The Lodge at Leathem Smith
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsThe Lodge at Leathem Smith excels in offering guests an inviting and memorable experience thanks to its scenic location, exemplary staff, and standout dining options. Nestled in a prime setting in Door County, the lodge provides breathtaking lakeside views and a cozy atmosphere, making it a preferred base for exploring the area. Its proximity to downtown Sturgeon Bay and local attractions, including a vibrant outdoor tiki bar, enhances the appeal for those seeking a lively yet peaceful getaway.
Guests often highlight the lodge's breakfast offerings, with particular emphasis on the delicious made-to-order omelet station, praised for its quality and the hospitality of the chef. The dinner experience is equally impressive, with the on-site restaurant and bar offering flavorful options like seared tuna and pizzas, all complemented by friendly staff and stunning views of Sturgeon Bay.
Staff members are recognized for their friendly and welcoming demeanor, consistently enhancing the guest experience through attentive service. Specific individuals such as Leslie, Milan, and Paul, the owner, receive commendations for their dedication and warmth, creating a pleasant atmosphere across the lodge.
Despite the positive aspects, there are areas needing improvement. The rooms, while spacious and comfortable, show signs of wear and require updates to ensure modern amenities and consistent cleanliness. Maintenance issues, notably in bathrooms and the pool area, have been noted, with the pool often unavailable or lacking adequate upkeep.
Parking can be challenging at times, particularly during busy periods, but generally sufficient with added convenience for boating guests. The beds garner mixed reviews; many guests enjoy their firmness and comfort, while others point out inconsistencies in bed quality requiring attention.
Overall, The Lodge at Leathem Smith shines through its exemplary location, superb dining experiences, and remarkable staff, offering good value despite certain areas needing refurbishment. With thoughtful updates, the lodge could significantly enhance its appeal, maintaining its charm and ensuring a consistently enjoyable stay for all guests.
Categories
Guests often highlight the lodge's breakfast offerings, with particular emphasis on the delicious made-to-order omelet station, praised for its quality and the hospitality of the chef. The dinner experience is equally impressive, with the on-site restaurant and bar offering flavorful options like seared tuna and pizzas, all complemented by friendly staff and stunning views of Sturgeon Bay.
Staff members are recognized for their friendly and welcoming demeanor, consistently enhancing the guest experience through attentive service. Specific individuals such as Leslie, Milan, and Paul, the owner, receive commendations for their dedication and warmth, creating a pleasant atmosphere across the lodge.
Despite the positive aspects, there are areas needing improvement. The rooms, while spacious and comfortable, show signs of wear and require updates to ensure modern amenities and consistent cleanliness. Maintenance issues, notably in bathrooms and the pool area, have been noted, with the pool often unavailable or lacking adequate upkeep.
Parking can be challenging at times, particularly during busy periods, but generally sufficient with added convenience for boating guests. The beds garner mixed reviews; many guests enjoy their firmness and comfort, while others point out inconsistencies in bed quality requiring attention.
Overall, The Lodge at Leathem Smith shines through its exemplary location, superb dining experiences, and remarkable staff, offering good value despite certain areas needing refurbishment. With thoughtful updates, the lodge could significantly enhance its appeal, maintaining its charm and ensuring a consistently enjoyable stay for all guests.
Luxury Resort
Located in Sturgeon Bay, The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a luxurious waterfront experience. With its scenic views, comfortable rooms, and upscale amenities, it's a great choice for a relaxing getaway.
Family Friendly Resort
As a lodge, it offers a rustic and comfortable setting. It allows families to enjoy a relaxed vacation.
Resort with Parking
This lodge provides parking for guests. It's a practical choice for visitors looking for accommodation with parking.
Accessible Resort
This lodge is listed as being wheelchair accessible, providing access for guests with mobility needs.
4-Star Resort
This 4-star resort features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a shared lounge, and a terrace. It offers a restaurant, a bar, and free WiFi. The hotel is non-smoking and is set 3 km from Door County Maritime Museum.
