Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

4-Star Hotels in Islamorada

14 HOTELS IN AND AROUND ISLAMORADARanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
Amara Cay Resort main photo
Amara Cay Resort
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $238
$
4 Star
This extensive modern resort features blue-and-white clad rooms and suites, offering luxurious accommodation right on the beach. It includes a swimming pool, excellent eateries, and a range of watersports. Guests can relax on hammocks on the private beach and enjoy sunset cocktails.
La Siesta Resort & Villas main photo
La Siesta Resort & Villas
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.2
Very Good
From $189
$
4 Star
Features a collection of charming villas and rooms with a relaxed, tropical vibe. It offers multiple pools, lush gardens, and a convenient location close to attractions. The resort provides a comfortable and family-friendly atmosphere.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
La Siesta Resort & Villas delivers an experience that many guests find aligns well with four-star expectations. With a commendable range of facilities and services, the resort has left visitors looking forward to returning. The hospitality and offerings have prompted numerous guests to highly recommend it for future stays in Islamorada. While some views indicate the rating might not match personal expectations of a four-star establishment, the positive experiences suggest a solid and enjoyable stay for those who visit.
Islander Resort main photo
Islander Resort
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $252
$
4 Star
Offers a beachfront location with stunning ocean views and a variety of activities. It features multiple pools, on-site dining, and comfortable rooms with balconies. The resort provides a perfect blend of relaxation and recreation for families and couples.
The Islands of Islamorada main photo
The Islands of Islamorada
Hotel in Islamorada FLUS flag
9.2
Excellent
$
4 Star
This hotel offers waterfront villas and suites with ocean views, a private beach, and a marina. It provides a bespoke experience with oceanfront pools and opportunities for water activities. The resort is meticulously designed for ultimate comfort and sophistication.
Bayside Villas by Islander Resort main photo
Bayside Villas by Islander Resort
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $288
$
Info
Categories
4 Star
Sustainability Journey
Luxury
Casa Morada main photo
Casa Morada
Resort in Islamorada FLUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $304
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Casa Morada is a perfect hotel for a getaway with exceptional staff who are friendly, nice and lovely. Guests have only positive things to say about the staff, who are always willing to make guests feel at home and offer their help promptly. Terri and Sarah are standout members of the team, but all staff members are exceptional. Checking in and checking out is effortless due to the helpful and attentive receptionists. From reception until departure, guests can expect an amazing experience with every person they meet. The staff at Casa Morada deserves special commendation for their exceptional service.
Categories
4 Star
Dog Friendly
Dog Play Area
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Three Waters Resort and Marina, Islamorada, a Tribute Portfolio Resort main photo
From $408
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina, situated in the heart of the Florida Keys on Islamorada, is celebrated for its prime location, scenic ocean views and direct beach access. Visitors praise the resort for its serene yet vibrant backdrop, perfect for both relaxing and adventurous getaways. The well-maintained grounds blend modern facilities with natural beauty and the proximity to local dining and entertainment options, including a nearby Starbucks, enhances convenience.

Guests have mixed feelings about the breakfast offerings. While an inclusive breakfast option is missing, the onsite café, Tiki Bar and Starbucks are appreciated, despite occasional closures and inconsistencies in food quality. Dinner receives better reviews, particularly for the Tiki Bar and raw bar with high praises for the steak and conch fritters. However, limited dining options during the off-season and high prices can be frustrating.

Room reviews are varied. While some guests find them clean, spacious and comfortable with stunning ocean views, others highlight outdated décor and maintenance issues. Common areas are generally well-kept, but room cleanliness concerns are frequently noted, including mold and neglected housekeeping duties.

Staff interaction at the resort is largely positive with many guests praising the friendly and accommodating team, especially at the Tiki bar and beach. However, some inconsistency in service, particularly at the front desk, has been reported.

The pool experience is enjoyable for many due to its oceanfront setting and amenities like a swim-up bar, but maintenance issues and cleanliness concerns, such as mold and broken fixtures, have been cited.

The beach is a standout feature with its beautiful, clean private areas and a wealth of activities. Families, in particular, appreciate the safe and kid-friendly environment, although occasional debris and seaweed buildup can be an issue.

Ample and convenient parking, including free valet services, adds to the hassle-free experience, making it easy for guests to load and unload close to their rooms.

Overall, Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina is a favorable destination for beach lovers and families, combining beautiful surroundings, a range of activities and largely positive service experiences, despite some noted areas for improvement in breakfast offerings, room conditions and pool maintenance.
Categories
4 Star
Beachfront
Beach
7 more hotels nearby!
Ocean Pointe Resorts - 1214 Sea View main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts - 1214 Sea View
10.9 km from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
8.7
Very Good
$
4 Star
This aparthotel has excellent reviews.
Nauti Hideaway, Unit #2314 main photo
Nauti Hideaway, Unit #2314
11.0 km from Islamorada
Hotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
8.7
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
4 Star
Beach
Family
Ocean Pointe Resorts - Serenity 2308 main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts - Serenity 2308
11.0 km from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
9.9
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Ocean Pointe Resorts 3410 Boho main photo
Ocean Pointe Resorts 3410 Boho
11.0 km from Islamorada
Aparthotel in Tavernier FLUS flag
9.7
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection By Hilton main photo
Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection By Hilton
14.6 km from Islamorada
Resort in Key Largo FLUS flag
8.1
Very Good
From $394
$
4 Star
Baker's Cay Resort provides a blend of luxury and nature, featuring private beach access, two swimming pools, and nature trails. It includes amenities like a spa, waterfront dining, and curated activities, ensuring a high-quality and relaxing experience.
Bungalows Key Largo - All Inclusive main photo
Bungalows Key Largo - All Inclusive
16.8 km from Islamorada
Resort in Key Largo FLUS flag
9.1
Excellent
From $1,225
$
4 Star
As an all-inclusive resort, Bungalows Key Largo provides a comfortable and hassle-free experience with meals, drinks, and activities included. The resort caters to adults only, ensuring a serene and high-quality stay.
Hawks Cay Resort main photo
Hawks Cay Resort
19.6 km from Islamorada
Resort in Marathon FLUS flag
7.4
Good
From $297
$
4 Star
Located on Duck Key, this resort offers a wide array of activities and amenities, including multiple swimming pools, a full-service spa, and a dolphin connection program. Guests can enjoy various water sports, tennis courts, and diverse dining options. The resort is family-friendly, with a dedicated kid's area and activities.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-14 out of 14 hotels in and around Islamorada
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities