Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsToby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection enjoys widespread acclaim for its strategic and convenient location, situated between Edinburgh city center and the airport. The hotel is easily accessible by bus and close to key attractions such as the Edinburgh Zoo and Murrayfield Stadium. Guests appreciate the quiet yet central setting and the ample free parking provided, making it an ideal base for both city exploration and quick airport access.
Breakfast at the hotel is well-received, particularly for its hearty and generous all-you-can-eat offerings. Traditional British or Scottish dishes are plentiful and delicious, though there is a noted desire for healthier options like fruits and cereals. Despite some minor critiques, the overall value and quality of the breakfast, combined with the friendly staff, make it a recommended part of the stay.
Dinner receives high praise, particularly for the carvery meals which are noted for their quality and great value. Guests enjoy the variety and delicious preparation of the food with the on-site restaurant enhancing convenience. Although there are occasional mentions of inconsistent vegetable quality, the restaurant’s ambiance and efficient service remain strong highlights.
The rooms at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection are appreciated for their cleanliness, modern decor and comfortable amenities. While some rooms are smaller and occasionally noisy, they are generally found to be cozy and welcoming. Cleanliness is a strong point with well-maintained rooms and common areas contributing to a pleasant stay.
Staff are consistently praised for their friendliness and helpfulness, creating a welcoming atmosphere. From the reception to the restaurant, the team is noted for their professional and courteous service, contributing significantly to guest satisfaction.
WiFi, however, presents an area for improvement with mixed reviews regarding its reliability and strength.
Parking facilities at the hotel are highly praised for their convenience and ample availability. The easy access and secure parking options enhance the overall guest experience, especially for families and those traveling by car.
The hotel is considered very family-friendly with spacious, clean family rooms and a child-centric atmosphere. Recommendations on transport and nearby attractions further add to its appeal for families.
Guests frequently commend the comfortable beds for providing a restful sleep, though there are occasional mentions of less comfortable fold-out couches.
Overall, Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection offers a three-star experience with excellent value for money, clean and comfortable accommodations, friendly service and a convenient location, making it a reliable choice for travelers.
Categories
Breakfast at the hotel is well-received, particularly for its hearty and generous all-you-can-eat offerings. Traditional British or Scottish dishes are plentiful and delicious, though there is a noted desire for healthier options like fruits and cereals. Despite some minor critiques, the overall value and quality of the breakfast, combined with the friendly staff, make it a recommended part of the stay.
Dinner receives high praise, particularly for the carvery meals which are noted for their quality and great value. Guests enjoy the variety and delicious preparation of the food with the on-site restaurant enhancing convenience. Although there are occasional mentions of inconsistent vegetable quality, the restaurant’s ambiance and efficient service remain strong highlights.
The rooms at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection are appreciated for their cleanliness, modern decor and comfortable amenities. While some rooms are smaller and occasionally noisy, they are generally found to be cozy and welcoming. Cleanliness is a strong point with well-maintained rooms and common areas contributing to a pleasant stay.
Staff are consistently praised for their friendliness and helpfulness, creating a welcoming atmosphere. From the reception to the restaurant, the team is noted for their professional and courteous service, contributing significantly to guest satisfaction.
WiFi, however, presents an area for improvement with mixed reviews regarding its reliability and strength.
Parking facilities at the hotel are highly praised for their convenience and ample availability. The easy access and secure parking options enhance the overall guest experience, especially for families and those traveling by car.
The hotel is considered very family-friendly with spacious, clean family rooms and a child-centric atmosphere. Recommendations on transport and nearby attractions further add to its appeal for families.
Guests frequently commend the comfortable beds for providing a restful sleep, though there are occasional mentions of less comfortable fold-out couches.
Overall, Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection offers a three-star experience with excellent value for money, clean and comfortable accommodations, friendly service and a convenient location, making it a reliable choice for travelers.
