Corstorphine Lodge Hotel is highly regarded for its prime location, offering convenience with close proximity to Edinburgh Airport and the city center. Guests appreciate the easy access to multiple bus stops outside the hotel, making commuting straightforward. The hotel's strategic positioning near popular local attractions, such as the Edinburgh Zoo and Murrayfield Stadium, further enhances its appeal. In addition, the surrounding area boasts numerous dining options, shops and amenities, contributing to the overall convenience and attractiveness of staying at the hotel.
Guests generally find the rooms at Corstorphine Lodge Hotel spacious, clean and comfortable with many noting the historic charm of the old building combined with modern amenities. High ceilings, decorative coving and large windows add to the cozy atmosphere, while amenities such as kettles with coffee and tea selections are appreciated. Despite some comments about the rooms and facilities being somewhat dated, the overall sentiment remains positive due to their cleanliness and size.
The breakfast experience at Corstorphine Lodge Hotel receives mixed reviews. Many guests enjoy the freshly prepared, made-to-order items and commend the friendly and accommodating chef, particularly for meeting dietary needs. However, some feel the breakfast is overpriced and lacks variety with several guests mentioning that breakfast is not included in the room price.
While the hotel does not provide dinner, its location near a variety of restaurants, including a highly recommended Italian eatery and popular bakeries, ensures guests have ample dining options. The bar service is somewhat limited and some guests find the set breakfast times restrictive, but the staff’s helpfulness, including delivering food ordered via external services, is appreciated.
Cleanliness is a consistent strong point for Corstorphine Lodge Hotel with many guests highlighting the spotless conditions of the rooms and common areas. Occasional issues like superficial cleaning oversights are noted but do not detract significantly from the overall positive impression.
The friendliness and helpfulness of the staff are standout features with numerous guests praising the warm and welcoming service. The staff often go above and beyond to ensure guest satisfaction, contributing to a pleasant stay.
Wi-Fi connectivity appears to be a challenge with many guests reporting intermittent or non-functional internet service. Despite this, the provision of USB sockets and complimentary Netflix is a positive addition.
Families find the hotel suitable due to the large, accommodating rooms and the friendly, engaging staff. The proximity to attractions like the zoo makes it particularly appealing for family vacations, despite minor inconveniences such as the lack of windows in some rooms.
However, opinions on the beds are mixed. While some guests find them comfortable, others report issues with thin, hard or saggy mattresses, indicating a need for updates to provide a more consistent sleeping experience.
Overall, Corstorphine Lodge Hotel offers decent three-star accommodation that aligns well with its price and location. It is a practical and economical option for travelers, particularly those who value convenience, cleanliness and friendly service over luxury amenities.
Located in Newbridge, Edinburgh, Norton House Hotel & Spa provides a mesmerizing experience for guests. Preserving the allure of a private country home, this property combines contemporary comforts with modern amenities. The 1840 country house hotel serves as an optimal setting for weddings and meetings, owing to its convenient proximity to both Edinburgh Airport and the city center. The Norton House Health Club & Spa, situated adjacent to the hotel, offers guests a space for relaxation and rejuvenation during weekend getaways. Additionally, the dog-friendly policy ensures a comprehensive Scottish experience for everyone. The hotel's fascinating history is reflected in its exceptional architectural details, which encompass a fusion of Jacobean and neo-Adam styles. Guests can relish the luxurious spa treatments and facilities, including treatment rooms, a sauna, a steam room, pools and an amber lounge. Norton House is the perfect starting point for discovering Scotland's finest destinations, from Cramond to Falkirk to Fife.
Summary of reviews
Norton House Hotel & Spa in Edinburgh is a beautiful property located in a peaceful rural setting just outside the city. The hotel offers a range of comfortable and spacious rooms with luxurious beds and soft linens. The breakfast is fabulous with plenty of options to choose from, although some guests found the prices to be expensive for the portion sizes. The dinner options received mixed reviews with some guests praising the food while others found the menu limited and poor. The hotel's spa facilities are amazing and spotlessly clean with guests enjoying the swimming pool, jacuzzi, sauna and steam bath. The staff are exceptional, providing friendly and attentive service throughout the stay. While some guests experienced slower service or a lack of visibility from waiters at mealtimes, the majority of guests noticed nothing but flawless service and amazing staff. Overall, Norton House Hotel & Spa is an excellent choice for a beautiful location, amazing spa and exceptional staff.
Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club is a lovely hotel with an interesting history and stunning views, surrounded by beautiful tranquil surroundings. Although breakfast and dinner received mixed reviews with some guests finding the options limited or disappointing, other guests enjoyed the wide range and good quality of food. The rooms are spacious, luxurious and comfortable with great leisure facilities, although some rooms may need updating. The hotel is spotlessly clean with friendly and helpful staff, although there were some issues with service. The leisure and spa facilities received positive reviews, but the swimming pool can be crowded. Families enjoyed the activities for children and the hotel's great location. Golf enthusiasts will appreciate the hotel's facilities and beautiful surroundings. Overall, Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club is a relaxing and enjoyable place to stay, offering great value for a 4-star hotel.
Acer Lodge Guest House provides an exemplary experience for visitors to Edinburgh, thanks to its notably convenient location, exceptional breakfast offerings, clean and comfortable accommodations, friendly staff and practical amenities like parking.
The location of Acer Lodge Guest House is highly appreciated by travelers due to its proximity to the airport and seamless public transport options to the city center. It is situated close to bus stops, making trips to central Edinburgh a breeze. Despite being on a busy street, effective soundproofing ensures a quiet stay and the availability of free parking adds to its convenience for those traveling by car. Overall, the locale combines accessibility with a pleasant surrounding area.
Guests consistently praise the breakfast, noting the high quality, taste and variety of options, including traditional Scottish items, croissants, waffles and oatmeal. The personal and made-to-order service that allows guests to choose breakfast options the night before further enhances the dining experience, making breakfast at the guest house a standout feature.
The rooms at Acer Lodge Guest House are frequently lauded for their cleanliness, comfort and spaciousness. Guests find the rooms well-maintained, thoughtfully arranged and beautifully decorated. The accommodations include comfortable beds and well-sized bathrooms equipped with quality toiletries. Though some guests mentioned the beds could be narrower or softer than their preference, this did not significantly detract from the overall positive experience. The rooms include conveniences like coffee makers and mini fridges, catering to travelers' needs and ensuring a comfortable stay.
Cleanliness is a recurring highlight with reviews repeatedly noting the spotless state of rooms and bathrooms. This high standard, combined with comfortable amenities, creates a homely atmosphere and contributes to a pleasant stay.
The staff, particularly owners Thomas and Anjoe, are often commended for their warmth, friendliness and attentiveness. Their prompt and helpful service, along with their willingness to assist with any needs or inquiries, significantly enhances the guest experience. The staff’s contribution is crucial in fostering a welcoming and comfortable environment.
Parking at Acer Lodge Guest House is another well-regarded aspect with free, convenient and secure off-street parking available right outside the entrance. Despite the busy street location, the soundproofing ensures guests enjoy a restful stay.
In summary, Acer Lodge Guest House stands out for its superbly convenient location, excellent breakfast service, clean and comfortable rooms, friendly and helpful staff and practical parking solutions, making it a highly recommended choice for visitors to Edinburgh.
JustB Edinburgh, located just outside the bustling city center of Edinburgh, offers guests a serene retreat with the advantage of convenient access to both urban activities and picturesque countryside. Set in a tranquil setting about 10 kilometers from the city, the hotel strikes a perfect balance between city and nature. Guests frequently commend the fantastic hosts and the beautifully maintained property that exudes a homely feel. Its proximity to public transport, including a nearby bus stop offering regular services to the city center, ensures effortless exploration without the hustle and bustle.
The hotel's breakfast experience is widely regarded as exceptional, with guests praising the wide array of delicious, gourmet breakfast options that accommodate various dietary needs. The tranquil, sun-filled conservatory or garden room where breakfast is served enhances the overall dining experience, offering a calming atmosphere that guests thoroughly enjoy.
