service enhancing the overall stay. The availability of early morning to-go breakfasts and help with specific needs further attest to the staff’s attentive care.
Wi-Fi connectivity presents a mixed experience. While many guests find the free Wi-Fi to be fast and reliable, issues with unstable and patchy connections are sometimes reported. This inconsistency suggests room for improvement in the hotel's internet services.
For families, the hotel’s central location and welcoming staff are plus points, though the family rooms can feel somewhat congested. Space limitations are more manageable for brief stays, especially for families with young children. Services like free baby cots add to the hotel’s family-friendly appeal.
The beds evoke mixed feedback with primary beds generally deemed comfortable but supplementary beds, such as sofa beds, often found to be lacking in comfort. Ensuring the right bed type in advance could enhance the sleep quality experience.
As a three-star hotel, Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh – Royal Mile offers excellent value for money with clean, comfortable rooms that are well-maintained except for some areas needing attention like corridor carpets. The breakfast aligns with three-star expectations and the hotel's strategic location enhances its appeal for budget-conscious travelers. Some guests even suggest the hotel exceeds typical three-star standards, potentially earning a higher rating.
For business travelers, the hotel provides adequate basic facilities, making it a suitable option for short stays. However, a few limitations such as the lack of conference rooms and occasional issues with business invoices should be noted.
Overall, the Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh – Royal Mile is a highly recommended option for travelers seeking affordability, cleanliness, excellent service and a central location in Edinburgh. While there are minor areas for improvement, the hotel generally ensures a pleasant and convenient stay.
The Stair Arms Hotel receives glowing reviews for its idyllic location, offering a perfect blend of accessibility and countryside tranquility. Situated near Edinburgh, it provides an ideal base for city exploration or serene country walks, with easy access from major roads and proximity to local attractions like the Glenkinchie distillery.
Guests frequently praise the hotel’s dining offerings, highlighting the exceptional breakfast and dinner experiences. The traditional English breakfast is lauded for its delicious taste and warm service, while dinner impresses with high-quality ingredients and skillful preparation. Although the breakfast menu might benefit from more variety, its overall quality and presentation earn positive feedback.
The hotel's rooms are appreciated for their spaciousness and modern decor, contributing to a comfortable and inviting stay. Recent refurbishments showcase stylish interiors and ensure restful nights with superbly comfortable beds. Cleanliness is noted across much of the hotel, although there are occasional mentions of areas needing improvement.
The staff at The Stair Arms Hotel are commendably friendly and attentive, consistently enhancing guests' experiences with their courteous service and local knowledge. Their professionalism and welcoming demeanor contribute significantly to the hotel's warm atmosphere.
The hotel is also celebrated for its dog-friendly accommodations, welcoming pets with dedicated facilities and beautiful grounds for walks. This feature, combined with excellent dining and cozy rooms, makes it a top choice for travelers with furry companions.
Overall, The Stair Arms Hotel offers a charming stay with its pleasant location, impressive dining, and exceptional hospitality, making it a favored destination for both leisure travelers and pet owners.
The Doubletree by Hilton Edinburgh City Centre is a fantastic hotel for anyone looking to explore Edinburgh. The location is excellent with many major attractions just a short walk away and surrounded by local shops, pubs and restaurants. Guests have mixed opinions of the breakfast, but it seems to be satisfactory for most. The rooms are spacious, clean and comfortable with excellent beds and well-maintained furnishings. The staff is exceptional, consistently receiving high praise for their welcoming, friendly and accommodating demeanor. The hotel is also very clean with mostly spotless rooms and well-furnished bathrooms. Overall, the Doubletree by Hilton Edinburgh City Centre is a lovely and enjoyable place to stay with fantastic facilities and an excellent location.
The The Caledonian Edinburgh, Curio Collection by Hilton is a luxurious and historic hotel with an unbeatable location in the heart of Edinburgh. Guests rave about the excellent breakfast options and exceptional staff who go above and beyond to make their stay special. The rooms are generally clean and comfortable, although some may be small or outdated. The spa facilities are fantastic, but some guests were disappointed by closures or maintenance issues. The hotel offers good parking facilities, but some guests noted the lack of assistance with luggage transport. Overall, the The Caledonian Edinburgh, Curio Collection by Hilton is a true 5-star hotel that provides an unforgettable experience within a beautiful and historic setting.
The Guards Hotel enjoys a prime location directly across from Haymarket Station, providing excellent access to trains, trams and buses, facilitating easy travel within Edinburgh and to the airport. Guests appreciate its proximity to attractions such as Princes Street and Edinburgh Castle, complemented by nearby dining and shopping options.
Room experiences vary significantly. Positive reviews highlight clean, spacious rooms—especially larger suites with ensuite bathrooms and antique furniture—equipped with amenities like tea and coffee facilities, hairdryers and TVs. However, the hotel struggles with inconsistent room quality with some guests reporting dated decor, maintenance issues and cleanliness concerns. While some rooms are quiet and comfortable, others suffer from inadequate heating and unpleasant odors, necessitating upgrades and more consistent housekeeping.
