4-Star Hotels in East Rutherford NJ

Roomza Times Square at Pestana CR7 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.9

Excellent

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Business Hotel

Fairfield By Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $253

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryFairfield By Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square offers an exceptional value for money, especially given its prime location just off Times Square. The hotel's convenient location makes it a great choice for budget-conscious travelers looking to explore Manhattan. Guests frequently commend the friendly and attentive staff with special mentions of Ahmed and Emily for their exceptional service.

The rooms are described as clean, comfortable and efficient with comfortable beds and plenty of amenities, although some reviews point out that the hotel feels dated and some features, like carpeting and bathroom doors, show signs of wear. Negative feedback primarily focuses on the hotel's inability to meet the expectations of a four-star establishment. Issues such as malfunctioning elevators and poor floor cleaning were highlighted and many reviews suggest that the hotel better aligns with three-star standards.

Despite these shortcomings, the hotel is praised for its affordability and decent price/service ratio, making it a solid choice for anyone on a limited budget. Travelers appreciate its merits as a good clean business hotel and find it offers a better deal compared to other accommodations in NYC. However, potential guests should adjust their expectations regarding its four-star rating, as many feel it does not fully meet those standards.
Show more

Moderne Hotel 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.7

Good

From $232

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Boutique-style Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Four Points by Sheraton Midtown - Times Square 6.4 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $234

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe hotel, Four Points by Sheraton Midtown - Times Square, has often been described as having a reasonable quality-price ratio, making it a good value for money. Many guests have appreciated the modern appeal and the comfortable beds, which contribute positively to the stay.

Despite being listed as a four-star hotel, the majority of reviews suggest that the quality doesn’t entirely meet the expectations for this category; several guests felt it aligned more with a 2.5-star to average four-star standard, indicating a discrepancy in expected luxury and service. Complaints about cleanliness and room quality have surfaced with some visitors noting that it didn't feel like a four-star experience and appeared somewhat overpriced given the amenities.

Nevertheless, the hotel does offer standard four-star hotel amenities and has been referred to as a clean and clean hotel with decent pricing, possessing a certain charm reminiscent of a four-star status. For those seeking comfort and a good deal in a prime location, this hotel remains a highly recommended option.
Show more

InterContinental New York Times Square by IHG 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.9

Good

From $324

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe InterContinental New York Times Square hotel has many positive features according to guest reviews. The suites are comfortable and have all the facilities needed for a pleasant stay. However, some guests expressed dissatisfaction with the breakfast, which they felt did not offer enough variety or fresh ingredients. Additionally, some customers felt disappointed with the level of service, especially in regards to bookings made through external websites. Despite this, most visitors felt that this hotel offered good value for money and was located in a prime location for exploring the city.
Show more

Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Midtown Manhattan/Penn Station 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $306

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel near Nightlife Spots

voco Times Square South New York by IHG 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.2

Very Good

From $234

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryTucked in the heart of New York City, voco Times Square South by IHG boasts a prime location that guests consistently appreciate. Situated near Penn Station, it offers the convenience of being a step away from the bustling streets of Manhattan and all its attractions. Visitors frequently highlight the cleanliness of the hotel and the warmth and friendliness of the staff, creating a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere.

The rooms, while described by some as basic, are considered comfortable, cozy by New York standards, and well-maintained. Many guests find them to be just the right size, contributing to an overall satisfying experience. Some might question the hotel's four-star rating due to certain missing amenities, like a fridge or minibar. However, the overall quality of service often meets or exceeds expectations, with free daily popcorn and water adding a delightful touch.

Despite some concerns about not fully living up to its four-star designation, voco Times Square South is frequently recommended by guests who have enjoyed their stay. The hotel's modern renovation has enhanced its appeal, and its competitive pricing for such a central location adds to its value. While management might need to address occasional service issues at the reception, the overall sentiment remains positive, making it a viable option for those seeking a good stay amidst the vibrant surroundings of New York City.
Show more

Aliz Hotel Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $228

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryAliz Hotel Times Square has garnered positive feedback for its cleanliness and stylish decor, exemplified by clean rooms and comfortable beds. Visitors appreciate the well-maintained and nicely equipped facilities, including a rooftop bar that adds to the overall appeal. Many reviewers recommend the hotel for its four-star ambiance, customer service and amenities, highlighting its affordable prices for a four-star establishment and its family-friendly environment.

However, there are mixed reviews regarding whether the hotel meets the full expectations of a four-star rating. Some guests found the experience lacking, pointing out the absence of facilities like a gym or swimming pool and commenting on service quality. Despite these concerns, the general consensus leans more towards satisfaction with the four-star experience provided, making it one of the better options in New York City.