Resort for Honeymoon
Dog Friendly Resort
Romantic Resort
Resort with Swimming Pool
Outdoor Pool
Resort with Outdoor Pool
Guest Reviews
Nestled in a prime setting, The Lodge at Leathem Smith stands out for its excellent location in Door County. Guests are enchanted by its beautiful lakeside views and the property's proximity to the water. Situated just across the street from the bay, the lodge offers breathtaking vistas, particularly during sunsets. The cozy atmosphere provides a perfect escape while remaining conveniently close to downtown Sturgeon Bay and Highway 42, making it a superb base for exploring all that the region has to offer. The grounds themselves are charming, offering a peaceful environment for walks amongst the trees with easy access to the harbor area, shops, and restaurants. The tiki outdoor bar adds to the vibrancy of the setting, with food, drinks, and live music enhancing the overall experience. For visitors eager to be near the water, the lodge's location is ideal with a boat ramp nearby and the marina within sight. The hotel not only boasts a prime spot along the river but also offers convenient outdoor facilities, all while providing a superb value considering its facilities and welcoming staff.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a complimentary breakfast that consistently pleases its guests, especially those with a penchant for omelets. The standout feature of the breakfast service is the made-to-order omelet station, often praised for its delicious offerings and the hospitality of the chef, who is described as friendly and attentive. Many guests find the breakfast to be a highlight of their stay, appreciating the quality of the omelets and considering them a great way to start the day. Despite some variability in the availability and variety of food items, the freshly prepared omelets frequently receive high marks, enhancing the overall dining experience. While not overly extensive, the breakfast menu is generally well-received, with the hotel's restaurant staff noted for their helpful and warm demeanor. Located conveniently on the water, the Lodge provides a delightful setting for guests to enjoy their morning meal.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a delightful dining experience that has left many guests impressed. The on-site restaurant and bar, particularly known for its tiki bar and lively music, provide a vibrant atmosphere for an enjoyable evening. Diners frequently praise the food at Kona Bay, highlighting the excellent quality of offerings such as the seared tuna, pizza, and quesadillas. Guests appreciate the great value, with special mentions of delicious half-price appetizers. The restaurant's menu receives acclaim for both its variety and the friendliness of the staff, enhancing the overall dining experience. With a stunning view of Sturgeon Bay from the patio, the ambiance is elevated, making meals at the lodge memorable. Despite some noting that supper could be on the pricey side for its quality, the combination of good food and exceptional service makes dining at The Lodge a worthwhile experience.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith has received a mixed set of reviews regarding its rooms, offering a blend of spaciousness and comfort along with some maintenance issues. Many guests appreciate the generous size of the rooms, noting them as large, comfortable, and well-equipped. The beds in several rooms have been described as cozy and offering a good night's rest, while some rooms are furnished with appealing features like jacuzzi tubs. The overall cleanliness of the rooms is highlighted by some visitors, and this contributes to a generally pleasant stay despite the lodge's age.
However, the rooms show signs of wear and tear, with frequent calls for remodeling and updating of furnishings and amenities. Bathrooms, in particular, seem in need of significant refurbishment, with guests reporting signs of mold, rust stains, and unpleasant odors. Some rooms have a musty smell and inadequate amenities like old towels and a lack of electrical outlets, while issues with heating and noisy air conditioning have also been noted.
The charm and character of the lodge, given its century-long history, are recognized by several visitors, who feel the lodge could benefit from some modernization without losing its unique atmosphere. Despite its drawbacks, the lodge serves as a functional base for exploring Door County, with travelers finding value in its spacious accommodations for short stays, though some find the overall experience overpriced given the condition of the property.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a mixed experience when it comes to sleeping comfort, with many guests highlighting the beds as a notable positive aspect of their stay. Numerous reviews praise the comfort level of the beds, often mentioning how comfortable and firm they found both the beds and pillows. For many guests, the beds were so comfortable that they stood out as a highlight of their visit, contributing to a restful night's sleep in spacious rooms. However, some guests noted inconsistencies, describing certain beds as dated, too soft, or sagging in the middle, with thin bedding and old pillows detracting from the overall comfort. While many have enjoyed a peaceful slumber on the lodge's beds, a few have encountered issues that suggest a need for updates to ensure a consistently pleasant sleep experience.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a mixed experience when it comes to cleanliness, with opinions ranging broadly across guest reviews. Many guests commend the establishment for its clean and attractive rooms, highlighting their satisfaction with the general upkeep and daily cleaning of accommodations. There are frequent mentions of cleanliness in specific rooms, praising them for being very clean and comfortable.
However, the hotel shows signs of wear and tear, indicating a need for maintenance and more thorough cleaning in some areas. Issues such as rust stains in bathrooms, dirty patio furniture, and grime on glass patio doors detract from its overall appeal. Some guests have encountered problems with dusty surfaces, cobwebs, stained sheets, and floors in need of cleaning, highlighting inconsistencies in the hotel's cleaning standards.
Certain sections of the property, including bathrooms and exterior areas, are in need of significant updating to improve the overall look and feel. Despite these challenges, the friendly staff receives positive mentions, contributing positively to the guest experience. Overall, while there are notable highlights regarding cleanliness, increased attention to detail in maintenance could enhance the guest experience at The Lodge at Leathem Smith.