The rooms at JustB Edinburgh are consistently praised for their charming décor and spaciousness, providing a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. Guests appreciate the attention to detail, cleanliness, and the restful comfort of the beds. Although a few guests find some room features like the bath or wardrobe a bit small for extended stays, the overall ambiance remains a highlight of the accommodations.
Cleanliness is a standout feature, with the property and rooms meticulously maintained to offer a modern, welcoming environment. The dedicated staff, led by Karen, Geoff, Karo, and Jeff, receive high praise for their warm hospitality and attentiveness. Guests frequently highlight their superb welcome and the hosts' readiness to assist or provide local recommendations, making stays particularly enjoyable.
Ample and convenient parking directly on-site offers peace of mind for those traveling by car, while the quiet, secure location further enhances the appeal of the hotel. The beds are consistently highlighted for their comfort, contributing to a restful night's sleep amid the tranquil, natural setting. Overall, JustB Edinburgh offers a welcoming, comfortable retreat with exceptional service, making it an excellent choice for a relaxing getaway.
Twin Lions Hotel is a favored destination for travelers seeking a blend of convenience, comfort, and exceptional service, situated just a few miles from Edinburgh's city center. Guests appreciate its strategic location, offering easy access to local attractions and transportation options, including the nearby airport and city buses. The tranquility of the neighborhood coupled with quiet rooms provides a peaceful retreat after a day of exploration.
The breakfast service at Twin Lions Hotel receives commendations for its hearty and tasty offerings. With classic English and Scottish dishes prepared to order, the personalized and quick service further elevates the dining experience, making it a satisfying start to the day. While some guests have suggested that the menu could offer more variety, the overall feedback remains positive.
Accommodations at Twin Lions Hotel are praised for their cleanliness and comfort, particularly the cozy beds. Rooms are consistently clean and tidy, although some guests note the compact size and dated decor. The hotel staff, however, frequently receive high praise for their friendliness and attentiveness, significantly enhancing the guest experience with their warmth and professionalism.
Guests benefit from reliable and efficient WiFi throughout their stay, complemented by the convenience of ample free parking, which is a key advantage for those traveling by car. The family-friendly atmosphere is another highlight, with the welcoming nature of the owners and staff making guests feel at home.
While there are some calls for renovation and minor improvements, particularly regarding room sizes and decor, Twin Lions Hotel remains a popular choice for travelers. Its combination of strategic location, friendly service, and overall value make it an attractive option for both leisure and business visitors to Edinburgh.
The Murrayfield Hotel in Edinburgh garners high praise from guests for its strategic location, comfortable accommodations, and welcoming staff, providing an ideal setting for both city explorers and rugby enthusiasts. Situated close to the Murrayfield Stadium and with seamless transport links to the city center, the hotel offers exceptional convenience amidst a serene environment. Its proximity to shops, restaurants, and bars enhances the experience, making it a great base for leisure and business trips.
Breakfast at the hotel is frequently highlighted as an outstanding experience with a wide variety of options, including freshly cooked dishes and gluten-free alternatives. Guests appreciate the high quality of the food and the friendly service, although some mention occasional service delays and buffet shortages. The hotel's restaurant, the Bothy, also receives positive feedback for its tasty dishes and delightful atmosphere, enhancing dining experiences with lovely service and local culinary specialties.
Rooms at the Murrayfield Hotel are lauded for their spaciousness and elegant decor, offering a cozy atmosphere with high ceilings and modern amenities. Comfortable beds, often large and plush, contribute to a restful night's sleep. Families appreciate the spacious rooms and attentive staff, making the hotel a perfect choice for exploring Edinburgh. Minor issues such as room temperature control and wear in fixtures are noted but do not significantly detract from the overall positive impression.
Cleanliness is a strong point, with guests often emphasizing the immaculate presentation in both rooms and common areas. The friendly and professional staff is consistently recognized for their exceptional service, creating a welcoming atmosphere that enhances guests' stays. Wi-Fi is generally reliable, though some guests experience connectivity issues.