Family Friendly Hotel
Hotel with Parking
3-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
'Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection' is highly praised for its strategic and convenient location. Positioned between the Edinburgh city center and the airport, it offers guests easy access to both, making it an ideal choice for travelers. The bus stop situated directly outside the hotel allows for an effortless journey into the city center, typically taking around 20-30 minutes. Guests appreciate its proximity to key attractions like the Edinburgh Zoo, Murrayfield Stadium and local shopping areas. The location's calm yet central setting, coupled with ample free parking, adds to its appeal. The hotel's recent refurbishment and friendly atmosphere are also noted, further enhancing the stay experience. Overall, the combination of convenient transport links, a quiet neighborhood and essential amenities make it a valuable option for both city exploration and quick airport access.
The breakfast experience at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection is largely viewed in a positive light by guests. Many reviews highlight the hearty and generous all-you-can-eat breakfast, which offers excellent value for money. Descriptions of the breakfast often mention it as hearty, plentiful and delicious with a traditional British or Scottish style featuring staples like sausages, bacon, fried eggs, mushrooms and toast. The variety at the buffet receives praise with some guests noting a wide selection of cooked plates and the overall quality of the food.
However, a few reviewers felt the breakfast offerings could be improved, particularly in terms of healthier options such as fruit, cereal, yogurt and lighter choices, which some found lacking. There were also remarks about occasional issues with temperature and the general lack of cold cuts, cheese and fresh rolls, which could disappoint some guests. Despite these criticisms, the staff's friendliness and the overall value for price remain consistent highlights, making breakfast a recommended part of the stay for most guests.
Guests at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection consistently praised the dining experience, highlighting the good quality and great value for money. The carvery dinner received numerous accolades for being amazing, tasty and an excellent option for a quick meal. Many reviewers appreciated the affordability and variety, describing it as a classic roast dinner with delicious, well-prepared food.
The extensive buffet and unlimited lunch options added to the appeal, making it a popular choice for both dinner and breakfast. Specific mentions of elements like the Yorkshire pudding dessert and the salmon with shrimp Wellington indicate a broad and satisfying menu.
Although some noted that the vegetables could be inconsistent in temperature and taste, the overall sentiment remained positive towards the dining options offered. The convenience and charm of having a restaurant directly on-site also contributed to the favorable reviews with many visitors choosing to dine there multiple evenings during their stay.
The combination of tasty Scottish cuisine, a busy yet efficient service and the lovely ambiance of the restaurant downstairs greatly enhanced the overall experience for guests.
The guest reviews for Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection highlight the cleanliness and comfort of the rooms. Many reviewers appreciated the modern and recently renovated decor, alongside the practical layout and amenities offered. Spaciousness was a noted advantage in several rooms with guests mentioning comfortable beds and well-equipped facilities like bathrooms with luxurious showers.
While a number of rooms are described as large and airy, a recurring theme is the small size of some rooms, which led to limited storage and a sense of being cramped. Nonetheless, these smaller rooms were often deemed cozy and welcoming. Noise was occasionally mentioned, especially for rooms facing the street or car park, but many guests found their rooms to be quiet, particularly when curtains were closed.
The cleanliness of the rooms consistently received positive feedback with many describing their rooms as spotless, very clean and well-maintained. There were a few isolated incidents of rooms not being thoroughly cleaned, but these appear to be exceptions rather than the norm. Comfortable, warm and cozy are frequent descriptors used, indicating a general satisfaction with the room environment.
Moreover, some reviews highlighted the practicality and functionality of the rooms with multiple mentions of well-appointed features such as USB outlets and effectively soundproofed spaces contributing to a pleasant stay. Notably, accessible rooms were praised for being easily accessible and meeting the needs of guests.
In summary, the rooms at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection are generally well-received for their cleanliness, modern renovations and comfortable furnishings, despite some variances in room size and occasional noise.
Travelers to Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection frequently commend the comfort of the hotel's beds. The majority of guests highlight the beds as very comfortable with ample space and supportive mattresses. Reviews often note the large size of the double and King-size beds, enhancing the overall sleep experience. Many guests appreciated the clean and cosy beds, often mentioning the adequacy of the duvets and blankets provided.
Certain rooms feature exceptionally comfortable beds and the combination of a comfortable mattress with reading lights has been well received. Warm blankets and multiple pillows contribute to a restful night's sleep.