Overall, Aliz Hotel Times Square is seen as a commendable choice for travelers looking for comfort and style in a central location, though some expectations for a four-star hotel may not fully align with every guest's experience.
Show more

Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown New York 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.6

Very Good

From $239

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryStaypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown New York offers a delightful blend of comfort, design and value. Guests frequently praise the hotel's colorful, pineapple-themed decor and surprising artwork, which adds a unique charm to the ambiance. Despite some opinions about the lack of four-star standard amenities such as bedroom slippers and toiletries, the overall feedback highlights exceptional cleanliness and a cozy atmosphere.

The hotel's staff receives rave reviews for their outstanding customer service, contributing significantly to an overall wonderful stay. Travelers also appreciate the free amenities like coffee, snacks, water and perfect cookies, which enhance the experience and showcase thoughtful touches.

Rooms may be smaller than expected, typical of New York, but they are well-organized, clean and boast high-quality towels and bedding. The comfort of the king-sized beds is particularly noteworthy. The location of the hotel adds to its appeal, providing a safe and friendly environment with easy access to local attractions. Guests find the hotel to be a good value for money, offering a very good price for the quality and services provided.

The excellent WiFi, efficient cleanliness and comfort make it an ideal choice for travelers. The hotel's inviting and functional decor, coupled with practical amenities, ensures a pleasant and memorable stay.
Show more

TRYP by Wyndham New York City Times Square - Midtown 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.5

Good

From $214

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLocated in the bustling heart of Manhattan, TRYP by Wyndham New York City Times Square – Midtown garners praise for its prime location, providing easy access to subway lines and major tourist attractions. Guests frequently highlight its good value for money, appreciating its convenience and comfort for short stays. The hotel excels in its fundamental roles, offering clean rooms suitable for resting and refreshing oneself.

However, there appears to be a discrepancy between the hotel's advertised four-star status and the experiences reported by some guests. While the location and friendly staff receive positive mentions, several guests note that the hotel does not meet the expectations typically associated with a four-star rating, mentioning inconsistent cleaning services and maintenance issues.

Despite these critiques, the hotel is often recommended as an affordable option in New York City, particularly for those prioritizing location and value over luxury. It strikes a balance for travelers seeking an accessible, no-frills stay without the extravagance expected from a higher-rated establishment.
Show more

Row NYC at Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

6.0

Rated

From $102

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

The Pearl Hotel 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.7

Very Good

From $301

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Pearl Hotel, situated in a central location and boasting quality service, offers a mixed experience for visitors. While it meets the essential needs and expectations of most guests, some aspects fall short of the four-star standard it advertises. The breakfast, although available as per New York standards, has received criticism for not matching the expectations of a hotel in this category.

Guests appreciate the service, location and quality of food, highlighting these as the strong points of the hotel. The centrality of the hotel does contribute to some noise, which might be a consideration for light sleepers. Despite these positives, there are concerns about the overall value for money, as some guests feel the price is high relative to the services offered. Premium rooms, while advertised as distinct, reportedly suffer from noise due to proximity to the elevator, which can be an inconvenience.

Overall, The Pearl Hotel provides a satisfactory experience with notable strengths in its service and central location, but there is room for improvement to truly embody the four-star experience it claims.
Show more

The Gallivant Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

6.0

Rated

From $174

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Gallivant Times Square benefits from an excellent location, making it particularly appealing for those wanting to be in close proximity to the vibrant attractions of New York City. Many guests have found the hotel to be pleasant and have enjoyed staying there, reporting a generally good quality/price ratio that is reflective of its advertised four-star status.

However, several reviews indicate that the hotel does not meet the typical standards expected of a four-star establishment. Issues with the elevator have been a major concern with guests experiencing long waits and describing the elevators as old and small, sometimes even broken, which detracts significantly from the overall experience. Reports suggest that only one of the three elevators is usually operational, causing constant queues.

Furthermore, the condition of the rooms has been a point of contention. Guests have suggested that a light renovation is needed, particularly focusing on the doors, air conditioning and Wi-Fi. Some have noted that the rooms do not match the high-quality images shown online, which hints at a possible gap between marketing and reality.

Overall, while The Gallivant Times Square offers good value for its location and price, it falls short of the four-star expectations set by its designation. Guests appreciate the chic ambiance and cost-effectiveness but highlight that addressing maintenance issues and improving service standards could help in better meeting the four-star claims.
Show more

SpringHill Suites by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square South 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $254

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Business Hotel

Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square South 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.5

Very Good

From $269

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Business Hotel

Hotel with Parking

Element Times Square West 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.0

Very Good

From $225

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryElement Times Square West offers a mixed experience for travelers seeking accommodations in Midtown West, New York. While the hotel's classification as a four-star establishment is debated among guests, it undeniably provides some attractive features. The location is frequently praised for its convenience, making it an excellent choice for exploring the city. The hotel also distinguishes itself by offering breakfast, a rarity that sets it apart from other local options.