Ample parking and the provision of free spaces are significant advantages, offering convenient accessibility for guests, even during peak events. Ultimately, the Murrayfield Hotel combines comfort, convenience, and quality service, making it a favored choice among visitors seeking a memorable experience in Edinburgh.
Hillhouse offers a highly appealing experience, combining a convenient location, welcoming accommodations, and outstanding hospitality. Situated in a peaceful neighborhood, it provides easy access to central Edinburgh with convenient bus connections and proximity to key spots like Princes Street and the airport. Guests appreciate this balance of tranquility and accessibility, further enhanced by good parking facilities and nearby amenities like supermarkets and Cramond Beach.
The accommodations at Hillhouse are praised for their cleanliness and comfort. Guests consistently note the tidy and well-maintained rooms, enjoying the cozy and spacious larger rooms, complete with comfortable double beds and private bathrooms. While some rooms are smaller than anticipated, Hillhouse maintains high standards of cleanliness, with daily room servicing ensuring fresh towels and a comforting, quiet ambiance.
Exceptional hospitality defines Hillhouse, with the staff receiving high praise for their friendly and accommodating service. The hosts, including standout staff members like Nancy, are noted for their attentiveness and willingness to exceed expectations, ensuring a personal and memorable guest experience.
Although opinions on bed comfort vary, many visitors find the beds to be very comfortable, allowing for a restful sleep. The overall atmosphere of cleanliness and care contributes to a warm and delightful stay. Hillhouse’s combination of ideal location, pristine conditions, and dedicated staff ensures it remains a charming choice for travelers seeking comfort and convenience.
Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh City West by IHG, receives generally positive feedback across various aspects of its service and amenities. Its strategic location is repeatedly highlighted by guests for its convenience and accessibility. The hotel is well-situated just outside Edinburgh's city center with a frequent and reliable bus service available right outside, offering a practical alternative to staying in the more expensive central areas. The presence of local amenities such as a large supermarket, retail park and various shops and cafes add to its appeal. Guests driving to the hotel appreciate the ample parking and easy access to key roads. The quieter setting, combined with scenic views over Edinburgh, provides a peaceful stay while remaining convenient for major city attractions and specific destinations like the nearby hospital, Murrayfield Stadium and Edinburgh Zoo.
Breakfast at the hotel is generally well-received with guests noting the variety and freshness of the offerings. The inclusion of breakfast in the room rate is considered a good value, providing extensive choices that cater to dietary preferences including gluten-free and vegetarian options. However, there are areas for improvement such as expanding the variety of hot breakfast items and better addressing periods of understaffing to avoid delays.
Dinner service at the hotel receives mixed reviews. While some guests enjoy the tasty bar food and find the option to dine-in up to 9 pm convenient, others feel that the limited menu and high prices detract from the experience. Inconsistent food quality and service levels suggest room for enhancements in this area.
The rooms at Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh City West are often praised for their cleanliness, comfort and modern decor. Many guests appreciate the spaciousness of the rooms, particularly those on higher floors that offer stunning city views. However, some reviews note issues with outdated decor, small bathrooms and occasional maintenance problems. The overall consensus is that the rooms provide a good value for money, especially for short stays, although some improvements could further enhance the guest experience.
Cleanliness at the hotel receives a mix of positive and negative feedback. While many guests find the hotel to be clean and well-maintained, there are instances where the cleaning standards are not consistently met, leading to dissatisfaction among some guests.
The hotel staff is predominantly praised for their friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism. Many guests report positive interactions with the reception team and commend the staff for their responsiveness and attentiveness. Despite occasional mentions of understaffing or less experienced staff, the overall sentiment is highly positive.
Wi-Fi service at the hotel is generally reliable and fast with most guests finding it sufficient for their needs. While there are occasional reports of weak signal strength in certain areas, the overall connectivity is praised.
Parking is another mixed aspect with guests appreciating the convenience of ample on-site parking spaces. While some reviews point out that the parking fees are somewhat high, many find the arrangements well-organized and safe.
