Comfort Inn Edgewater on Hudson River enjoys high praise for its prime location, offering stunning views of Manhattan and easy access to New York City. Visitors appreciate the serene riverside setting, which balances tranquility with the convenience of proximity to major attractions like Times Square, accessible via a short bus ride. The hotel is also well-positioned near various restaurants, shopping centers and local amenities, offering ample parking and straightforward public transportation options.
The hotel's breakfast receives mixed reviews with most guests finding it satisfactory and appreciating the range of options such as waffles, eggs, bacon and bagels. While some guests note the convenience and variety of the breakfast offerings, others suggest that it could benefit from a more diverse selection and better food management.
The rooms at Comfort Inn Edgewater are often praised for their cleanliness, comfort and spaciousness. Guests frequently highlight the spectacular views of the Hudson River and Manhattan skyline, as well as the comfortable pillows and two queen-sized beds. Despite minor issues like small bathrooms or slight dampness, the general atmosphere is perceived as quiet and pleasant.
Cleanliness is a consistent strong point with guests applauding the high standards maintained throughout the hotel, including the rooms and common areas. The efforts of the cleaning staff and the fresh, pleasant smell are frequently mentioned, adding to the overall comfort of the stay.
The hotel's staff receives high accolades for their friendliness and helpfulness, contributing significantly to a positive guest experience. The professional and attentive nature of the front desk staff, especially individuals like Carla and Carlos, are often highlighted in reviews.
Finally, the beds are a standout feature with numerous guests praising their exceptional comfort and supportive qualities, ensuring a restful night's sleep.
In summary, Comfort Inn Edgewater on Hudson River combines a prime riverside location with clean, comfortable rooms and exceptional staff service, making it a well-regarded choice for visitors looking to enjoy both relaxation and easy access to New York City.
Quality Suites NYC Gateway enjoys a favorable location for those looking to explore New York City while avoiding the high costs and crowded nature of staying directly in Manhattan. Situated conveniently close to Manhattan, guests can easily reach iconic locations like Times Square in about 20 minutes via public transport or taxi. The hotel is close to a variety of essential amenities, including shops, restaurants, and snack bars, making it a strategic and practical choice for families and individuals interested in spacious accommodations near the city. Although some guests perceive the surrounding neighborhood as an industrial area with limited pedestrian access and public transport options, many appreciate its value as a convenient base for city excursions.
Guests enjoy the spaciousness and cleanliness of the rooms at Quality Suites NYC Gateway, noting the comfort of the beds and pillows. The rooms are well-equipped with amenities such as a minibar, microwave, refrigerator, and kitchenette, which enhance the overall experience. Daily housekeeping ensures that rooms remain tidy and stocked with fresh towels, although there are occasional reports of noise, outdated facilities, and minor maintenance issues that could be improved.
The staff at Quality Suites NYC Gateway is frequently praised for their attentiveness, friendliness, and willingness to go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. Guests consistently commend the warm welcomes and assistance provided by the team, which significantly enhances the overall experience. While there are isolated reports of less-than-ideal interactions with certain staff members, the general consensus is overwhelmingly positive.
Breakfast at the hotel, included in the room rate, receives mixed reviews. While it offers popular items such as waffles, cereal, and bagels, many guests find the selection limited and note a lack of healthy options like fruits and dairy products. The breakfast setup can become crowded and lacks variety, with calls for improvements to better meet diverse dietary needs.
Overall, Quality Suites NYC Gateway presents a favorable option for those looking to explore New York City from a nearby, more affordable base. With its spacious, comfortable rooms and commendable staff service, it provides a convenient and welcoming experience, despite some areas that could benefit from enhancements.
The Robert Treat Hotel in Newark, NJ, is widely appreciated for its prime location, making it a favorable choice for travelers attending concerts, business meetings or visiting New York City. The hotel’s proximity to Newark Penn Station allows for easy access to Manhattan and its location near the Prudential Center, NJPAC, various restaurants and shops adds to the convenience. Guests frequently highlight the complimentary shuttle service to and from the airport and train station, as well as the nearby park and on-site restaurant, enhancing their overall experience.
The in-house restaurant is particularly well-regarded for its delicious food and quality dishes with guests frequently commending the excellent flavors, clean interior and attentive staff. Additionally, many guests found the Wi-Fi to be reliable with a generally good connection and appreciated the gym's equipment and fitness facilities despite some maintenance issues.
However, the hotel doesn’t consistently meet expectations in a few areas. Breakfast options have been a notable disappointment with some guests redirected to nearby establishments at an additional cost. The rooms receive mixed reviews; while some guests describe them as clean and comfortable with nice views and sufficient amenities, others report issues with cigarette smoke, outdated decor, small sizes and maintenance shortcomings. Cleanliness also varies with inconsistencies ranging from exceptionally clean to complaints of dirty linens, mold and leftover debris.
The staff's service is similarly mixed. While many guests appreciate the friendliness and professionalism of certain team members, others encounter unprofessional and unhelpful behavior, which can detract from the overall experience. Parking, though secure and reasonably priced, occasionally presents challenges due to limited spots and extra fees.
For families, the hotel provides varying levels of comfort with some appreciating the spacious rooms and kid-friendly service, while others find the accommodations small and not entirely safe or family-friendly due to cleanliness and maintenance issues. The hotel’s location is favorable for those looking to experience the nightlife with easy access to entertainment venues and bars, although noise from the surroundings can be a concern.
In summary, the Robert Treat Hotel has many strengths, particularly its excellent location, convenient dining and general amenities like free Wi-Fi and a gym. However, the hotel could benefit from improvements in areas such as breakfast service, room maintenance, cleanliness standards and staff professionalism to ensure a consistently positive guest experience.
Categories
3 Star
Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub
Historic
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-3 out of 3 hotels in and around New Rochelle