Nestled in scenic surroundings, The Lodge at Leathem Smith boasts a team that leaves a memorable impression on its guests thanks to their remarkable service. The friendly and welcoming nature of the staff stands out as one of the highlights of the lodge experience. Guests are greeted with warmth, with staff consistently checking in on their needs and ensuring their comfort. The hotel's front desk and general service staff often receive compliments for their helpfulness and approachability, creating a pleasant atmosphere for all visitors.
Despite occasional lapses in organization during peak times, particularly at the restaurant and bar, the staff’s accommodating nature doesn't go unnoticed. Several guests appreciate how the team managed busy scenarios efficiently, showing their ability to prioritize guest satisfaction. The breakfast team is recognized for their accommodating service, ensuring a delightful start to the day.
Individual staff members like Leslie and Milan have been specifically noted for their exemplary service, with Milan earning additional praise for his culinary skills. Such dedication is a testament to the staff's commitment to delivering an exceptional experience. Paul, the owner, and the general manager, with their kindness and attention to guest needs, contribute significantly to the lodge’s inviting ambiance.
While there are minor concerns regarding communication at times, the overarching sentiment is that the staff at The Lodge at Leathem Smith excel in friendliness and responsiveness, marking them as a standout feature of this charming getaway.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers a serene setting with captivating water views and delightful amenities, such as a TIKI patio and a cozy indoor restaurant and pub. However, guests seeking poolside relaxation may encounter some drawbacks, as the majority of reviews highlight the pool’s unavailability or lack of maintenance. Frequently described as closed, empty, or not in operation, the pool presents challenges for those hoping to take a dip. While the outdoor pool sometimes remains filled and usable, issues like cracked tiles, chipped paint, freezing water temperatures, and cleanliness concerns deter guests from enjoying this feature. Despite the inviting surroundings and other attractions at the lodge, the pool does not consistently meet visitor expectations.
The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers guests a pleasant stay with its nice accommodations and included breakfast, providing good value for visitors. However, parking at the lodge can occasionally be a challenge. While parking is generally adequate, it can be difficult during peak times, particularly when the hotel is full. Some guests appreciated the availability of spaces for boats and access to trolling motor plug-ins, which is a great convenience for those visiting the area for boating activities. Despite minor issues with parking scarcity on busy nights, the overall experience at the lodge is satisfactory, offering comfortable accommodations to guests.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
Dinner
Rooms
However, the rooms show signs of wear and tear, with frequent calls for remodeling and updating of furnishings and amenities. Bathrooms, in particular, seem in need of significant refurbishment, with guests reporting signs of mold, rust stains, and unpleasant odors. Some rooms have a musty smell and inadequate amenities like old towels and a lack of electrical outlets, while issues with heating and noisy air conditioning have also been noted.
The charm and character of the lodge, given its century-long history, are recognized by several visitors, who feel the lodge could benefit from some modernization without losing its unique atmosphere. Despite its drawbacks, the lodge serves as a functional base for exploring Door County, with travelers finding value in its spacious accommodations for short stays, though some find the overall experience overpriced given the condition of the property.
Beds
Cleanliness
However, the hotel shows signs of wear and tear, indicating a need for maintenance and more thorough cleaning in some areas. Issues such as rust stains in bathrooms, dirty patio furniture, and grime on glass patio doors detract from its overall appeal. Some guests have encountered problems with dusty surfaces, cobwebs, stained sheets, and floors in need of cleaning, highlighting inconsistencies in the hotel's cleaning standards.
Certain sections of the property, including bathrooms and exterior areas, are in need of significant updating to improve the overall look and feel. Despite these challenges, the friendly staff receives positive mentions, contributing positively to the guest experience. Overall, while there are notable highlights regarding cleanliness, increased attention to detail in maintenance could enhance the guest experience at The Lodge at Leathem Smith.
Staff
Despite occasional lapses in organization during peak times, particularly at the restaurant and bar, the staff’s accommodating nature doesn't go unnoticed. Several guests appreciate how the team managed busy scenarios efficiently, showing their ability to prioritize guest satisfaction. The breakfast team is recognized for their accommodating service, ensuring a delightful start to the day.
Individual staff members like Leslie and Milan have been specifically noted for their exemplary service, with Milan earning additional praise for his culinary skills. Such dedication is a testament to the staff's commitment to delivering an exceptional experience. Paul, the owner, and the general manager, with their kindness and attention to guest needs, contribute significantly to the lodge’s inviting ambiance.
While there are minor concerns regarding communication at times, the overarching sentiment is that the staff at The Lodge at Leathem Smith excel in friendliness and responsiveness, marking them as a standout feature of this charming getaway.
Pool
Parking
Yes, The Lodge at Leathem Smith has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Outdoor Pool.
No, a spa isn't available at The Lodge at Leathem Smith.
Yes, The Lodge at Leathem Smith welcomes dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at The Lodge at Leathem Smith.
No, The Lodge at Leathem Smith doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