Though most reviews are positive, it's worth noting that some guests found the fold-out couch and smaller beds less comfortable. Nevertheless, the general consensus emphasizes the excellent quality of the beds, making for a largely comfortable and accommodating stay.
Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection boasts an impressive track record when it comes to cleanliness, as noted by its guests. The rooms and bathrooms have been newly renovated, offering a modern and fresh environment. Guests frequently mention how spotless and tidy both the rooms and common areas are with housekeeping staff ensuring that the accommodations are cleaned every day.
The bathrooms, although sometimes small, are consistently described as very clean, modern and functional with spotlessly clean showers and toilets. The cleanliness isn't limited to the rooms; the entire building maintains a high standard of tidiness. Breakfast ingredients and common areas are also kept clean and orderly.
Though the cleanliness is generally praised, there are occasional mentions of areas needing improvement, such as mold in one bathroom and dirt under some tables. Nevertheless, the well-maintained, comfortable and immaculate rooms, combined with the helpful and friendly staff, make for a pleasant stay. Guests appreciated the large, clean rooms and found the bedding to be clean and changed daily. Overall, the accommodation offers a very clean, comfortable and welcoming environment.
The staff at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection consistently receives praise for their friendliness and helpfulness with many guests highlighting their positive interactions and attentive service. Reviewers often describe the staff as very nice, polite and courteous, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. Particularly noted are the reception and restaurant staff, who are frequently mentioned for their professionalism and kindness. Moreover, specific staff members, such as Dom and Angela, have been singled out for their exceptional assistance and organizational skills. While there have been a few isolated incidents of communication issues and occasional rudeness, the overwhelming sentiment is that the staff are lovely, cheerful and accommodating, making guests feel well cared for during their stay. This high level of service and the convenient location accessible by bus to the city center and the airport create a pleasant experience for guests at this hotel.
When it comes to WiFi at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection, guests have had mixed experiences. On the positive side, there is free WiFi available and some guests have reported good WiFi connections. However, many reviews indicate significant issues. Common complaints include a weak signal in the rooms, difficulty connecting and overall poor reliability. The WiFi was sometimes described as thin or even unworkable, making it challenging to use effectively during their stay. While there were no major mentions in some reviews, the general sentiment leans towards the need for improvements in the hotel’s WiFi provision to meet guest expectations more consistently.
Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection consistently earns praise for its parking facilities, offering ample free parking spaces that guests find highly convenient and accessible. Whether traveling with a family or driving a rental car, visitors appreciate the large, well-secured parking lot available right at the hotel, which simplifies the parking experience. Many reviews highlight the ease of parking with some noting that the spaces are a bit tight but still manageable. The availability of on-site and behind-the-house parking is deemed a significant bonus, making it a great base for those exploring Edinburgh. Overall, the parking arrangements at the hotel are considered a strong asset, ensuring a hassle-free stay for those traveling by car.
Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection is a top choice for families, offering a welcoming and family-oriented atmosphere. The family rooms are consistently praised for being spacious, clean and perfectly suited for families, including those with teenagers. The hotel's environment is designed with families in mind and the young, attentive staff contribute to a friendly, child-centric atmosphere. Guests appreciate the cozy and accommodating rooms, which provide ample space for everyone. The hotel also gives excellent advice on transport to explore local attractions, such as visiting pandas, enhancing the overall experience. Nearby shops are noted as being great for kids and the hotel's location makes airport travel safe and convenient for families. Overall, it's an ideal spot for family visits and comfortable stays with young children.
Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection provides an experience that aligns with typical three-star hotel standards, offering a generally quiet atmosphere and clean rooms which contribute to its very good value for money. Visitors can expect basic yet adequate amenities reflective of the price, along with a charming touch of rooms positioned above the pub.
The hotel features well-maintained facilities and rooms that, despite needing some freshening up such as bathroom renovations, are largely comfortable and cozy. The service quality stands out with top-notch room service and better-than-average care compared to typical budget chains. Guests appreciate the well-kept pint of beer in the bar and the newly decorated, large rooms which enhance the overall stay.
