Info
Summary of reviewsThe Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection is highly regarded for its strategic suburban location, providing easy access to Edinburgh via quick routes and efficient public transport, while offering a tranquil, scenic environment close to local amenities. The hotel’s modern and comfortably soundproofed accommodations are particularly suited for events, family visits and local attractions like Dalhousie Castle and Rosslyn Chapel, making it an excellent base for exploring the area.
One of the hotel’s standout features is its breakfast, frequently lauded for its excellence, variety, generous portions and accommodating staff. Guests enjoy a wide range of fresh, well-cooked options in a welcoming atmosphere. Though some suggest improvements in service speed and dining area brightness, the breakfast experience remains a significant highlight.
Dining at the adjacent Melville Inn is another point of praise. Guests appreciate the high-quality, flavorful food in a cozy and quiet restaurant setting. The staff’s friendliness and efficiency further enhance the dining experience. Although there are occasional logistical challenges, such as restricted hours and the need for reservations, the positive dining reviews emphasize the excellent food and inviting ambiance.
The rooms at The Melville Inn are consistently described as clean, modern and comfortable. Guests value the spaciousness and contemporary decor, while the well-maintained bathrooms and comfortable beds contribute to a restful stay. Despite minor issues like poor ventilation, the overwhelmingly positive feedback on room cleanliness and comfort reinforces the hotel’s appeal.
Cleanliness throughout the hotel is a strong point with guests frequently mentioning the spotless and well-maintained facilities. The hotel’s commitment to maintaining a high standard of hygiene contributes significantly to the pleasant atmosphere.
The staff at The Melville Inn receive high accolades for their friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism. Guests appreciate the warm welcome and attentive service from both the reception and restaurant teams, which considerably enhances the overall guest experience.
On the downside, Wi-Fi connectivity is an area needing improvement. Many guests report slow speeds, inconsistent connections and poor signal strength, which diminishes the convenience for those requiring reliable internet access.
The ample, free parking is another positive aspect with guests praising the ease and convenience of the spacious and readily available parking facilities.
For families, The Melville Inn is an excellent option. The spacious family rooms and attentive staff ensure a comfortable stay for guests of all ages. The hotel's proximity to local attractions and family-friendly amenities make it a preferred choice for family trips and gatherings.
Golf enthusiasts also favor the hotel for its proximity to various quality golf courses, offering excellent value and convenience for golf trips.
In summary, The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection excels in location, dining, cleanliness, staff service and family-friendly accommodations. While its Wi-Fi service needs enhancement, the overall experience remains highly positive, making it a recommended choice for visitors to Edinburgh and its surroundings.
Show moreRead review summaries for all categories
Categories
