Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Check In
Check Out
1 room2 guests1 room, 2 guests
Info
Summary of reviewsThe Carlisle Inn Sarasota consistently garners positive reviews, particularly for its location, breakfast, dinner, rooms, cleanliness, staff, gym, pool, parking, family atmosphere and beds.
The hotel's location is highly commended for being nestled in a quiet, safe neighborhood, while still offering easy access to Sarasota's popular attractions such as Siesta Key Beach, Lido Beach and the Legacy Trail. The serene setting amidst the Amish district provides a tranquil retreat away from the city's hustle and bustle. Adequate parking and proximity to restaurants and shops further enhance its appeal, making it a convenient base for exploring the area.
Breakfast at Carlisle Inn Sarasota is often described as delicious and satisfying with a full complimentary buffet featuring homemade pastries, fresh fruit and artisanal products from Der Dutchman bakery. Guests appreciate the spacious and clean breakfast area and note the thoughtful touches like homemade cookies in the afternoon and continuous availability of coffee and tea.
Guests frequently praise the hotel's dining experience at Der Dutchman, which provides high-quality meals with an Amish influence. Reviewers highlight the delicious, homemade food and excellent value, recommending the evening buffet and various meal options.
Rooms at Carlisle Inn Sarasota are exceptionally large, clean and modern, equipped with amenities like small refrigerators, microwaves and kitchenettes. The comfortable beds, tasteful decor and meticulous attention to cleanliness contribute to a tranquil and restful environment. Common areas are similarly well-designed and maintained, enhancing the overall guest experience.
The staff at Carlisle Inn Sarasota are celebrated for their exceptional friendliness, attentiveness and professionalism. Guests consistently commend the team for their welcoming and accommodating nature, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay. Notable mentions of specific staff members highlight the personalized service that guests receive.
The hotel's fitness center is well-regarded for its cleanliness and extensive equipment selection. Though some noted it as small, it provides a comprehensive workout experience 24 hours a day. Similarly, the pool area with its clean, heated and well-maintained pools, including hot tubs and jacuzzis, is a favorite among guests, offering a relaxing ambiance.
Parking at Carlisle Inn Sarasota is hassle-free with ample, conveniently located spaces that add significant value to the guest experience. The parking facility is well-maintained with thoughtful amenities like available umbrellas enhancing the overall convenience.
Families find Carlisle Inn Sarasota particularly accommodating with a warm family atmosphere, engaging activities and amenities like baby cots and pool towels. The family-friendly environment and attentive staff ensure a welcoming and relaxing stay for guests of all ages.
Lastly, the beds receive high praise for their comfort, contributing to a well-rounded sleep experience. Guests frequently highlight the quality of the mattresses, pillows and sheets, noting that the beds are a standout feature in providing a restful night.
In summary, Carlisle Inn Sarasota excels in offering a well-rounded, comfortable and enjoyable stay, making it a highly recommended destination for a variety of travelers. Show more
Read review summaries for all categories
Categories
Hotel near Golf Courses
This hotel is mentioned as being near Legacy Golf Club, providing a convenient option for guests looking to play golf in the area.
Hotel for Honeymoon
This inn provides a cozy and comfortable setting, perfect for couples seeking a relaxing and intimate getaway. It offers a quiet and peaceful atmosphere.
Family Friendly Hotel
This inn is known for its exceptional service and comfortable accommodations, making it a pleasant stay for families. It offers a quiet and relaxing environment, perfect for those looking to unwind. The inn is conveniently located near local attractions, providing easy access to various activities.
Hotel with Swimming Pool
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota provides a serene pool setting, perfect for guests looking for a quiet and relaxing swim. The area is well-maintained and offers a peaceful retreat.
Heated Pool Outdoor Pool
Hotel with Free Wi-Fi
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota provides rooms with free Wi-Fi access, ensuring guests can stay connected. It also features an outdoor swimming pool and fitness center.
Business Hotel
Carlisle Inn Sarasota provides over 5,000 square feet of meeting space suitable for corporate events, conventions, trade shows, and wedding receptions. It offers a business center with free WiFi and a computer. The hotel also provides complimentary hot breakfast.
Hotel with Parking
This inn provides free on-site parking for guests. Its location and dedicated parking area make it easy to come and go as needed.
