Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Small, 3-Star Hotels in Butler Beach

33 HOTELS IN AND AROUND BUTLER BEACHRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Shimmering Palms main photo
Shimmering Palms
0.9 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Quail Hollow A1-4U main photo
Quail Hollow A1-4U
1.7 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Coastal Haven main photo
Coastal Haven
1.7 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Escape to Tarragona main photo
Escape to Tarragona
2.0 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
9.0
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Pickled Beaches main photo
Pickled Beaches
2.3 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in Saint Augustine Beach FLUS flag
9.0
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Pelican Pad main photo
Pelican Pad
2.8 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
5.0
Rated
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Bliss By The Sea main photo
Bliss By The Sea
3.8 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Bliss By The Sea, gracefully situated on the tranquil riverbank, offers a serene retreat with captivating views and convenient access to local attractions such as historic St. Augustine and picturesque beaches. This boutique hotel provides a sense of privacy and tranquility, ideal for those seeking an escape from the hustle and bustle. Guests are consistently pleased with the clean and comfortable accommodations, elegant Oriental-inspired decor, and thoughtful inclusions such as jacuzzi tubs in select rooms for added relaxation.

The morning breakfast experience at Bliss By The Sea is generally well-received, with guests lauding the delicious offerings, particularly the fresh pastries and croissants. The serene garden adds a charming backdrop to partake in this morning ritual. While the breakfast has room for improvement in terms of variety, it still complements the spectacular ocean vistas, providing a delightful start to the day.

Bliss By The Sea stands out for its exceptional cleanliness, beautifully maintained facilities, and tasteful decor, creating an inviting and tranquil atmosphere. The attentive cleaning staff contributes significantly to guest satisfaction with their diligent care. The presence of accommodating and friendly staff like Anna and Anya enhances the experience, though some guests note occasional challenges in communication and limited in-person interaction.

The hotel features small yet refreshingly clean pools and a jacuzzi tub, providing an undisturbed setting for relaxation. The beach, located conveniently across the road, albeit with limited direct access, allows guests to enjoy the coastal beauty alongside fishing and kayaking opportunities. Additionally, parking, while somewhat limited, is complimentary, benefitting early arrivals.

Bliss By The Sea caters to families with its spacious porches, pools, and generous breakfast portions, though it may be best suited to those seeking a romantic or peaceful family getaway rather than catering specifically to young children.

The rooms offer an enchanting view and a comfortable bedding experience for many guests, despite some mixed feedback on bed comfort due to varying preferences. The overall experience is overwhelmingly positive, marked by cozy accommodations and charming decor.

Bliss By The Sea remains a well-rated, quaint bed-and-breakfast, providing a charming seaside getaway that couples tranquility with convenience, creating memorable stays that resonate with guests seeking relaxation amidst beautiful surroundings.
Categories
3 Star
Small
Beach
Seaside Getaway main photo
Seaside Getaway
4.0 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in Saint Augustine Beach FLUS flag
8.5
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Beach
Island Shores Inn main photo
Island Shores Inn
6.3 km from Butler Beach
Motel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
7.5
Good
From $114
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Salty Breezes #1b main photo
Salty Breezes #1b
6.5 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Dog Friendly
St. Francis Inn - Saint Augustine main photo
St. Francis Inn - Saint Augustine
6.6 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.7
Very Good
From $227
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Bayfront Westcott House Bed & Breakfast main photo
Bayfront Westcott House Bed & Breakfast
6.6 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
9.6
Excellent
From $295
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Historic
Bayfront Inn main photo
Bayfront Inn
6.7 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.7
Very Good
From $153
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Bayfront Inn with its prime waterfront location in the heart of St. Augustine, is highly regarded for its exceptional convenience and stunning bay views. Guests frequently praise the hotel's easy accessibility to the historical district, restaurants, shops and museums, allowing for a hassle-free and immersive exploration of the city. This central yet serene location offers a peaceful retreat from the bustling traffic, enhancing the overall experience.

The breakfast offerings at
Bayfront Inn receive favorable remarks for their variety and quality. Guests appreciate the mix of hot and cold options, including homemade biscuits, eggs, sausage, cereals, pastries and fresh fruit. The clean and bright breakfast area, along with the complimentary aspect, adds to the enjoyment. The availability of afternoon treats and snacks further elevates the guest experience.

Dinner, available on limited nights, features delicious homemade tamales and a popular charcuterie hour, complemented by homemade cookies and enjoyable social gatherings. The staff’s helpfulness with restaurant recommendations enhances dining convenience.

Rooms at
Bayfront Inn are noted for their cleanliness, comfort and charm. Despite some variability in decor and space, guests frequently highlight the spotless condition of the accommodations with some rooms offering beautiful views of the bay and marina. While certain areas could benefit from updates, the overall comfort and well-maintained facilities contribute positively to the stay.

