Radisson Collection Hotel, Royal Mile Edinburgh 9.1 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
7.9
Good
From $91
From $91
5-Star Hotel
Ideally situated in the heart of Edinburgh's Old Town and with the city's most iconic sightseeing attractions just a breath away, Radisson Collection Hotel, Royal Mile Edinburgh offers unparalleled 5-star luxurious accommodation.
Show more
 
Royal Mile Balconies by the Castle 9.1 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
8.1
Very Good
From $278
From $278
5-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe 'Royal Mile Balconies by the Castle' boasts an exceptional location right beside Edinburgh Castle, nestled in the heart of the old town. Guests consistently highlight the immaculate and spotlessly clean rooms, which are well-equipped for short stays and feature high-quality products. Attention to detail is evident in every convenience provided, enhancing the comfort and functionality of the accommodations.

However, despite the meticulous upkeep and the conveniences offered, there is a recurring sentiment that the establishment does not live up to its advertised five-star rating. Many reviews liken the experience more to an Airbnb, indicating that the rooms do not match the luxury and quality typically associated with a five-star rating and instead suggest a three-star level of service and amenities.
Show more
 
Royal Mile Suites by the Castle 9.1 km from Penicuik
Aparthotel in Edinburgh
7.9
Good
From $240
From $240
5-Star AparthotelSummary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryRoyal Mile Suites by the Castle offers an exceptional experience with great luxurious amenities that many guests have praised. However, there are differing opinions regarding the hotel's overall star rating. Some visitors have questioned the five-star designation with several noting that the facilities and services feel more aligned with a four-star or even lower rating. Despite this, the property has earned recognition for its quality in areas highlighted as deserving of the high rating, but the value for the price may not always meet expectations. Overall, while offering an excellent stay in many aspects, the classification as a five-star establishment remains a point of contention among guests.
Show more
 
The Bonham 9.1 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
9.3
Excellent
From $255
From $255
5-Star Hotel
A luxury boutique hotel located in the charming West End, known for its elegant Victorian architecture and stylish interiors. It consistently receives high praise for its comfortable rooms and excellent service.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Bonham is an elegant boutique hotel in Edinburgh, praised for its stunning architecture and beautiful decor. Guests appreciate the ambiance and the traditional charm of the building with many original features. The staff are noted for providing professional service, which contributes to a generally high-class experience. Rooms are particularly highlighted for their five-star quality, suggesting a luxurious stay.

However, there are recurring sentiments that The Bonham doesn't fully meet the five-star standard expected, especially given its pricing. Some guests felt that the experience was more in line with a four-star hotel, citing certain service and detail-oriented aspects that fell short. Afternoon tea service, for instance, did not meet the five-star expectations for some.

Overall, while The Bonham impresses with its aesthetics and some aspects of service, there are mixed feelings about its alignment with the five-star rating, particularly concerning value for money and certain service standards.
Show more
 
Festival Lets 9.2 km from Penicuik
Apartment in Edinburgh
9.9
Excellent
From $1,702
From $1,702
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Apartment with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Royal Mile Apartment 9.2 km from Penicuik
Apartments in Edinburgh
7.9
Good
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Apartment with Parking

EV charging stations  

Luxury Apartment

Show more
 
Old Town Chambers, Autograph Collection 9.2 km from Penicuik
Aparthotel in Edinburgh
9.2
Excellent
From $322
From $322
5-Star Aparthotel
Situated in the center of Edinburgh’s Old Town, 5* Old Town Chambers provides a unique and exceptional event space for dinners and corporate functions.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryIf you're looking for a five star experience in Edinburgh, look no further than Old Town Chambers, Autograph Collection. Guests rave about the exceptional location and high standard apartments, calling it the best accommodation they've stayed in. The service provided by the staff is superb and guests love the stylish design and layout of the apartments with beautiful views and convenient kitchens. Many highlight the exceptional service and would strongly recommend it to others. Overall, the property is described as fabulous, perfect and exceptional with many guests already planning to return. Highly recommended for a truly memorable stay in wonderful Edinburgh.
Show more
 
Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG 9.2 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
8.8
Excellent
From $299
From $299
5-Star Hotel
This 5-star hotel is located in the heart of the city of Edinburgh and offers opulent and elegant accommodation, reminiscent of the golden age of travel.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG, is a truly exceptional five star hotel with a central location and fabulous decor. The friendly and adorable staff go above and beyond to provide superb customer service. It's no wonder that guests have described their stays as magnifique and amazing, making this hotel the best they have ever stayed in. Despite being sold as a five star hotel with rates to match, some guests have felt that the experience was more like a four star. However, overall, guests found it to be a wonderful place to stay and would highly recommend it, despite some minor disappointments such as issues with odors. Considering its good value for money compared to other five star hotels, the Kimpton - Charlotte Square is definitely worth considering for your next stay in Edinburgh.
Show more
 
100 Princes Street 9.2 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
9.7
Excellent
From $382
From $382
5-Star Hotel
Part of the prestigious Red Carnation Hotel Collection, this hotel offers a bold, luxurious style with meticulous attention to detail. Features include gilded furnishings, grand art, unobstructed Edinburgh Castle views, and highly personalized service.
Show more
 
JOIVY Luxury Flats on George Street 9.4 km from Penicuik
Apartments in Edinburgh
8.0
Very Good
From $433
From $433
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Show more
 
Luxury New Town 1 Bed Apartment 9.4 km from Penicuik
Apartments in Edinburgh
8.3
Very Good
From $290
From $290
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Show more
 
Edinburgh Old Town 9.4 km from Penicuik
Apartment in Edinburgh
9.2
Excellent
From $484
From $484
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Apartment with Parking

