5-Star Hotels, B&Bs, Resorts in Sag Harbor NY

Topping Rose House 3.8 km from Sag Harbor

Hotel in Bridgehampton NY

7.3

Good

From $887

5-Star Hotel

Located in Bridgehampton, this hotel offers a refined Hamptons experience, especially for food enthusiasts. The property combines luxurious accommodations with a focus on culinary excellence.

Bridgehampton Inn 3.9 km from Sag Harbor

Hotel in Bridgehampton NY

8.7

Very Good

From $325

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Small Hotel

Mill House Inn 6.7 km from Sag Harbor

Bed & Breakfast in East Hampton NY

8.3

Very Good

From $338

5-Star Bed & Breakfast

This luxurious bed and breakfast in East Hampton provides a serene and relaxing experience with thoughtful services. Guests can enjoy a delightful breakfast and personalized attention.

This is a Test 8.1 km from Sag Harbor

Hotel in Greenport NY

Info Categories

5-Star Hotel

Hotel with Spa

Hotel with Gym

The Roundtree, Amagansett 8.8 km from Sag Harbor

Hotel in Amagansett NY

9.4

Excellent

From $646

5-Star Hotel

An elegant hotel in Amagansett, it serves as an ideal beachside retreat. The hotel provides a relaxing and luxurious experience.

Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and Spa 9.4 km from Sag Harbor

Bed & Breakfast in East Marion NY

8.9

Excellent

From $7

Info Categories

5-Star Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Rooms With Fireplace

Boutique-style Bed & Breakfast

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 16.6 km from Sag Harbor

Resort in Montauk NY

7.4

Good

From $661

5-Star Resort

This resort in Montauk features a seawater spa and provides a luxurious beachfront experience. Guests can enjoy various amenities including spa treatments and oceanfront access.

Montauk Manor 19.1 km from Sag Harbor

Hotel in Montauk NY

8.9

Excellent

From $170

5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryMontauk Manor boasts what many guests describe as five-star accommodations with exceptional service and food. The property is praised as fabulous and immaculate, standing out as a wonderful and stunning place to stay. Reviewers frequently use terms like exceptional, superb and phenomenal to describe their experiences and consistently mention the manor as their favorite place to stay. The hotel is said to be fantastic for both families and couples with amazing views that contribute to its luxurious atmosphere.

However, some guests found the stay to be below their five-star expectations, noting issues such as a lack of activities in Montauk, inadequacies in housekeeping and a general perception that the hotel's standards fell short of true five-star status. Despite these comments, the majority sentiment highlights the hotel as an outstanding, excellent and beyond expectations location for a memorable stay.
Show more