The staff at
Bayfront Inn is consistently celebrated for their exceptional friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism. Their attentive service significantly enhances the overall guest experience, making stays memorable and pleasant.

While reviews of the WiFi are mixed with some guests experiencing strong connectivity and others encountering weak signals, the inclusive internet service and staff support help mitigate these issues.

The outdoor pool with its picturesque bay view, is often described as beautiful and charming, though some guests note it could benefit from refinishing. The pool area is generally well-kept, adding to the relaxing atmosphere of the inn.

Parking at
Bayfront Inn is generally positive with guests appreciating the ample, free and convenient parking spaces, including assigned spots that add to security and organization.

Family accommodations are highly rated with spacious rooms suitable for larger groups and a variety of thoughtful amenities such as cold bottled water, fruit and cookies. The family-friendly environment and prime location make it ideal for family getaways.

Bayfront Inn’s location also places guests within easy reach of the local nightlife, including nightclubs, music venues, eateries, bars and shopping areas, making it a great choice for those looking to explore the vibrant local entertainment scene.

The beds receive generally positive reviews for comfort with many guests praising the soft pillows and restful sleep quality, though a few mixed comments highlight issues with firmness and bedding.

Overall,
Bayfront Inn offers a blend of historic charm and modern comforts, making it an excellent choice for travelers seeking a comfortable stay with easy access to St. Augustine's rich history and vibrant local attractions.
Categories
3 Star
Small
Honeymoon
Edgewater Inn - St. Augustine main photo
Edgewater Inn - St. Augustine
6.8 km from Butler Beach
Hotel in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $154
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Edgewater Inn in St. Augustine is celebrated for its prime location and exceptional hospitality, offering a delightful retreat close to the historic district. Nestled at the eastern end of the Bridge of Lions, guests enjoy easy access to downtown attractions without the hassle of traffic or parking. The inn's waterfront position provides stunning views of the Matanzas River, historic buildings, and memorable sunsets. The proximity to various attractions and the serene, less crowded ambiance make it ideal for exploration and relaxation.

Visitors are consistently impressed with the breakfast experience, featuring homemade egg casseroles, sausage, fruit, and pastries, all served in a cozy room with charming views. Complimentary wine and snacks during the happy hour further enhance the inn's hospitality. The delicious and varied breakfast offerings contribute positively to guests' overall experience.

Rooms at the Edgewater Inn combine modern amenities and impeccable cleanliness with comfort. Guests enjoy spacious accommodations with updated decor, comfortable beds, and crisp linens. Many rooms offer breathtaking views, with some featuring private decks, adding to the serene atmosphere. Cleanliness is a notable highlight, with modern touches such as wooden flooring enhancing the fresh feel.

The staff at Edgewater Inn receive high praise for their friendliness and attentiveness. Names like Rick, Sarah, and Sue are frequently mentioned for their exceptional service, contributing significantly to the welcoming and familial atmosphere. Guests appreciate the personal touch and helpful recommendations, ensuring a memorable stay.

Though free WiFi is available, its reliability may vary across different areas. Nevertheless, the inn's standout features, including its location and easy access to attractions, remain highlights of the stay. While the pool garners mixed feedback, with some guests appreciating its cleanliness and warmth, others note aspects like its positioning and upkeep as areas for improvement.

Edgewater Inn offers exceptional comfort with its beds, described as among the most comfortable experienced by guests. Rooms are complemented by luxurious linens and pleasing color schemes, contributing to a restful environment. Despite occasional mentions of pillows not matching the mattress quality, the overall bedding experience is highly positive.

The inn's tranquil setting amidst picturesque river views adds to its charm, providing a peaceful escape. Although its exterior may appear dated, the interior is well-maintained and inviting. Edgewater Inn offers more than typical three-star quality, making it a standout choice for travelers visiting St. Augustine. The serene outdoor spaces and deck overlooking the water enhance the relaxing atmosphere, making it a fabulous place to stay and enjoy the stunning surroundings.
Categories
3 Star
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Casa De Solana Bed and Breakfast main photo
Casa De Solana Bed and Breakfast
6.8 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $169
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Casa De Solana Bed and Breakfast is an enchanting haven located in the heart of old St. Augustine's historic district. Guests are captivated by its convenient and central location, which allows easy access to vibrant shops, restaurants, and attractions within walking distance. The inn offers a perfect blend of proximity and tranquility, creating a romantic and quiet retreat that beautifully complements the charm of St. Augustine.

Renowned for its breakfast offerings, this bed and breakfast serves up delicious and generous portions, often hailed as superb and wonderful. The imaginative approach to breakfast, complete with fancy table settings, enhances the morning dining experience, contributing significantly to the charm and enjoyment of a stay here.

Within its historical charm, Casa De Solana provides guests with inviting and well-maintained rooms praised for their cleanliness and comfort. The beautifully furnished suites promise a restful night's sleep, despite some minor mentions of tight spaces or dated bathrooms. The impeccable cleanliness throughout the property, including the spotless facilities, is a testament to the dedicated staff.

