7,372,316 hotels
in 60 categories

$ (USD)

Select currency

POPULAR
$ U.S. Dollar€ Euro£ Pound Sterling¥ Chinese Yuan₹ Indian Rupee¥ Japanese Yen
ALL CURRENCIES
AED U.A.E. DirhamALL Albanian LekAMD Armenian DramAOA KwanzaARS Argentine PesoAUD Australian DollarAZN Azerbaijani New ManatsBAM Bosnia-Herzegovina Convertible MarkBBD Barbadian DollarBDT Bangladeshi TakaBGN Bulgarian LevBHD Bahrain DinarBND Brunei DollarBOB Bolivian BolivianoBRL Brazilian RealBTN Bhutanese NgultrumBWP Botswanan PulaBYN Belarusian RubleBZD Belize DollarCAD Canadian DollarCDF Congolese FrancCLP Chilean PesoCHF Swiss FrancCNY Chinese YuanCOP Colombian PesoCRC Costa Rican ColónCUP Cuban PesoCVE Cape Verdean EscudoCZK Czech KorunaDJF Djiboutian FrancDKK Danish KroneDOP Dominican PesoDZD Algerian DinarEGP Egyptian PoundETB Ethiopian BirrEUR EuroFJD Fijian DollarGBP Pound SterlingGEL Georgian LariGHS Ghanaian CediGIP Gibraltar PoundGTQ Guatemalan QuetzalHKD Hong Kong DollarHNL Honduran LempiraHTG Haitian GourdeHUF Hungarian ForintIDR Indonesian RupiahILS New Israeli SheqelINR Indian RupeeIQD Iraqi DinarIRR Iranian RialISK Icelandic krónaJMD Jamaican DollarJOD Jordanian DinarJPY Japanese YenKGS Kyrgyzstani SomKHR Cambodian RielKRW Korean WonKWD Kuwaiti DinarKZT Kazakhstani TengeLAK Lao KipLBP Lebanese PoundLKR Sri Lankan RupeeLYD Libyan DinarMAD Moroccan DirhamMDL Moldovan LeuMGA Malagasy AriaryMKD North Macedonian DenarMMK Myanmar KyatMOP Macanese PatacaMUR Mauritian RupeeMVR Maldivian RufiyaaMXN Mexican PesoMYR Malaysian RinggitMZN Mozambican MeticalNAD Namibian DollarNGN Nigerian NairaNIO Nicaraguan CórdobaNOK Norwegian KroneNPR Nepalese RupeeNZD New Zealand DollarOMR Omani RialPAB Panamanian BalboaPEN Peruvian SolPKR Pakistani RupeePLN Polish ZlotyPYG Paraguayan GuaraniQAR Qatari RiyalRON Romanian New LeuRSD Serbian DinarRUB Russian RubleRWF Rwandan FrancSAR Saudi Arabian RiyalSCR Seychellois RupeeSEK Swedish KronaSGD Singaporean DollarSVC Salvadoran ColónTHB Thai BahtTND Tunisian DinarTRY Turkish LiraTTD Trinidad and Tobago DollarTWD New Taiwan DollarTZS Tanzanian ShillingUAH Ukraine HryvniaUGX Ugandan ShillingUSD U.S. DollarUZS Uzbekistani SomVEF Venezuelan BolívarVND Vietnamese DongXAF Central African CFA FrancXOF West African CFA francXPF CFP FrancYER Yemeni RialZAR South African RandZMW Zambian Kwacha
EN
- English
  
  US
- English
  
  IE
- Español
  
  ES
- Français
  
  FR
- Deutsch
  
  DE
- Italiano
  
  IT
- 日本語
  
  JP
- Ελληνικά
  
  GR
- Suomi
  
  FI
Sign In

Pool

Outdoor Pool

Heated Pool

Indoor Pool

Dog Friendly

Parking

Luxury

Adult Only

Free Wi-Fi

EV charging stations

Honeymoon

Business

Gym

Family

Dogs Stay Free

Small

Spa

Tennis

3 Star

Check In

Check Out

1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests

World > North America > United States > New York > Suffolk > Shelter Island

Hotels with Private Pool Rooms in Shelter Island NY

109 HOTELS IN AND AROUND SHELTER ISLAND

Price range

Sort by: Relevance

Ranking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.

Spacious Oceanview Villa Elegant Coastal Escape, Sleeps 22 21.7 km from Shelter Island

Villa in New London CT

$

Info Categories

Villa with Private Pool Rooms

Villa with Swimming Pool

Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Dog Friendly Villa

Show more

Brand new house with an all year round hot tub. 22.8 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Private Pool

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more

Casa Hermes in Hamptons 23.0 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Show more

Beautiful/Spacious House in West Hampton Beach 23.3 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more

Silver Beach Bliss: Luxury Waterfront Home w/ Pool 23.8 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Baiting Hollow NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Show more

Stunning Westhampton Beach Home with Private Pool 23.9 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Show more

Meadow Lane Estate 24.7 km from Shelter Island

Vacation Home in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Vacation Home with Private Pool Rooms

Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Show more

Home 24.7 km from Shelter Island

Villa in Westhampton NY

$

Info Categories

Villa with Private Pool Rooms

Villa with Swimming Pool

Private Pool

Villa with Parking

Show more

West Hamptons Zen retreat 24.8 km from Shelter Island

Villa in Westhampton NY

$

Info Categories

Villa with Private Pool Rooms

Villa with Swimming Pool

Private Pool Outdoor Pool

Dog Friendly Villa

Show more

*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.

SHOWING 101-109 OUT OF 109 HOTELS IN AND AROUND SHELTER ISLAND

«
1
2
3
4
5
6
»

View all hotels in Shelter Island.

7,372,316

Hotels

60

Categories

49,804

Regions

208,995

Cities

As Featured On

GNTO LICENSE NUMBER (MH.T.E.): 0259Ε60000576001

Copyright © 2012–2025 Travelmyth™. All rights reserved.

Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy Cookies Settings

×

Checkin

×

Categories

1

Map

× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