Castle Villas at Bluebeards is a great choice for those looking for a centrally located hotel with stunning harbor views. The restaurant and bar offer delicious food and drinks, although the menu is limited and there is no food available after 10 pm. The rooms are comfortable and well-equipped with some offering beautiful views of Charlotte Amalie city. The hotel is undergoing renovations, but guests have complimented the clean and spaciousness of the rooms. The staff is friendly and welcoming, although some guests reported poor customer service from certain employees. The pool deck is large and offers breathtaking views of the harbor, although the pool itself received mixed reviews. Overall, Castle Villas at Bluebeards is a fair place to stay with a lovely view and a castle-style atmosphere, although requirements for areas under construction and noise need to be considered.
Flamboyan on the Bay Resort & Villas is a stunning location in Saint Thomas, offering fantastic views of Magen's Bay from many of its rooms and pool areas. The breakfast options are great and worth trying, while the two on-site restaurants offer excellent and tasty food at reasonable prices. The rooms are mostly clean, cozy and equipped with breathtaking views, although some guests had negative experiences with bugs, unclean towels and dishes, broken items and outdated decor. The property and rooms are impeccably clean and well-maintained and the staff is exceptional, friendly and helpful. The pool area is beautiful and provides a great spot to unwind and soak up the sun with clean and warm pools and stunning views. The beds are comfortable, although some guests found them a little hard. Overall, Flamboyan on the Bay Resort & Villas is a fantastic place to stay with amazing amenities and hospitality.