Accessible Hotel
This hotel offers handicapped-accessible rooms in standard or deluxe configurations.
4-Star Hotel
This inn is a 4-star hotel offering comfortable accommodations in Sarasota. It provides essential amenities for a pleasant stay.
Romantic Hotel
Hotel with Gym
Hotel with Outdoor Pool
Hotel with Heated Pool
Room Types
King RoomThis double room has a cable TV, seating area and sofa. A small refrigerator is also provided.
Standard Queen Room with Two Queen BedsThis quadruple room features a flat-screen TV and seating area.
Deluxe Queen Room with Two Queen BedsFeaturing free toiletries, this quadruple room includes a private bathroom with a bath or a shower and a hairdryer. The well-fitted kitchenette has a stovetop, a refrigerator, a dishwasher and kitchenware. The spacious air-conditioned quadruple room features a flat-screen TV with cable channels, soundproof walls, a tea and coffee maker, a seating area as well as pool views. The unit has 2 beds.
Deluxe King RoomThis double room features a kitchenette with a microwave and stove top. It also includes a spa bath for guests' enjoyment.
Deluxe SuiteThis suite has a seating area with a sofa. The kitchen includes an oven, stove top, and full size refrigerator.
Queen Room - Disability AccessThis double room features a tea/coffee maker, seating area and air conditioning. The private bathroom includes an accessible bath.
Guest Reviews
9.6
Excellent
Location
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota is well-received for its advantageous location, making it an excellent choice for travelers looking to explore the city and its surroundings. Nestled in a quiet and safe neighborhood, the hotel is conveniently situated close to a myriad of attractions, restaurants and shops with the added benefit of being just a short drive to downtown Sarasota. Guests appreciate the easy access to popular destinations such as the Ed Smith Stadium, Siesta Key Beach, Lido Beach and Legacy Trail.
Despite its distance of about 8-10 miles from the beaches, which some guests found less ideal, the property compensates with its serene setting amidst the Amish district. This scenic and tranquil environment offers a peaceful retreat away from the hustle and bustle, yet still keeps all major points of interest within a reachable distance, typically within a 15-20 minute drive.
Adequate parking and the quiet atmosphere enhance the appeal, while its proximity to restaurants and shops, including the on-site restaurant and bakery, provides added convenience. Visitors note that a car is essential for optimal mobility around Sarasota, but commend the hotel’s central location for making popular spots easily accessible. This makes the Carlisle Inn Sarasota a strategically located, tranquil base for exploring the rich attractions the area has to offer.
Breakfast
Breakfast at Carlisle Inn Sarasota is a well-regarded experience among guests, often described as delicious, satisfying and varied. Many reviewers praise the hot breakfast, highlighting a full complimentary buffet that consistently includes fresh, well-prepared items such as scrambled eggs, sausage, waffles, bagels, biscuits, pastries and fresh fruit. The inclusion of home-baked pastries and artisanal products like homemade granola and Amish-made items from Der Dutchman bakery receive special mention.
Several guests appreciate the complimentary aspect of the breakfast, noting that it exceeds their expectations with its variety and quality. The breakfast area is frequently described as spacious and clean with a well-organized setup and ample seating. Guests also enjoy additional touches like homemade cookies available in the afternoons and continuous availability of coffee and tea.
Despite the predominantly positive feedback, a few reviews suggest areas for improvement, such as the need for more variety and healthier options. Some mention the repetitive nature of the offerings, while others note the abundant use of disposable tableware, which could be reduced. Nevertheless, the overall sentiment is that the breakfast service at Carlisle Inn Sarasota significantly enhances the stay, providing a comforting and hearty start to the day.
Dinner
Guests of the Carlisle Inn Sarasota frequently praise the hotel's dining experience, highlighting its associated restaurant, Der Dutchman, which is just a short walk across the parking lot. Reviewers consistently describe Der Dutchman as providing excellent, high-quality meal options for lunch and dinner, often noting the delicious, homemade food that stands out for its great value. The restaurant, which is managed by the Amish, not only boasts a diverse and flavorful menu but also features a bakery and a charming gift shop with unique decor. The Amish influence extends to the overall dining experience, contributing a unique and delightful touch that guests seem to enjoy immensely. Despite a few mentions of the restaurant being closed on certain days for cleaning, the overall impression remains strongly positive. Diners recommend trying the evening buffet and various well-priced meal options, making Der Dutchman a notable highlight of their stay at Carlisle Inn Sarasota.
