Gardener's Lodge 2.9 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Vacation Home with Parking


Show more
 
The Old Forge 3.2 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in Stillington
7.0
Good
From $132
From $132
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Dog Friendly Vacation Home


Show more
 
The Durham Ox 5.3 km from Sutton on the Forest
Inn in Crayke
9.4
Excellent
From $142
From $142
Info Categories
5-Star Inn


Luxury Inn


Dog Friendly Inn


Show more
 
The Landings Cottage 5.3 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in Nun Monkton
9.4
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Dog Friendly Vacation Home


Show more
 
The Carriage House 6.1 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in Upper Poppleton
9.2
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Vacation Home with Parking


Show more
 
The Station House 6.1 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in Upper Poppleton
9.2
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Vacation Home with Parking


Show more
 
Vikings Two Bedroom Apartment With Free Parking. 6.2 km from Sutton on the Forest
Apartments in York
8.2
Very Good
From $231
From $231
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment


Apartment with Parking

EV charging stations  


Luxury Apartment


Show more
 
Clementine's Guest House 6.2 km from Sutton on the Forest
Hotel in York
9.2
Excellent
From $106
From $106
5-Star Hotel
This hotel provides a luxurious and comfortable experience with its well-appointed rooms and personalized service. Located conveniently in York, it offers easy access to the city's attractions while providing a peaceful retreat.
Show more
 
The Old Coach House 6.3 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
9.8
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Dog Friendly Vacation Home


Show more
 
MonkBridge House 6.3 km from Sutton on the Forest
Bed & Breakfast in York
9.6
Excellent
5-Star Bed & BreakfastSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryNestled in a prime location just a short walk from York, MonkBridge House sets the bar high for bed and breakfast accommodations with its exceptional hospitality and attention to detail. Consistently described as perfect, guests are welcomed by friendly and accommodating hosts who make every effort to ensure a flawless stay. Rooms are immaculately clean and well-appointed with plentiful quality toiletries, while the pretty garden offers a tranquil retreat.

The breakfast experience is a highlight, with delicious meals cooked to order, adding to the overall feeling of luxury and care. Thoughtful extras throughout the property leave guests feeling pampered and satisfied, with parking included as a delightful bonus. This attention to detail resonates with guests, many of whom express a strong desire to return, cementing MonkBridge House as a top choice for those seeking a five-star experience in a charming bed and breakfast setting.
Show more
 
Bootham Court Grade II duplex apartment with free parking & Wi-Fi - sleeps 2-6 people 6.4 km from Sutton on the Forest
Apartment in York
9.3
Excellent
5-Star Apartment
This duplex apartment combines historic charm with modern luxury. The Grade II listed building offers a unique and upscale experience, complete with free parking and Wi-Fi for added convenience.
Show more
 
Gillygate Holiday Apartment 6.4 km from Sutton on the Forest
Apartment in York
8.9
Excellent
From $205
From $205
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment


Luxury Apartment


Apartment with Free Wi-Fi


Show more
 
York Boutique House- spacious & stylish with free parking 6.5 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
9.1
Excellent
From $249
From $249
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Show more
 
St Wilfrid's Court 6.5 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
9.1
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Show more
 
The Workshop 6.6 km from Sutton on the Forest
Apartment in York
9.6
Excellent
5-Star Apartment
The Workshop provides a luxurious apartment stay with a focus on modern design and comfort. Its stylish interiors and well-equipped facilities make it a top choice for discerning guests.
Show more
 
Jorvik House 6.6 km from Sutton on the Forest
Hotel in York
8.7
Very Good
From $163
From $163
5-Star Hotel
Cited as a 5-star hotel by some sources, this boutique townhouse offers stylish, characterful rooms with Nordic design touches and is conveniently located near the city centre attractions.
Show more
 
Minster's Keep- Near York Minster & Free Parking 6.6 km from Sutton on the Forest
Apartment in York
8.6
Very Good
From $344
From $344
5-Star Apartment
This stylish apartment boasts a prime location near York Minster, offering luxurious accommodation with modern amenities. Its proximity to the city's main attractions makes it a desirable choice for sophisticated travelers.
Show more
 
12 Pear Tree House 6.7 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
9.8
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Luxury Vacation Home


Vacation Home with Parking


Show more
 
The Barn at Orchard Farm 6.7 km from Sutton on the Forest
Vacation Home in York
10
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Vacation Home


Vacation Home for Adults Only


Luxury Vacation Home


Show more
 
Judge's Lodging 6.7 km from Sutton on the Forest
Hotel in York
8.6
Very Good
From $179
From $179
5-Star Hotel
Judge's Lodging offers a historic and luxurious experience with its elegant rooms, charming atmosphere, and central York location. Its blend of history and modern amenities makes it a unique and memorable choice.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryJudge's Lodging in York presents itself as a five-star establishment but has received mixed reviews regarding its alignment with that prestigious classification. Guests generally appreciate the hotel’s great location, acknowledging its convenience despite some noise at night. However, there are several points of contention: many visitors feel the hotel falls short of five-star expectations, with some pointing out it seems more like a three-star experience. Concerns include the lack of a proper fridge in the rooms, inconsistent hygiene standards, and room images not matching those advertised online.

Despite these criticisms, numerous guests still express satisfaction and recommend the hotel to others, highlighting exceptional and wonderful experiences and valuing it as an excellent option for staying in York. While the property is old and there are challenges such as the absence of a lift or concierge service, the overall impression remains positive for many who have stayed. Although the luxury may be lacking for those expecting top-tier standards, the reasonable pricing compared to other five-star hotels and the charming experience outweigh the shortcomings for many guests. Ultimately, for its price range, Judge's Lodging is a place that guests have frequently recommended and shown willingness to return to.
Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
Categories:
  •     5 Star (162)
  •     Parking (123)
  •     Luxury (121)
  •     Dog Friendly (52)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (36)
  •     Adult Only (31)
  •     Small (30)
  •     EV charging stations (14)
  •     Accessible (12)
  •     Boutique-Style (12)
  •     Honeymoon (11)
  •     Romantic (10)
  •     Nightlife (7)
  •     Historic (5)
  •     Family (5)
  •     Business (4)
  •     Sustainability Journey (3)
  •     Golf (3)
  •     Health & Safety (3)
  •     Spa (2)
  •     Gym (2)
  •     Pool (2)
  •     Indoor Pool (2)
  •     Dogs Stay Free (2)
  •     Cheap (2)
  •     Tennis (1)
  •     Yoga (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