Portree, the rosedale hotel beaumont57.412071,-6.192193(Show on Map)
8.0
Very Good
+5 Photos
+5 Photos
+ 3 Photos3
Checkin - Checkout datesTue, 11 Aug - Wed, 12 Aug11 Aug - 12 Aug
1 Room2 Guests
Info
Summary of reviews
The Rosedale Hotel in Portree, Isle of Skye, consistently delights guests with its remarkable waterfront location, offering breathtaking harbor views from both rooms and dining areas. This prime spot is perfect for exploring the town and its vibrant attractions, making it a top choice for visitors seeking convenience and scenic beauty.
The hotel's breakfast is widely praised for its delicious and varied menu, including dishes like Eggs Benedict and a hearty full Scottish breakfast, served in a room with stunning harbor views. The dinner experience is equally celebrated, known for high-quality cuisine, fine dining standards and notable dishes such as superb risotto and acclaimed sticky toffee pudding. Guests suggest making dinner reservations well in advance due to the restaurant's popularity.
Guest rooms are described as spacious, clean and comfortable with modern bathrooms and cozy accommodations adding to the pleasant stay. However, some guests note variance in room experience with a few mentioning small, dated rooms, heating issues and obstructed views. Cleanliness generally receives high marks, though occasional lapses in room maintenance and dated decor are noted.
The staff at The Rosedale Hotel earn high praise for their friendliness, attentiveness and professionalism, significantly enhancing the overall guest experience. Many reviews spotlight the staff's commitment to going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay.
For families, feedback is mixed. While the hotel’s location and room sizes are appreciated, the lack of dedicated family activities and occasional service hiccups have been points of concern. Beds are mostly deemed comfortable, though some guests encounter issues with bed size and mattress quality.
Overall, the hotel meets expectations for a three-star establishment with its location and character standing out as key advantages. While it fulfills the basics well, ongoing renovations and attention to detail in room updates could elevate the guest experience further. Despite minor shortcomings, The Rosedale Hotel offers a charming and satisfying stay, especially for those captivated by scenic harbor views and quality dining.
Categories
Small
This family-run hotel is located on Portree harbor. Originally formed from 3 fisherman's houses, it is now a unique hotel with an abundance of character. The majority of the rooms enjoy picturesque views of Portree bay and it has an award winning restaurant.
Family
3 Star
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Room Types
Double Room with Sea ViewOffering free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room offers a seating area, a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a flat-screen TV with streaming services, as well as sea views. The unit offers 1 bed.
Standard Twin Room with Partial Sea ViewFeaturing free toiletries, this twin room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The twin room features a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a carpeted floor, heating, as well as a flat-screen TV with streaming services. The unit has 2 beds.
Standard Double RoomFeaturing free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room features a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a carpeted floor, heating, as well as a flat-screen TV with streaming services. The unit has 1 bed.
Standard Family RoomOffering free toiletries, this family room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The family room has carpeted floors, a seating area with a flat-screen TV with streaming services, a wardrobe, an electric kettle, as well as a sofa. The unit has 3 beds.
Large Double Room with Sea ViewOffering free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room offers a flat-screen TV with streaming services, a seating area, a wardrobe, an electric kettle as well as sea views. The unit has 1 bed.
Large Double RoomProviding free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room features carpeted floors, a seating area with a flat-screen TV with streaming services, a wardrobe, an electric kettle, as well as heating. The unit offers 1 bed.
Double or Twin Room with Sea ViewProviding free toiletries, this twin/double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The twin/double room provides a seating area, a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a flat-screen TV with streaming services, as well as sea views.
Large Double Room with Partial Sea ViewFeaturing free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room features a seating area, an electric kettle, a carpeted floor, heating, as well as a flat-screen TV with streaming services. The unit has 1 bed.
Standard Double Room with Partial Sea ViewFeaturing free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. The double room features a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a carpeted floor, heating, as well as a flat-screen TV with streaming services. The unit has 1 bed.
Standard Double Room with Sea ViewProviding free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a bath and a hairdryer. The double room provides a wardrobe, an electric kettle, a carpeted floor, a flat-screen TV with streaming services, as well as sea views. The unit offers 1 bed.