Rooms
Rooms at the Carlisle Inn Sarasota feature exceptionally large, clean and modern accommodations that are much larger than expected. Reviewers frequently praise the spacious, well-appointed rooms equipped with amenities like small refrigerators, microwaves and even some with kitchenettes. Many guests highlight the immaculate cleanliness and comfort of the rooms, noting that they are beyond spacious and often comparable to generously spaced suites. Rooms are also described as being very quiet and soundproof, providing a tranquil and restful environment.
The bed quality is repeatedly recognized for its comfort, making for a restful sleep. The tasteful, calming decor adds to the overall pleasant atmosphere with an element of sophisticated elegance. Many reviews mention the rooms' beautiful layouts with some having separate vanity areas, multiple sinks and substantial closet space.
Common spaces such as hallways and meeting rooms are also spacious and well-designed. The property as a whole maintains high standards of cleanliness and appeal. The warm and friendly staff contribute positively to the guest experience, addressing requests promptly and efficiently.
Overall, the comfort, size and cleanliness of the rooms at Carlisle Inn Sarasota consistently exceed guest expectations, offering a delightful stay that many describe as one of their best hotel experiences.
Beds
The beds at Carlisle Inn Sarasota have consistently received high praise from guests. Descriptions such as comfortable, super comfortable and extremely comfortable are frequently used, indicating a repeated emphasis on the quality of sleep provided. Guests have noted that the beds are equipped with good mattresses, pillows and sheets, often contributing to a well-rounded sleep experience. The king-size beds have been specifically mentioned as very comfortable and bedding quality is frequently highlighted as a positive aspect.
Cleanliness also stands out with reviews noting that both the beds and the rooms are exceptionally clean. While the majority of guests found the beds to be very comfortable, a few mentioned mattresses being on the firmer side and even described some as hard, revealing a slight variance in preference. Despite this, the overall consensus leans towards the beds far surpassing expectations, leading to a comfortable and restful stay. The combination of friendly staff, clean environs and well-appointed beds contributes to Carlisle Inn Sarasota being highly regarded among its guests.
Cleanliness
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota is highly acclaimed by guests for its exceptional cleanliness. Reviews consistently praise the hotel as immaculate, spotless and extremely well-maintained. Guests describe the rooms as spacious and fresh, often noting their pristine condition. The entire property, including common areas and facilities, is maintained to an impeccable standard with meticulous attention to detail. The hotel’s bright and airy atmosphere contributes to its clean and welcoming environment. Visitors appreciate the consistent changing of towels and prompt attention to cleanliness-related requests by the friendly and professional staff. The overall cleanliness significantly exceeds expectations, making Carlisle Inn Sarasota one of the cleanest and most well-kept accommodations that guests have ever experienced.
Staff
At the Carlisle Inn Sarasota, guest reviews consistently praise the hotel's staff for their exceptional friendliness, attentiveness and professionalism. Visitors frequently commend the team for being not only welcoming and warm but also highly accommodating and supportive. The staff, including notable mentions of Becky, Connie and other front desk personnel, are highlighted for their outstanding customer service and hospitable nature, ensuring that guests feel truly cared for throughout their stay.
Housekeeping is often recognized for their prompt, efficient and thorough service, creating a clean and comfortable environment that enhances the overall guest experience. The breakfast team also receives accolades for their organized and professional approach, contributing to a pleasant start to each guest's day.
The hotel's friendly atmosphere is further complemented by the staff's dedication to detail and willingness to go above and beyond, making sure all guest needs and preferences are met with care and efficiency. From reception to housekeeping, each team member plays a crucial role in maintaining the hotel's reputation for excellent service.
Overall, the Carlisle Inn Sarasota is celebrated for its super friendly and attentive staff, creating not just a place to stay but a memorable experience that leaves guests eager to return.
Wi-Fi
Recent reviews of Carlisle Inn Sarasota reveal mixed feedback regarding its WiFi service. On the positive side, guests frequently praised the WiFi for being excellent, reliable and easy to connect to. Comments highlighted superb and great WiFi, mentioning that it worked very well throughout the hotel, especially in public spaces which are noted to be very clean and offering good WiFi as well.