The hotel is recognized as family-friendly, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere for those traveling with children. Spacious rooms, kids' play areas and family-oriented services contribute to a positive experience, although there are mentions of room sizes being smaller for larger families and some discomfort with sofa beds.
Beds at the hotel receive favorable comments for their comfort and cleanliness, contributing to a restful stay for most guests. However, there are minor criticisms regarding the firmness of pillows and comfort of pull-out beds.
Overall, Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh City West offers a comfortable stay well-aligned with its three-star rating. The hotel’s convenience, affordability and quality of amenities make it a suitable choice for both leisure and quick business trips.
The hotel offers a romantic package which includes luxurious accommodation, champagne, special treats, a dozen roses, breakfast in bed and late checkout, making it ideal for the most unique and romantic honeymoon experience.
Ardmillan Hotel in Edinburgh garners substantial praise for its excellent location. Situated conveniently with easy access to transport links, it allows guests to reach the city center quickly via a short bus ride or walk. The nearby Haymarket station and main attractions such as Murrayfield Stadium and Edinburgh Castle add to its appeal. The quiet and friendly neighborhood, combined with a traditional Scottish character, makes it an ideal spot for a relaxed stay.
Breakfast at the hotel, especially the traditional Scottish offering, receives positive reviews for its quality, taste and generous portions. The friendly staff enhance the dining experience, although there are minor criticisms regarding the lack of cooked options for continental breakfast seekers.
While the hotel does not provide dinner services, the cozy bar, known for its excellent whiskey selection and welcoming atmosphere, compensates this. Guests can easily find a variety of dining options, including Italian and Indian restaurants within walking distance.
The rooms at Ardmillan Hotel are often praised for their cleanliness and comfort. Many find them to be tidy, cozy and well-maintained, despite some noting issues such as thin walls, dated decor and minor maintenance problems. The beds are generally comfortable, contributing to a restful stay, although a few guests find them small or in need of upgrades.
Cleanliness is a strong point with frequent commendations for the spotless rooms and excellent housekeeping. However, occasional issues with bathroom cleanliness and furniture wear are noted. The overall perception remains that of a clean and budget-friendly option with some need for upkeep.
The staff at Ardmillan Hotel consistently receive accolades for their friendliness, helpfulness and attentiveness. Guests appreciate their warm, welcoming attitudes and willingness to assist, making the stay more pleasant and comfortable.
The hotel's free wifi service is liked for its reliability, although there are instances of variable speeds and weak signals, particularly in certain areas. Parking is another area with mixed feedback. While free street parking is appreciated, the limited and sometimes misleading on-site parking availability can be a concern.
For families, the hotel offers a cozy environment with amenities that cater to both children and adults, despite some limitations in room size and occasional cleanliness issues. The proximity to transport links adds to its convenience for family outings.
Overall, Ardmillan Hotel stands out for its prime location, comfortable atmosphere, friendly staff and generally positive guest experiences, making it a favorable choice for travelers visiting Edinburgh.
Cumberland Hotel, located in a prime area of Edinburgh, is celebrated for its excellent and convenient location. It offers easy access to public transportation, key attractions and dining options, all while ensuring a peaceful stay in a tranquil setting. The local neighborhood charm adds to its allure, making it a highly recommended choice for visitors.
The breakfast experience at the hotel generally receives positive feedback, appreciated for its variety and quality. Guests highlighted the hearty, well-prepared meals and the friendly, attentive breakfast staff. Specific items like traditional Scottish fare were particularly enjoyed and the breakfast atmosphere is noted for being cozy and well-organized.
The hotel's dining options are more limited, particularly for dinner. While the bar area is praised for its ambiance and service, the lack of an evening meal service often leads guests to explore nearby eateries. Lunch choices are sparse and although breakfast service has seen some challenges, it still manages to offer a decent start to the day for most guests.
Guest reviews about the rooms present a balance between traditional charm and modern conveniences. Spaciousness and cleanliness are frequently appreciated with family rooms being particularly comfortable. Though some rooms feature modern amenities, others show signs of aging with occasional maintenance issues. Rooms are generally clean and tidy, despite some sporadic reports of minor cleanliness lapses.