Show more
 
The Balmoral Hotel 9.4 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
9.3
Excellent
From $590
From $590
5-Star Hotel
Occupying Edinburgh's most prestigious address, No. 1 Princes Street, for more than a century, The Balmoral Hotel welcomes its guests in its elegant, glamourous and luxurious rooms and suites.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Balmoral Hotel is a luxurious five-star establishment located in the heart of Edinburgh that offers exceptional facilities and services. Guests have described their stay as nothing short of amazing, creating sentimental and treasured memories that they will cherish forever. The hotel's outstanding features, including its top-end customer service, demonstrate why it is the best choice in Edinburgh and the best hotel in Scotland. Guests who have stayed in hotels rated 5* on the continent have remarked that The Balmoral is different class A, exceeding their expectations. The Spa and the pool are simply incredible, complete with a range of refreshments and treatments to book in advance. Reviewers note that the location is perfect for getting around the city and the lovely service is evident in every area of the hotel. There is no doubt that The Balmoral is the definition of 5-star luxury accommodation in Edinburgh.
Show more
 
InterContinental Edinburgh The George by IHG 9.4 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
8.4
Very Good
From $284
From $284
5-Star Hotel
The Principal is one of Edinburgh's most luxurious hotels. Offering 5-star facilities and accommodation, every guest that enters its doors will be met with nothing but luxurious treatment.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe InterContinental Edinburgh The George by IHG has been praised by guests for its exceptional facilities and services. As a luxury hotel, it's located in the best area of the city and is considered top class by guests. While some have noted that it lacks certain amenities such as a swimming pool, overall the hotel is very worthy of its 5-star rating. Exceptional and superb are just a few of the positive words used to describe the hotel, making it a first-class destination for travelers.
Show more
 
The Edinburgh Grand, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Edinburgh 9.4 km from Penicuik
Aparthotel in Edinburgh
9.0
Excellent
From $308
From $308
5-Star Aparthotel
Set in a magnificent former bank building in the New Town, this property offers luxurious serviced apartments. It combines historical architecture with contemporary design and high-end facilities.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryThe Edinburgh Grand, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Edinburgh presents a blend of rich fabrics and wooden period features, thanks to its history as an old bank. Guests have frequently remarked on the building's loveliness and meticulously preserved historic elements, creating a unique and special atmosphere. Many reviews highlight the first-class service and impeccable food, especially mentioning an event and dinner in the Penthouse suite as a particular highlight. There is a consensus that the facilities and treatments at the hotel align with luxury five-star standards, supported by comments on true five-star service, deserving every one of its stars and everything being of five-star quality.

However, some critiques suggest that the hotel does not quite meet the expectations of a five-star rating. Points of improvement include the lack of amenities such as dressing gowns and minibars and varying opinions on the cleanliness and breakfast options, which some found lacking for a hotel of this supposed caliber. Though there are varied individual experiences, the overall sentiment still leans towards positive with many expressing a desire to return for what they feel is a true five-star experience.
Show more
 
Gleneagles Townhouse 9.5 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
9.2
Excellent
5-Star Hotel
Bringing the Gleneagles luxury experience to the city center, this hotel features a unique pre-war style with vintage furnishings. It is praised for its friendly staff, sophisticated atmosphere, and excellent dining at The Spence restaurant.
Show more
 
The Queens View 9.5 km from Penicuik
Apartment in Edinburgh
9.5
Excellent
From $226
From $226
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Apartment for Adults Only

Show more
 
South Learmonth Gardens Apartment 9.5 km from Penicuik
Apartment in Edinburgh
9.1
Excellent
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Show more
 
Queen Street Boutique Suites 9.5 km from Penicuik
Apartments in Edinburgh
8.0
Very Good
From $260
From $260
Info Categories
5-Star Apartment

Luxury Apartment

Show more
 
W Edinburgh 9.5 km from Penicuik
Hotel in Edinburgh
8.9
Excellent
5-Star Hotel
A recently opened, contemporary luxury hotel in the St James Quarter, featuring a distinctive architectural design, stylish rooms, a rooftop terrace with panoramic views, and exciting dining and bar venues.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryW Edinburgh offers a promising and high-caliber experience that aligns well with its five-star rating, making it an excellent choice for a city break. The hotel's striking architecture and breathtaking views set the scene for a memorable visit. Visitors will likely find the professional and attentive staff exceptional, contributing significantly to a personalized and welcoming atmosphere. Despite some initial teething issues as the hotel had just opened, the service provided by the staff is consistently praised and lives up to its five-star promise.

While there are minor critiques concerning the bar's ambiance and room service menu, the overall impression is that of a top-notch establishment. Some guests noted areas where the service did not entirely meet five-star expectations, such as the lack of amenities like biscuits with tea and some lingering organizational challenges. However, these are anticipated to improve as the hotel settles into operation. With adjustments in service quality and refinement of offerings, W Edinburgh is poised to deliver a truly impeccable experience befitting its status.
Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in Penicuik.
Categories:
  •     5 Star (73)
  •     Luxury (62)
  •     Parking (35)
  •     Dog Friendly (25)
  •     Accessible (22)
  •     Small (22)
  •     Honeymoon (19)
  •     Romantic (19)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (17)
  •     Family (15)
  •     Business (14)
  •     Adult Only (13)
  •     Sustainability Journey (12)
  •     Nightlife (12)
  •     Gym (11)
  •     Historic (10)
  •     Boutique-Style (9)
  •     Golf (8)
  •     EV charging stations (8)
  •     Spa (6)
  •     Indoor Pool (4)
  •     Pool (4)
  •     Tennis (4)
  •     Heated Pool (2)
  •     Yoga (2)
  •     Outdoor Pool (1)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (1)
  •     Dog Sitting (1)
  •     Rooftop Pool (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