However, there were several concerns. Some guests experienced slow and unstable connections, reporting that the internet service was almost non-existent in their rooms or not available at certain times. Others noted that the WiFi reception kept cutting out or that the internet connection didn't work everywhere. A few guests mentioned that despite the convenient in-room WiFi, the service could still use some improvement.
Overall, while the WiFi service at Carlisle Inn Sarasota has been highly effective for many, there remain areas needing enhancement to ensure a consistently positive experience for all visitors.
Gym
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota boasts a fitness center that consistently impresses guests with its cleanliness and maintenance. The gym is described as well-equipped, offering everything from new equipment and weights to extra towels and water. Though some reviews mention that the gym is small, many appreciated that it was spacious enough and found it to be a fantastic workout facility. The infrastructure is noted to be beautiful and the gym is available 24 hours, providing flexibility for guests' workout schedules. Overall, the gym at the Carlisle Inn Sarasota stands out as a highlight for fitness enthusiasts, providing a very good exercise experience in a clean and well-kept environment.
Pool
The pool at Carlisle Inn Sarasota receives high praise from guests with consistent emphasis on its cleanliness and well-maintained condition. Guests find the pool area beautiful with plenty of sun loungers and towels readily available. The pool is described as very large, clean and heated, adding to the overall comfort and experience.
The pool area includes amenities such as hot tubs and jacuzzis, which are also highlighted for their excellence. The saltwater and outdoor pools provide a relaxing ambiance, making it a favored spot for relaxation. Guests also appreciate the quiet and well-organized atmosphere around the pool.
Though generally well-received, some guests pointed out that the pool is on the smaller side and can get crowded, particularly with kids. There are also mentions of a preference for longer pool hours and more shade. Despite these minor critiques, the overall sentiment towards the pool area remains highly positive, marking it as one of the hotel's standout features.
Parking
Carlisle Inn Sarasota offers a hassle-free parking experience for its guests, ensuring that parking concerns are the last thing on visitors' minds. The hotel boasts adequate parking spaces with ample and plenty of spots available directly on the property. Reviewers frequently highlight the convenience of parking right in front of the door, making it easy to carry luggage and settle in quickly.
The parking area is easily accessible and abundant, providing sufficient space whether one arrives early or late. Furthermore, the inclusion of free parking adds significant value, saving guests from any added expenses. Convenient and free parking make it a prime choice for visitors traveling by car.
Additionally, thoughtful amenities such as umbrellas available for the parking lot and an overall well-maintained parking facility enhance the experience. Staff members contribute to the positive experience with polite and excellent service, further accommodating guests' parking needs.
Overall, Carlisle Inn Sarasota’s parking facilities receive high praise for their convenience, accessibility and abundance, making the stay even more comfortable and stress-free.
Family
Carlisle Inn Sarasota stands out as a wonderful destination for families seeking a comfortable and engaging vacation experience. The hotel offers a warm family atmosphere, making it very practical for those traveling with children. The swimming pool is a hit with kids, ensuring they are entertained throughout their stay. Guests consistently praise the family-friendly environment and attentive staff who make everyone, including the youngest guests, feel welcome.
Rooms are noted for their cleanliness and comfort, which is perfect for families. The availability of baby cots and provision of pool towels add to the convenience, allowing parents to feel at ease. Despite occasional disruptions from large groups, such as youth baseball teams, the overall atmosphere remains safe, calm and homey, contributing to a relaxed stay.
Families appreciate the daily events and diverse activities available, which cater to all ages and enhance the vacation experience. The good breakfast options and friendly interactions with staff are other highlights that guests frequently mention. Carlisle Inn Sarasota’s focus on creating a family-centric environment, complete with clean facilities and a respectful guest culture, solidifies its reputation as an ideal spot for family trips. Its location and amenities make it highly recommended for those planning a family vacation.
Business
Carlisle Inn Sarasota proves to be a prime choice for business travelers, offering a range of facilities that cater specifically to their needs. Positioned in a good location, the hotel presents itself as ideal for business stays, largely due to its excellent customer service and business-friendly environment. The establishment boasts meeting rooms and dedicated business facilities, ensuring that it accommodates professional gatherings with ease.