The staff at Cumberland Hotel have earned significant praise for their friendliness and helpfulness with reception staff being especially noted for their courtesy and professionalism. Individual employees are often mentioned for their exceptional service.
WiFi connectivity is a mixed experience with some guests finding it reliable and satisfactory, while others face persistent issues with weak or nonexistent connections. It might be advisable to check with the hotel about WiFi availability before the stay, especially for those who require reliable internet access.
Parking options at the hotel are generally well-received, noted for their convenience and ample space. However, the additional daily fee, ranging from £10 to £15, is seen as an extra expense, though many guests find it justified by the convenience offered.
For families, the Cumberland Hotel is a strong contender providing spacious accommodations and a family-friendly atmosphere. The hotel’s prime location and attentive service make it a solid choice for family vacations, despite some minor drawbacks regarding child-specific amenities and occasional noise issues.
Overall, Cumberland Hotel offers a strategic location, comfortable accommodations and friendly service, making it a commendable choice for visitors seeking both accessibility and tranquility in Edinburgh.
Dalry Guesthouse in Edinburgh receives glowing reviews for its prime location, exceptional cleanliness and welcoming staff, making it an ideal choice for travelers eager to explore the city. Positioned conveniently close to public transportation, including tram lines and bus stops, as well as being a short walk from Haymarket station, the guesthouse ensures ease of travel. Guests appreciate the proximity to a variety of restaurants, shops and a nearby grocery store, all while enjoying a tranquil and peaceful setting.
The breakfast provided is appreciated for its simplicity and sufficiency, offering a range of cereals, toast, fruit and beverages. While not overly extravagant, it is seen as a thoughtful inclusion and adequate for a light morning meal.
Rooms at Dalry Guesthouse are consistently praised for their cleanliness and comfort with amenities that meet guests' expectations. Beds are generally regarded as comfortable, allowing for a restful night's sleep, although some reviews point to occasional inconsistencies in bedding quality. The showers are particularly noted for excellent water pressure and temperature, enhancing the overall stay experience.
Cleanliness is a standout feature with the entire guesthouse, including the bathrooms and common areas, maintained to a high standard. The friendly and accommodating staff, particularly the owner, contribute significantly to guest satisfaction, providing a warm and hospitable environment along with useful local recommendations and assistance with logistics.
The free WiFi at Dalry Guesthouse is generally reliable, though a few guests have mentioned occasional connectivity issues. Overall, the internet service is deemed sufficient for most visitors' needs.
In summary, Dalry Guesthouse offers great value for money with its excellent location, clean and comfortable accommodations, sufficient breakfast and outstanding staff. It is highly recommended for both solo travelers and families seeking a pleasant and convenient stay in Edinburgh.
Summary of reviews related to the 'Honeymoon' category
JOIVY Haymarket in the lovely city of Edinburgh has received overwhelmingly positive feedback from honeymooners. Guests appreciate the beautiful views and well-decorated, clean rooms. Many describe their rooms as spacious and even smaller rooms have been renovated impressively. Reviewers consistently highlight the hotel as a perfect spot for honeymooners with phrases like excellent honeymoon stay, amazing honeymoon stay and great honeymoon stay frequently mentioned. It's clear that honeymooners found their experience fantastic and lovely, making JOIVY Haymarket an ideal choice for a romantic getaway.
Eliza House is a charming, historic hotel in Edinburgh that consistently receives praise for its prime location, cleanliness and accommodating staff. Situated near Haymarket Station, the hotel offers easy access to public transportation, making exploring the city and reaching the airport hassle-free. Guests enjoy the proximity to major attractions like the Royal Mile and Edinburgh Castle, as well as the vibrant local shops, restaurants and pubs. The neighborhood combines central convenience with a peaceful atmosphere, perfect for both tourists and business travelers.
The hotel provides a complimentary, self-serve, grab-and-go breakfast including coffee, tea and an assortment of snacks like croissants, cereal bars and pastries. While the simplicity and lack of a full breakfast are noted, many guests appreciate the thoughtful gesture and convenience of the offerings.