Conveniently, the hotel is just 20 minutes away from the town center via the number 26 Lothian bus, which stops right outside the front door. The lounge bar adds a relaxing and cozy vibe to the guest experience. Overall, this three-star hotel presents a reasonable option for budget-conscious travelers seeking a consistent and reliable stay with some charming and practical touches.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
However, a few reviewers felt the breakfast offerings could be improved, particularly in terms of healthier options such as fruit, cereal, yogurt and lighter choices, which some found lacking. There were also remarks about occasional issues with temperature and the general lack of cold cuts, cheese and fresh rolls, which could disappoint some guests. Despite these criticisms, the staff's friendliness and the overall value for price remain consistent highlights, making breakfast a recommended part of the stay for most guests.
Dinner
The extensive buffet and unlimited lunch options added to the appeal, making it a popular choice for both dinner and breakfast. Specific mentions of elements like the Yorkshire pudding dessert and the salmon with shrimp Wellington indicate a broad and satisfying menu.
Although some noted that the vegetables could be inconsistent in temperature and taste, the overall sentiment remained positive towards the dining options offered. The convenience and charm of having a restaurant directly on-site also contributed to the favorable reviews with many visitors choosing to dine there multiple evenings during their stay.
The combination of tasty Scottish cuisine, a busy yet efficient service and the lovely ambiance of the restaurant downstairs greatly enhanced the overall experience for guests.
Rooms
While a number of rooms are described as large and airy, a recurring theme is the small size of some rooms, which led to limited storage and a sense of being cramped. Nonetheless, these smaller rooms were often deemed cozy and welcoming. Noise was occasionally mentioned, especially for rooms facing the street or car park, but many guests found their rooms to be quiet, particularly when curtains were closed.
The cleanliness of the rooms consistently received positive feedback with many describing their rooms as spotless, very clean and well-maintained. There were a few isolated incidents of rooms not being thoroughly cleaned, but these appear to be exceptions rather than the norm. Comfortable, warm and cozy are frequent descriptors used, indicating a general satisfaction with the room environment.
Moreover, some reviews highlighted the practicality and functionality of the rooms with multiple mentions of well-appointed features such as USB outlets and effectively soundproofed spaces contributing to a pleasant stay. Notably, accessible rooms were praised for being easily accessible and meeting the needs of guests.
In summary, the rooms at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection are generally well-received for their cleanliness, modern renovations and comfortable furnishings, despite some variances in room size and occasional noise.
Beds
Certain rooms feature exceptionally comfortable beds and the combination of a comfortable mattress with reading lights has been well received. Warm blankets and multiple pillows contribute to a restful night's sleep.
Though most reviews are positive, it's worth noting that some guests found the fold-out couch and smaller beds less comfortable. Nevertheless, the general consensus emphasizes the excellent quality of the beds, making for a largely comfortable and accommodating stay.
Cleanliness
The bathrooms, although sometimes small, are consistently described as very clean, modern and functional with spotlessly clean showers and toilets. The cleanliness isn't limited to the rooms; the entire building maintains a high standard of tidiness. Breakfast ingredients and common areas are also kept clean and orderly.
Though the cleanliness is generally praised, there are occasional mentions of areas needing improvement, such as mold in one bathroom and dirt under some tables. Nevertheless, the well-maintained, comfortable and immaculate rooms, combined with the helpful and friendly staff, make for a pleasant stay. Guests appreciated the large, clean rooms and found the bedding to be clean and changed daily. Overall, the accommodation offers a very clean, comfortable and welcoming environment.
Staff
Wi-Fi
Parking
Family
3 Star
The hotel features well-maintained facilities and rooms that, despite needing some freshening up such as bathroom renovations, are largely comfortable and cozy. The service quality stands out with top-notch room service and better-than-average care compared to typical budget chains. Guests appreciate the well-kept pint of beer in the bar and the newly decorated, large rooms which enhance the overall stay.
Conveniently, the hotel is just 20 minutes away from the town center via the number 26 Lothian bus, which stops right outside the front door. The lounge bar adds a relaxing and cozy vibe to the guest experience. Overall, this three-star hotel presents a reasonable option for budget-conscious travelers seeking a consistent and reliable stay with some charming and practical touches.
No, Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection.
No, Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't allow dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection.
No, Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