The rooms are notably large and comfortable, paired with modern business amenities such as high-speed internet, which supports a seamless work experience. Guests can benefit from a quiet environment that is perfect for productivity and focus. The new and modern appearance of the hotel further enhances the experience, making it an attractive option for business trips.
The commitment to customer-oriented service is evident through the attentive staff, including a particularly friendly reception staff member. Overall, Carlisle Inn Sarasota offers all necessary amenities for a convenient and stress-free business stay, making it a top choice for professional travelers seeking to balance work and comfort.
Accessible
Carlisle Inn Sarasota has received commendable feedback regarding its accessibility for guests with disabilities. The accessible facilities are described as well-maintained and functional, offering convenient features such as wheelchair ramps and easy-access entries. The hotel provides accessible rooms which are clean, safe for elderly guests and equipped with bathing accessibility. Additionally, the staff is noted for their efforts to accommodate special needs, offering helpful recommendations and showing concern for guests using accessible rooms. These positive aspects highlight the hotel's commitment to ensuring a comfortable stay for all visitors.
Heated Pool
Travel enthusiasts will be pleased to discover that the heated pool at Carlisle Inn Sarasota receives consistent praise from its guests. The pool area is frequently highlighted as a prime feature, described as well-heated and comfortable, ensuring a pleasant swim experience. Many reviewers find the warmth akin to bath water, making it a relaxing retreat. The presence of a jacuzzi further complements the heated pool, creating a multifaceted aquatic experience. The organization and maintenance of the pool area stand out, enhancing the overall enjoyment. Whether visitors are looking to take a leisurely dip or unwind in the jacuzzi, the heated amenities at Carlisle Inn Sarasota come highly recommended for a truly comforting stay.
Outdoor Pool
The outdoor pool area at Carlisle Inn Sarasota has received high praise from guests for its cleanliness, relaxation and features. The heated pool and jacuzzi are highlights, making the pool area enjoyable and fun. Many guests appreciated the nicely heated water and the relaxing atmosphere. The saltwater pool is an additional positive feature noted by visitors. While some mentioned the pool was small, they still found it clean and pleasant and children seemed to particularly enjoy it. The presence of deck chairs adds to the comfort, though a few guests noted the lack of shade as a minor drawback. Overall, the pool area was frequently described as beautiful, great and easy to access, contributing significantly to a pleasant stay.
Honeymoon
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota is ideal for honeymooners and celebrated as a top spot for newlyweds. Known for its dedicated honeymoon suite and specialized packages, the hotel provides a romantic and serene environment perfect for couples. Guests frequently highlight how the atmosphere caters to a memorable honeymoon experience. Those celebrating anniversaries also find the setting suitable with amenities designed for relaxation, including jet noise-canceling headphones. While some specific details may not be explicitly stated, the overall feedback emphasizes the hotel's commitment to providing a blissful escape for honeymooners.
Luxury
Carlisle Inn Sarasota has received overwhelmingly positive acclaim from its guests, reflecting an ambience of elegance and luxury. The hotel surpassed initial expectations, leaving visitors in awe of its beautiful, well-kept facilities. Guests describe their stay as the best hotel experience in years with luxurious rooms and accommodations that could easily be rated five stars. The atmosphere throughout the hotel exudes a sophisticated charm with amenities and services akin to what is typically found in high-end establishments. The suites are particularly noted for their well-equipped, luxurious nature, making the Carlisle Inn Sarasota an exceptional choice for a truly elegant and refined getaway.
Romantic
The Carlisle Inn Sarasota delivers an ideal retreat for couples, creating a romantic setting that many guests describe as perfect. The ambiance is lovely and charming with a sense of peace that makes visitors feel at home. The quiet rooms and pool areas offer great escapes for those looking to relax together. The staff's attentive service adds to the overall experience. For special occasions like anniversaries or a simple weekend getaway, Carlisle Inn stands out as an oasis away from the crowds, offering both spacious and intimate accommodations.
Yes, Carlisle Inn Sarasota has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Heated Pool, Outdoor Pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Carlisle Inn Sarasota.
No, Carlisle Inn Sarasota doesn't allow dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at Carlisle Inn Sarasota.