The staff at Casa De Solana are celebrated for their exceptional hospitality and warmth, consistently going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. Their professionalism and genuine dedication leave a lasting impression on guests, enhancing the overall experience with special touches like early check-ins and signature cookies.

While the offsite parking offers a slight challenge due to narrow streets, the brief stroll to the lot is a manageable inconvenience for most guests charmed by the historic surroundings. The inn's beds are notably comfortable, providing relaxation and coziness with plush mattresses and ample pillows, contributing significantly to a restful night.

Casa De Solana stands as a testament to St. Augustine's rich history, with its status as the 7th oldest property in the city. This beautifully maintained inn immerses visitors in an authentic historical experience, offering a charming ambiance that invites travelers to step back in time while enjoying modern comforts. Overall, Casa De Solana Bed and Breakfast exudes an alluring historic charm, ensuring guests a memorable and delightful stay.
Categories
Small
3 Star
Historic
Penny Farthing Inn main photo
Penny Farthing Inn
6.8 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.1
Very Good
From $185
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Penny Farthing Inn, situated in the heart of St. Augustine's historic district, is highly praised for its exceptional location, ideal for guests wishing to explore the city on foot. Its proximity to local attractions, shopping, and dining, coupled with free parking, makes it a perfect base for discovering the charm of St. Augustine while being a peaceful retreat away from bustling crowds.

The breakfast experience at the inn is frequently lauded for its delicious and freshly prepared offerings, such as eggs Benedict and French toast with raspberry sauce. Guests enjoy the ample portions and appreciate the accommodating staff that cater to dietary needs. The breakfast setting adds to the overall charm with its quaint and cozy atmosphere.

The rooms in the 19th-century wooden house evoke a sense of Victorian allure, complemented by modern comfort. Guests highlight the cozy ambiance of each uniquely decorated room, enriched with period furnishings. Comfortable beds and serene outdoor spaces, such as private balconies and porches, enhance the guest experience, making stays memorable despite minor imperfections like window treatments or tilting due to age.

Cleanliness is another strong point for the inn, with guests frequently commending the spotless condition of the rooms, elegant decor, and pristine linens. Although minor outdoor areas could improve, this does not detract from the overall perception of immaculate tidiness.

The staff at Penny Farthing Inn are frequently praised for their friendliness, professionalism, and attentiveness. Hospitality is a core value, and the welcoming nature of the hosts contributes to an inviting atmosphere that guests appreciate, with high recommendations for their accommodating and polite service.

Comfortable and quality beds further augment the tranquil ambiance ensuring guests enjoy restful nights. Despite occasional mentions of firmness preferences, the overall consensus is positive, adding to the rejuvenating experience of the inn.

Overall, the Penny Farthing Inn stands out as a charming, clean, and comfortable destination with an exceptional location and dedicated staff, enhancing guest experiences and earning widespread praise.
Categories
Small
3 Star
Rooms with Fireplace
Old City House Inn and Restaurant main photo
Old City House Inn and Restaurant
6.8 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $154
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Historic
Hemingway House Bed and Breakfast main photo
Hemingway House Bed and Breakfast
7.0 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
7.8
Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Parking
Agustin Inn - Saint Augustine - Adults Only main photo
Agustin Inn - Saint Augustine - Adults Only
7.1 km from Butler Beach
Inn in St. Augustine FLUS flag
7.6
Good
From $199
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Agustin Inn - Saint Augustine - Adults Only is a highly recommended hotel for those looking for a comfortable and luxurious stay in the heart of Saint Augustine. The hotel's superb location within walking distance of shops, restaurants and historic sites, is a major highlight for guests. The staff is friendly, accommodating and attentive with the manager, Jessica, receiving special praise. The breakfast is exceptional with a varied and plentiful menu that guests describe as the best they've ever had. The rooms are comfortable and beautifully decorated with unique decor and luxury amenities like plush beds, jetted tubs and ceiling fans. The hotel is spotless inside and out with a dedicated staff maintaining the highest standards of cleanliness. The hotel offers free parking, which is an added convenience. The hotel is strictly for adults only, making it a perfect romantic and peaceful getaway. The jacuzzi and hot tub rooms are a luxurious experience with guests raving about the spa tubs and jetted tubs. Overall, Agustin Inn offers a clean, relaxing and quaint atmosphere, making it a great choice for a stay in Saint Augustine.
Categories
3 Star
Small
Nightlife
Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast Adults Only - 21 years old and up main photo
Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast Adults Only - 21 years old and up
7.1 km from Butler Beach
Bed & Breakfast in St. Augustine FLUS flag
9.1
Excellent
From $178
$
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Adult Only
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 33 hotels in and around Butler Beach
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities
Small, 3-Star Hotels, B&Bs, Inns, Motels in Butler Beach FL