4-Star Hotels in East Rutherford NJ

Crowne Plaza HY36 Midtown Manhattan by IHG 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $283

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Dream Midtown, by Hyatt 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.6

Good

From $232

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryDream Midtown, by Hyatt, has garnered mixed reviews with several guests expressing disappointment regarding its four-star rating and the quality of its facilities and services. Common complaints highlight the hotel falling short of four-star standards with issues such as small rooms, inadequate lighting and tiny elevators frequently mentioned. Many guests felt that the price-performance ratio was not justified and some even described their stay as a huge disappointment, particularly for a hotel branded under four stars. Additionally, the breakfast offerings were found to be basic and, for some, below the expected standard of a four-star hotel. There were also mentions of less-than-adequate service from the staff, contributing to guests' dissatisfaction. Despite these concerns, a few positive aspects were noted including the overall good ambiance of the hotel. However, these were overshadowed by the more prevalent negative feedback regarding the hotel's four-star claim.
Show more

The Manhattan Club 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $289

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Manhattan Club in New York presents a blend of strengths and areas for improvement, positioning itself as a solid four-star establishment. The hotel's strategic and central location is consistently praised, offering good accessibility to Manhattan's key attractions. Guests commend the friendly and accommodating staff, noting their professionalism and warmth. The spacious suites, some featuring two bathrooms and great views, are highlights for many visitors, providing comfort and convenience.

However, the hotel's dated decor and furnishings receive mixed feedback, suggesting the interiors could benefit from a refresh. While the property has seen some renovations, aspects like old furniture and inadequate bathroom facilities fall short of four-star expectations. Some guests find the hotel inflexible with check-in times and notice drafty windows that impact room comfort. Additionally, the lack of a hotel kitchen and minimal shower pressure were noted as areas needing attention.

Despite these issues, the overall ambiance, reflective of New York's vibrant style, and competitive pricing in a prime location make it a recommended choice for travelers. Many guests express intentions to return, underlining a generally positive experience with room for enhancement.
Show more

The High Line Hotel 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.9

Good

From $404

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Boutique-style Hotel

Historic Hotel

EVEN Hotel New York - Times Square South by IHG 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $266

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryNestled in a prime location, the EVEN Hotel New York - Times Square South by IHG proves to be an excellent choice for those wishing to explore the city. With just a short 4-minute stroll to Madison Square Garden and a 20-minute walk to Grand Central, visitors are well-positioned to enjoy the vibrant energy of New York. Despite its higher price point, many guests found the hotel's offerings exceeded expectations. The rooms and staff are often described as top class, contributing to an overall pleasant stay. While not all agree on the four-star rating, the convenient location and quality amenities make it a favorable option for travelers.
Show more

Hyatt Regency Times Square 6.5 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $256

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHyatt Regency Times Square is a great choice for a stay in New York City. Guests praise the hotel's superb location right in the heart of Times Square with easy access to all the major attractions. While the hotel may be busy, it offers excellent facilities and services. Guests have given very positive reviews, highlighting the overall quality of the hotel. Some guests have commented on the slightly outdated look of the hotel, but this doesn't detract from the great experience they had. If you're looking for a top-notch hotel in New York City, Hyatt Regency Times Square should be at the top of your list.
Show more

Park Central Hotel New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.4

Good

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryPark Central Hotel New York is a 4-star hotel situated in a prime location in the city, close to key landmarks like Times Square and Central Park. The modern hotel exudes a classic upscale vibe and is particularly recommended for business travelers. Guests have praised the hotel's value for money, noting it offers a good price for the convenience, room quality and service it provides in Midtown NYC. The staff generally receive high marks for their pleasant demeanor and the cleanliness of the rooms is often highlighted.

However, the hotel garners mixed reviews regarding its four-star rating. Some guests feel that the services and facilities are slightly below the expected standard for a hotel of its purported caliber. Issues like intermittent availability of hot water, prolonged wait times for the lift and inadequate amenities have led some reviewers to rate it more akin to a three-star hotel. Despite these critiques, many still find it to be a good value for the location and consider it a comfortable place to stay in New York.
Show more

DoubleTree by Hilton New York Times Square South 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.0

Very Good

From $245

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLocated in the heart of New York City, the DoubleTree by Hilton New York Times Square South has garnered mixed reviews, particularly over its four-star rating. Many guests appreciate its wonderful location and modern, clean rooms, which also boast amazing views. The hotel's decor is described as a blend of modern and classic, offering an elegant and comfortable ambiance.

Despite the positive aspects, several guests feel that the hotel does not meet the standard of a four-star experience, particularly when compared to European standards. The absence of restrooms in the lobby, limited cafeteria hours and exclusive access to the rooftop bar for guests over 21 are some of the services cited as falling short.

Housekeeping delays and an overall sense that the facilities and staff service could be better have also been noted. While some reviewers believe the stay aligns with the expected four-star experience and offers good value for money, others disagree, suggesting that it doesn’t quite match up to the level anticipated from a four-star hotel.