Guests appreciate the good value for money, especially for families traveling with children. The hotel provides basic amenities, catering to those who appreciate the ability to self-cater within their budget range. Its central location and competitive pricing make it a popular choice for budget-conscious travelers.

Despite these positives, some reviews suggest that the facilities and services do not entirely align with four-star expectations, with some guests expressing dissatisfaction with the elevator service and the quality of housekeeping. The dining area for breakfast also drew criticism for being overcrowded and offering limited options.

Overall, Element Times Square West is recommended for those prioritizing location and affordability over luxury, with its great quality-to-price ratio making it a solid choice for practical travelers visiting the bustling heart of New York City.
Show more

citizenM New York Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.8

Excellent

From $283

4-Star Hotel

This hotel provides a modern and tech-savvy experience with its stylish rooms and innovative amenities. It is located in the heart of Times Square and offers a rooftop bar with panoramic views.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryCitizenM New York Times Square offers a modern and sleek concept that garners largely positive feedback for its clean and comfortable rooms and pleasant staff. The hotel's excellent location, just steps from the subway, adds to its appeal, making it a fantastic value for the price. The amenities and facilities are generally rated as four-star quality, bringing a high cost-performance ratio that makes it a great choice for travelers.

The hotel does, however, present a few shortcomings. Some guests felt that the service and amenities, while commendable, were somewhat basic for a four-star rating. The rooms, although modern and comfortable, were noted to be smaller than expected for a property of this caliber. Breakfast offerings also received critiques for not meeting the four-star standard, leaving some guests wanting more.

Despite these areas for improvement, the overall sentiment is that CitizenM provides a good balance between cost and quality, delivering a four-star experience with modern, clean amenities and a prime location. The creative touches, such as adjustable modern lights and artistic design, contribute to the hotel's unique charm, making it a solid option for those visiting New York City.
Show more

M Social Hotel New York Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.4

Very Good

From $305

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryM Social Hotel New York Times Square consistently receives praise for fulfilling the expectations of a four-star establishment. Guests highlight its stylish and modern ambiance, complimented by comfortable and well-decorated rooms. The service provided, particularly by staff members like Ms. Flora, has been noted for enhancing personal experiences, such as special occasions.

The hotel's prime location near Times Square is frequently mentioned as a significant advantage, making it an attractive choice for visitors looking to explore central NYC. The views from the rooms, especially those on higher floors, add to the overall positive impression.

While the majority of visitors felt the hotel met or exceeded four-star standards with its cleanliness and well-maintained facilities, a few noted that certain amenities and staff attentiveness fell short of typical four-star expectations. Nonetheless, the hotel is generally seen as offering good value for money with its competitive pricing and quality service making it a recommendable option for travelers seeking a four-star experience in New York City.
Show more

Paramount Times Square - A Generator Hotel 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.0

Good

From $207

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLocated in Times Square, the Paramount Hotel offers a mixed experience for travelers. Praised for remarkable cleanliness and good service, the hotel ensures a tidy and comfortable stay. Its central location makes it accessible and affordable, adding to its appeal as an affordable city option. The lobby is particularly well-planned and grand, matching the overall aesthetic of the hotel. The rooms, while clean and comfortable, reflect a slightly dated charm.

Despite being marketed as a four-star hotel, many guests feel it falls short of this rating, suggesting it’s closer to a three-star or even two-star standard. The amenities and services, including the absence of room service, fail to meet four-star expectations. Furthermore, some guests were disappointed by the lack of small comforts like toothpaste or a complimentary coffee.

Nevertheless, the hotel is a good value for its location and room rates. The faded splendor of the rooms is often compensated by the delightful staff and the comfort of the beds. While opinions vary, those seeking a basic yet centrally located stay in Times Square might find the Paramount Hotel a suitable choice.
Show more

The Time New York, part of JdV by Hyatt 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.7

Good

From $250

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Time New York, part of JdV by Hyatt, garners mixed reviews from guests, reflecting a blend of satisfaction and areas needing improvement. The hotel's design is frequently praised as spectacular, contributing to its image as a luxury superior establishment. Guests consistently highlight the staff's performance, affirming that their service aligns well with the expectations of a 4-star hotel. Many find the hotel to be a good choice overall within the four-star category with some even rating it as a perfect hotel deserving five stars.

However, there are contrasting opinions regarding the hotel's four-star status. Some guests feel the hotel does not meet the standards typically associated with a 4-star rating, noting elements such as the general upkeep and certain facilities like breakfast and cleanliness that fall short of expectations. The ambiance is described as very dark by some, which they felt detracted from the overall experience. The additional storage fee also surprised a few guests, highlighting a disparity in perceived value.

In summary, while The Time New York impresses with its design and staff service, consistency in meeting all aspects of a four-star experience remains an area for improvement.
Show more

*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.

SHOWING 41-60 OUT OF 200+ HOTELS IN AND AROUND EAST RUTHERFORD