Guest Reviews
8.0
Very Good
Review Summaries
Location
The Rosedale Hotel boasts an incredible location that consistently delights its guests. Nestled right on the waterfront in Portree, it offers spectacular views of the harbor and bay, making it a prime spot for scenic enjoyment. The hotel's central position provides convenient access to numerous restaurants, attractions and the town's charming, colorful houses. Many reviews highlight its ideal location for exploring the Isle of Skye, emphasizing ease of walking to nearby amenities and the bus station. Guests frequently commend the lovely and breathtaking harbor views from their rooms and the dining area, appreciating the picturesque setting. The accommodation is known for its cozy and comfortable ambiance and the perfect and quiet setting adds to the overall appeal. Overall, The Rosedale Hotel’s unparalleled harborfront location is its standout feature, making it a top choice for visitors seeking beautiful views and convenience in Portree.
Breakfast
'The Rosedale Hotel' receives high praise for its breakfast offerings with many guests calling it delicious, excellent and even amazing. The breakfast menu is described as extensive, varied and high-quality, featuring options like Eggs Benedict and freshly cooked hot dishes, including a full Scottish breakfast. Guests appreciated the generous portions and taste, often noting that the included breakfast was a pleasant surprise.
While most reviews were positive about the quality and variety, highlighting friendly staff and great service, some mentioned issues with slow service and the occasional overcooked dish, such as poached eggs or black pudding. Despite a few complaints about service speed and scheduling, the overall sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive with many suggesting that the breakfast alone is worth the stay. The breakfast room's breathtaking views over the harbour also enhance the dining experience, making it highly recommended by guests who have visited.
Dinner
The Rosedale Hotel consistently receives high praise for its dining experiences. Diners frequently commend the quality of the food, highlighting it as top-notch and describing the meals as delicious, fresh and superb. The restaurant offers an exquisite dining experience with comments noting fine dining standards, excellent portions and a very high standard of cuisine.
Several reviews emphasize the need to make dinner reservations in advance due to the restaurant's popularity, a testament to its esteemed reputation. The menu, albeit noted by some as limited, is lauded for the quality and taste of its offerings, featuring standout dishes such as a perfect risotto and the best sticky toffee pudding in the world.
The setting of the restaurant garners praise for its cozy atmosphere and great views over the harbor, adding to the overall dining appeal. Guests also report positive interactions with the attentive and efficient staff, which contributes to the fantastic dining experience.
While there were a few critiques, such as occasional delays and a steak not cooked to specification, the overwhelming feedback celebrates the restaurant as a highlight of The Rosedale Hotel. Highly recommended by both residents and even local eateries, the restaurant stands out for its gourmet food and the wonderful dining experiences it provides.
Rooms
The guest reviews for The Rosedale Hotel paint a diverse picture of the room experiences. Positively, many guests appreciated the spacious and clean rooms, often highlighting the stunning views of the bay, harbor or lake. These scenic vistas were a significant highlight for several visitors. The modern bathrooms, when available, were well-received, particularly those with large bathtubs and modern showers.
Comfort was a recurring theme with numerous mentions of clean and cozy accommodations. Some rooms were newly renovated, offering a fresher feel. The hotel's cleaning standards seemed generally high, as many reviews noted the rooms were kept spotless.
On the downside, some guests found the rooms to be small, dated and in need of renovation. Issues with heating and musty smells were also pointed out. There were occasional bursts of discomfort caused by old mattresses and limited storage space. The lack of an elevator posed challenges for those with mobility issues and the views from some rooms were not as expected, being obstructed or facing car parks instead of the sea.
Overall, while the rooms offered beautiful views and a reasonable level of comfort, consistency seemed to be an area needing improvement. Guests desiring a more up-to-date and spacious environment may find certain aspects lacking, although the positive feedback on cleanliness and scenic overlooks suggests a worthwhile stay for casual travelers.
Beds
The beds at The Rosedale Hotel have garnered a range of responses from guests, predominantly leaning towards the positive. Many visitors praise the beds for being extremely comfortable and ensuring a good night's sleep. The terms comfortable and comfy are frequently used, indicating that the hotel has largely met expectations in providing restful and cozy bedding.
The bedding itself, described as soft, clean and plush, contributes significantly to the overall comfort. Guests have appreciated the spacious and clean rooms, which further enhance the sleeping experience. The general consensus suggests that the hotel's beds are of good size with some specifically mentioning king beds and the arrangement of beds being good.
