Small Hotels, B&Bs, Guesthouses, Motels in Brookhaven NY

67 Lake House

Hostel in Brookhaven NY

8.3

Very Good

$

Info Categories

Small Hostel

Hostel with Free Wi-Fi

Hostel with Parking

46 more hotels nearby!

Smithpoint motel 3.3 km from Brookhaven

Motel in Shirley NY

$

Info Categories

Small Motel

Dog Friendly Motel

Motel with Free Wi-Fi

Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach 3.4 km from Brookhaven

Country House in Shirley NY

7.3

Good

From $4,501

$

Info Categories

Small Country House

Country House with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Country House with Parking

112 Motel 4.5 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Medford NY

7.7

Good

From $140

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Hotel with Parking

Hotel with Rooms With Jacuzzi / Hot-tub

JD COZYNEST LLC 4.6 km from Brookhaven

Guest House in Shirley NY

9.1

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Small Guest House

Guest House for Honeymoon

Guest House with Parking

Come As You Are Inn LLC 8.7 km from Brookhaven

Bed & Breakfast in Sayville NY

9.6

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Small Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast for Adults Only

Bed & Breakfast with Parking

The SkyBreeze Inn 9.8 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Bohemia NY

5.7

Rated

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Family Friendly Hotel

The Madison Fire Island Pines 10.6 km from Brookhaven

Guest House in Fire Island Pines NY

9.2

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Small Guest House

Guest House for Adults Only

Guest House for Honeymoon

A Victorian on the Bay Bed and Breakfast 10.9 km from Brookhaven

Bed & Breakfast in Eastport NY

9.3

Excellent

From $209

$

Info Categories

Small Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi

Cozy unit 11.2 km from Brookhaven

Guest House in Centereach NY

$

Info Categories

Small Guest House

Aj & TJ BnB 12.3 km from Brookhaven

Bed & Breakfast in Sound Beach NY

9.8

Excellent

$

Info Categories

Small Bed & Breakfast

Dog Friendly Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Parking

The Fox and Owl Inn 13.4 km from Brookhaven

Bed & Breakfast in Port Jefferson NY

8.9

Excellent

From $178

$

Info Categories

Small Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Bed & Breakfast with Parking

Westhampton Seabreeze Motel 13.9 km from Brookhaven

Motel in Westhampton NY

8.0

Very Good

From $233

$

Info Categories

Small Motel

Motel with Parking

The Surfcomber Unit 3 14.1 km from Brookhaven

Motel in Ocean Bay Park NY

$

Info Categories

Small Motel

Dog Friendly Motel

Accessible Motel

Coastal Cove Cottage 14.2 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Ocean Bay Park NY

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Hotel with Free Wi-Fi

Clegg's Hotel 14.8 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Ocean Beach NY

8.5

Very Good

From $309

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

Palms Hotel Fire Island 14.9 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Ocean Beach NY

7.2

Good

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Family Friendly Hotel

The Blue Parrot Guest House 14.9 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Ocean Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Seven Beach Lane 15.2 km from Brookhaven

Hotel in Westhampton Beach NY

$

Info Categories

Small Hotel

Dog Friendly Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Three Village Inn 15.3 km from Brookhaven

Inn in Stony Brook NY

7.6

Good

From $181

$

Info Categories

Small Inn

Inn with Free Wi-Fi

Historic Inn

Small Hotels in Brookhaven NY