Cleanliness is another area of mixed reviews. Some guests find the rooms very clean and comfortable, while others cite issues like dust, dirty carpets, mold and neglected details. Despite these challenges, the linens and towels are noted to be clean. The building itself needs refurbishment to meet higher cleanliness standards.
Staff at The Guards Hotel consistently receive praise for their friendliness, helpfulness and accommodating nature. The owner and reception staff are particularly noted for their warm and engaging service, making the check-in process smooth and efficient. However, the lack of 24/7 reception can cause inconvenience when trying to reach staff during off-hours.
The Wi-Fi service is generally perceived as problematic with many guests experiencing weak signals, especially on the top floors. While some manage to get a decent connection, many report difficulties logging on or staying connected, indicating a need for improvement in this area.
For families, the hotel offers large family rooms with cribs, highchairs and sofabeds, making it suitable for those traveling with children. However, space may be limited for larger families. Ground-floor rooms offer added comfort and accessibility.
Bed quality receives mixed feedback. Many guests find the beds comfortable with clean linens and cozy quilts. However, a number of reviews mention old, saggy mattresses, broken frames and even insect bites, pointing towards the need for better bed maintenance and upgrades.
As a three-star hotel, The Guards Hotel offers basic, budget-friendly accommodations that reflect its rating. It is especially suitable for short stays focused on affordability and central location, though some guests note the need for refurbishment and improved cleanliness. The hotel provides functional and economical lodging for budget-conscious travelers.
Accessibility features include disabled-friendly rooms and convenient access from the airport, but the lack of elevators and drainage issues in some bathrooms can pose challenges for disabled and elderly guests.
In summary, The Guards Hotel provides a decent stay with significant room for improvement in consistency, cleanliness and Wi-Fi reliability, balanced by its excellent location, friendly staff and budget-friendly rates.
Operating as a hotel since 1881, Principal Edinburgh George Street is one of the most lavish hotels in the Scottish capital. The hotel's rooms and suites are not only luxurious and comfortable, but they also reflect the rich Scottish heritage through their colour palette and decorations, becoming an ode to this beautiful country. Guests may also indulge in the unique and gourmet tastes of the hotel's famous restaurant, The Printing Press, or drink a delicious cup of coffee in the company of a good book in the hotel's renowned coffee shop. Whatever they choose, it is certain that this hotel will leave a lasting impression and make everyone's stay in Edinburgh unforgettable.
Summary of reviews
InterContinental Edinburgh The George by IHG is a luxurious 5-star hotel located in the heart of Edinburgh, making it an ideal location for tourists and business travelers alike. The hotel offers high-end accommodations that are tastefully decorated and very relaxed with spacious and clean rooms that are well-maintained. Guests have praised the hotel's cleanliness and housekeeping, as well as the exceptional and attentive staff who provide excellent customer service. The hotel's breakfast buffet offers an extensive and delicious selection of hot and cold options, although some guests have noted the lack of vegetarian and gluten-free options. The hotel's central location is perfect for accessing all the main tourist points on foot and is near many key attractions such as Holyrood Palace, Rose Street bars and the St James Quarter shops. Overall, guests have described the hotel as exceptional, superb and truly special, making it a first-class destination for travelers seeking a luxurious stay in Edinburgh.
Overall, guests have had a fantastic stay at ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square. The hotel's central location makes it easily accessible to all the city's attractions and the staff is happy to help with anything guests need. Breakfast is a highlight with plenty of delicious options available and guests particularly appreciate the sustainability efforts. Rooms are clean and modern with some even offering lovely views of the city and the beds are super comfortable. The staff is exceptionally friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable, going above and beyond to make guests feel welcome and comfortable. Despite some minor criticisms, this hotel is a fantastic option for anyone looking for a budget-friendly stay in a stylish and conveniently located hotel.
Located in the idyllic New Town of Edinburgh, Kimpton Charlotte Square Hotel is a luxurious hotel housed in a Georgian style building and it offers the most lavish and comfortable accommodation to all guests. Every room and suite is elegantly appointed and spacious, providing guests not only with the necessary amenities but also with luxurious and thoughtful details that will make their stay special. The hotel also boasts a rejuvenating spa where guests can relax, a private garden where they can enjoy a refreshing drink or a delicious meal, a well-equipped gym and an absolutely dreamy location for the most memorable wedding.
Summary of reviews
Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG is a luxurious five-star hotel located in the heart of Edinburgh with exceptional facilities and exemplary staff. Guests love the hotel's central location, making it convenient for exploring the city's major attractions. The rooms are well-designed, furnished and spotlessly clean with comfortable beds and thoughtful touches. The breakfast area provides a cozy atmosphere, although some guests had mixed views about their breakfast experience. The spa, pool and gym facilities were praised by guests, but some noted that it could be bigger. The hotel's valet parking services are convenient but come at an extra cost. Overall, Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG is a superb choice for those looking for a luxurious experience and unmatched location in Edinburgh.