Rooms at Eliza House are spacious, cozy and clean with high ceilings and large windows adding a touch of grandeur. The period features and traditional decor, while charming, could benefit from some updates and maintenance. Despite occasional issues with aging furnishings and minor maintenance problems, the rooms are generally quiet and offer a peaceful retreat from the city. Guests frequently commend the cleanliness of both the bedrooms and bathrooms, though some mention dated furnishings and occasional less attentive cleaning in certain areas.
The staff at Eliza House consistently receive high marks for their friendliness and helpfulness, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere. Their efficiency and readiness to assist with any needs, from providing city information to helping with luggage, enhance the overall guest experience.
The WiFi service is generally reliable and fast with minor connectivity issues in certain rooms. The beds are another highlight, often praised for their comfort and quality, although a few guests report variability in bed firmness and occasional noise.
Eliza House offers good value for money, making it an ideal choice for budget-conscious travelers seeking an affordable, pleasant and centrally located stay. The hotel's historical charm, dating back to the 1860s, adds a unique character and its pet-friendly policy is a bonus for travelers with dogs, although improvements could be made to address occasional dog-related odors.
Overall, Eliza House provides a cozy, comfortable stay with a blend of historical elegance and modern convenience, ensuring a memorable visit to Edinburgh.
The Guards Hotel enjoys a prime location directly across from Haymarket Station, providing excellent access to trains, trams and buses, facilitating easy travel within Edinburgh and to the airport. Guests appreciate its proximity to attractions such as Princes Street and Edinburgh Castle, complemented by nearby dining and shopping options.
Room experiences vary significantly. Positive reviews highlight clean, spacious rooms—especially larger suites with ensuite bathrooms and antique furniture—equipped with amenities like tea and coffee facilities, hairdryers and TVs. However, the hotel struggles with inconsistent room quality with some guests reporting dated decor, maintenance issues and cleanliness concerns. While some rooms are quiet and comfortable, others suffer from inadequate heating and unpleasant odors, necessitating upgrades and more consistent housekeeping.
Cleanliness is another area of mixed reviews. Some guests find the rooms very clean and comfortable, while others cite issues like dust, dirty carpets, mold and neglected details. Despite these challenges, the linens and towels are noted to be clean. The building itself needs refurbishment to meet higher cleanliness standards.
Staff at The Guards Hotel consistently receive praise for their friendliness, helpfulness and accommodating nature. The owner and reception staff are particularly noted for their warm and engaging service, making the check-in process smooth and efficient. However, the lack of 24/7 reception can cause inconvenience when trying to reach staff during off-hours.
The Wi-Fi service is generally perceived as problematic with many guests experiencing weak signals, especially on the top floors. While some manage to get a decent connection, many report difficulties logging on or staying connected, indicating a need for improvement in this area.
For families, the hotel offers large family rooms with cribs, highchairs and sofabeds, making it suitable for those traveling with children. However, space may be limited for larger families. Ground-floor rooms offer added comfort and accessibility.
Bed quality receives mixed feedback. Many guests find the beds comfortable with clean linens and cozy quilts. However, a number of reviews mention old, saggy mattresses, broken frames and even insect bites, pointing towards the need for better bed maintenance and upgrades.
As a three-star hotel, The Guards Hotel offers basic, budget-friendly accommodations that reflect its rating. It is especially suitable for short stays focused on affordability and central location, though some guests note the need for refurbishment and improved cleanliness. The hotel provides functional and economical lodging for budget-conscious travelers.
Accessibility features include disabled-friendly rooms and convenient access from the airport, but the lack of elevators and drainage issues in some bathrooms can pose challenges for disabled and elderly guests.
In summary, The Guards Hotel provides a decent stay with significant room for improvement in consistency, cleanliness and Wi-Fi reliability, balanced by its excellent location, friendly staff and budget-friendly rates.
Categories
Honeymoon
Golf
Family
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 133 hotels in and around Gogar