However, a few reviews highlight some issues with bed sizes and quality, such as small or narrow beds that disrupted sleep and outdated or lumpy mattresses. Some guests felt the beds were too soft, others too firm and a few noted the presence of squeaky or old mattresses. There were occasional mentions of bed discomfort due to these issues.
Overall, despite some minor complaints, the majority of guests have found the beds to be comfortable and satisfactory. The recurring theme of comfortable bedding and a cozy room environment suggests that The Rosedale Hotel generally provides a pleasant stay for its guests.
Cleanliness
The Rosedale Hotel generally receives positive feedback for its cleanliness with many guests praising the clean, comfortable rooms and spotless facilities. The bedding, bathrooms and overall rooms often meet high cleanliness standards, described as spick-and-span, immaculate and sparkling clean. Reviewers frequently commend the hotel's clean, well-furnished rooms and the comfortable, cosy decor contributes to a pleasant stay.
However, there are also notable concerns that appear in multiple reviews. Some guests mentioned that certain rooms were not adequately cleaned, featuring dirty carpets, cobwebs and dust. Hallways and corridors occasionally suffer from unpleasant odors and stained carpets. Maintenance issues like chipped paintwork, non-functional heaters and ventilation problems also detract from the experience for some visitors.
While many areas of the hotel are kept clean and well-maintained, some aspects like ongoing renovations and dated decor indicate a need for improved attention to detail and better upkeep. Overall, the Rosedale Hotel & Restaurant manages to offer clean, comfortable accommodations for most guests, but future visitors should be aware of occasional lapses in cleanliness and the need for updates to some facilities.
Staff
The Rosedale Hotel boasts a commendable reputation for its exceptional staff. Guests frequently praise the team for their friendliness, attentiveness and helpfulness throughout their stay. The staff's welcoming nature and professional demeanor leave a lasting impression with many noting their politeness and willingness to go the extra mile to ensure guest satisfaction. Despite occasional inconsistencies and a few mentions of inefficiency or miscommunication, the overall perception of the staff remains overwhelmingly positive. Words like "fantastic," "superb," and "amazing" are frequently used to describe the staff's efforts, contributing significantly to the hotel's overall appeal. Additionally, personal interactions with staff members are highlighted as moments of genuine connection and service excellence. The dedicated team at The Rosedale appears to consistently enhance the guest experience, compensating for any minor shortcomings and maintaining a high standard of hospitality.
Family
The Rosedale Hotel receives mixed feedback regarding activities for kids and overall family experience. The positive highlights indicate that the establishment is ideal for family tours and is strategically located, making it family-friendly. Many guests noted the accommodating nature and size of the family rooms with phrases such as enormous and one of the bigger family rooms reinforcing this. Families were generally happy with the room conditions and clean linens and the staff were described as giving ample effort to accommodate guests.
However, there were chronic issues highlighted in multiple reviews. Some guests found a lack of family activities and noted the absence of family related notes or a dedicated family room. Additionally, several reviews emphasized a disappointing experience, where overall expectations weren't met and complaints weren't adequately addressed. Issues such as missed items and insufficient attention to details contributed to a rather stressful stay for some families. Despite the efforts to be family-friendly, the overall sentiment suggests a need for improvements in meeting family needs consistently.
3 Star
The Rosedale Hotel is often described as meeting the typical three-star standard. While it does fulfill expectations for a three-star hotel, some guests note the property appears slightly aged and in need of renovation. The décor and bathrooms are dated, though updates are reportedly planned soon.
Guests appreciate its great location, which is considered one of its best features. As a typical Scottish hotel, it offers a basic yet clean environment. However, the rooms and facilities, including limited room service, are seen as quite basic. Additionally, the food and drinks are deemed overpriced relative to the hotel’s three-star categorization.
Service quality is generally seen as good, aligning well with its three-star rating. Though some suggest that the hotel sometimes doesn't quite measure up to three stars, it strives to offer a satisfactory experience. Overall, The Rosedale Hotel is perceived as a solid three-star hotel that could benefit from modernization.
FAQ
No, The Rosedale Hotel doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at The Rosedale Hotel.
Yes, The Rosedale Hotel welcomes dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at The Rosedale Hotel.