Overall, for its price range, the DoubleTree by Hilton New York Times Square South provides a generally satisfactory experience, especially regarding its location and room quality.
Show more

The Manhattan at Times Square 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

5.7

Rated

From $201

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Manhattan at Times Square offers a comfortable stay with good service and reasonable rates, making it a great choice for budget-conscious travelers. Guests appreciated the hotel's facilities and acknowledged it as a good value for the price. However, many reviews indicate that the hotel does not meet the standards typically associated with a four-star rating. Numerous comments suggest that the hotel appears outdated and in need of upgrades with some comparing it more to a two or three-star establishment. Cleanliness was noted positively, but several reviews pointed out that the hotel fell short in terms of luxury and amenities expected from a four-star property. Overall, while the hotel provides a pleasant stay with good value, it does not match the advertised four-star quality.
Show more

Hilton New York Times Square 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.7

Good

From $274

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Family Friendly Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hilton Times Square 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.4

Very Good

From $274

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Dog Friendly Hotel

Executive Class at MTS Hotel 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

6.2

Rated

From $380

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Carnegie Hotel 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.8

Excellent

From $262

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Carnegie Hotel garners mixed feedback regarding its four-star rating. On the brighter side, guests appreciate its stylish, modern and well-designed interiors, alongside clean and ultra-modern rooms and bathrooms. The hotel's efficient use of space in the small rooms is noted positively and the establishment impresses with its stylish public areas.

The service provided by the staff often exceeds expectations, including thoughtful touches like afternoon tea and evening wine and cheese. These amenities contribute a touch of elegance to the overall stay.

However, some aspects fall short of four-star expectations. Complaints commonly cite the modest room size, basic breakfast offerings and a lack of facilities. Criticisms extend to the perceived value for money with some guests feeling that the rates are not aligned with the overall quality provided, describing it as more akin to a three-star experience or even a youth hostel with four-star pricing.

In summary, while the Carnegie Hotel boasts many commendable qualities, there are areas that might disappoint those expecting quintessential four-star luxury.
Show more

W New York - Times Square 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.7

Good

From $316

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryW New York - Times Square offers a blend of modern comfort and prime location, making it a considerable choice for travelers visiting the bustling heart of New York City. Guests consistently praise the hotel's convenient location, which allows for easy walking access to Times Square and major attractions. The rooms are recognized for being clean, modern, and spacious, providing a sense of safety and comfort. The staff frequently receives commendations for their exceptional service, noted for being helpful and welcoming, enhancing the overall guest experience from check-in onwards.

Although the hotel often meets expectations in terms of service and cleanliness, some guests express disappointment concerning the hotel's star rating and value. A few reviews suggest that the facilities could use some updating, as they appear worn, and the experience does not always align with the expectations set by its four-star rating. Nonetheless, the positive attributes, particularly the service and location, often lead guests to recommend the hotel and express interest in returning for future stays.
Show more

New Yorker by Lotte Hotels 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

7.6

Good

From $205

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Accessible Hotel

Skyscraper Hotel

Sheraton New York Times Square Hotel 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

6.3

Rated

From $284

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Sheraton New York Times Square Hotel offers a mixed bag of experiences, but generally leans towards the positive for many guests. The hotel boasts a fantastic location, making it an excellent base for exploring the city. Guests often find the beds comfortable and appreciate the professional service provided by the staff. Cleanliness is noted as satisfactory, contributing to a pleasant stay overall.

However, some areas fall short of four-star expectations. The furnishings seem outdated with repeated mentions of old furniture disrupting the modern ambiance one might expect from a Sheraton. Additionally, the lack of amenities such as a minibar, room service and WIFI are disappointing for a hotel in this category.

Though the hotel provides standard services and a satisfactory level of cleanliness, several guests feel it does not live up to the four-star rating it advertises. The overall experience may not match Sheraton's usual high standards with some guests noting that service quality and facility updates are necessary to truly reflect a four-star hotel.
Show more

Renaissance New York Times Square by Marriott 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $340

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryRenaissance New York Times Square Hotel by Marriott generally receives mixed opinions regarding its four-star rating. While many guests agree that the hotel is clean and offers comfortable beds, there are differing views on whether the establishment truly meets four-star standards. Several reviews highlight that the hotel provides good value for money considering its prime location and amenities.

Some guests feel the ambiance and decor fit well within a four-star experience, while others believe the aesthetic and service levels fall short of the expected quality. There are multiple mentions of the hotel being comparable to a three to three-and-a-half-star facility, lacking the luxury typically associated with a higher ranking. Comments about the hotel's "factory" feel and middle-class appeal also suggest room for improvement.

Despite some criticisms, many visitors vouch for a pleasant four-star experience, noting the hotel's efforts in maintaining its rating. The value proposition remains strong for many, even if some aspects, such as the breakfast and overall service, may not fully align with four-star expectations.
Show more

The Michelangelo New York 6.6 km from East Rutherford

Hotel in New York NY

8.5

Very Good

From $313

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Michelangelo New York captivates guests with its old-world charm and service, presenting a romantic and luxurious setting that makes visitors feel like royalty. As a four-star establishment, it offers a pleasing ambiance and exudes a comfortable and diligent service quality typically expected from such a rating. The hotel is appreciated for its vintage charm and lovely decor, even though it stands as one of the older hotels in town.

However, factors such as outdated facilities, lack of regular maintenance and cleanliness issues have been noted. Guests have pointed out that aspects like dirty external windows and occasional discrepancies in housekeeping detract from the overall experience. Despite its charm, some visitors feel that the hotel's pricing does not align well with the benefits received, suggesting it might feel more like a declining four-star accommodation at times.

Overall, The Michelangelo New York maintains a quality ambiance and comfort typical of a four-star rating while balancing its vintage allure with some modern elements. Still, prospective guests may want to weigh the nostalgic charm against some of the dated attributes when considering their stay.
Show more