Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Historic Hotels in East Rutherford

44 HOTELS IN AND AROUND EAST RUTHERFORDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Hotel Lucerne main photo
Hotel Lucerne
6.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $269
$
Historic
Located on the Upper West Side, Hotel Lucerne offers a classic and refined atmosphere. Its architecture and design reflect the elegance of a bygone era. The hotel provides a comfortable and timeless experience, making it a notable historic stay.
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
Hotel Lucerne is a charming historical gem in New York City with a rich heritage and old-world allure. The building exudes vintage style and European elegance, boasting a beautiful and well-preserved exterior that harks back to the early twentieth century. The hotel has managed to maintain its historical character and old-world glamour, which is particularly evident in its classic decor and architecture. Guests appreciate the charming ambiance, characterized by a blend of history and elegance, making it stand out as a venerable establishment in the uptown west area. While the decor may be considered outdated, it only adds to the distinctive style and historical charm that makes Hotel Lucerne a unique and memorable stay.
Hotel Marrakech main photo
Hotel Marrakech
6.2 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
6.8
Rated
From $84
$
Info
Categories
Historic
Nightlife
Free Wi-Fi
Dream Midtown, by Hyatt main photo
Dream Midtown, by Hyatt
6.5 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.6
Good
From $232
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Dream Midtown by Hyatt offers a prime location in Midtown Manhattan, nestled conveniently between Central Park and Times Square. Guests rave about the easy access to major attractions, theaters, museums and dining experiences, lauding the hotel's perfect position for exploring New York City. The proximity to Broadway and subway stations adds to its appeal for both leisure and business travelers.

The hotel's complimentary continental breakfast served at the nearby Serafina restaurant garners mixed reviews. While some guests appreciate the inclusion of breakfast in the room rate and find it satisfactory for a quick start, others criticize the limited variety and lack of hot items. Suggestions for improvement include adding more substantial options like eggs and sausages.

The dining experience at Dream Midtown receives a generally positive response with particular praise for the quality of meals at Serafina and the vibrant rooftop bar offering stunning city views. Although some find the rooftop bar slightly pretentious with smaller portions, it remains a popular spot for evening relaxation. The cocktail lounge adds to the overall pleasant dining experience, though room service fees and expensive wine are noted downsides.

Rooms at Dream Midtown offer a clean stay with many guests complimenting the tidiness and comfortable beds. However, the rooms are often described as small and narrow with occasional issues such as insufficient lighting, outdated fixtures and noise disturbances. Despite these drawbacks, the hotel’s prime location and cleanliness are repeatedly highlighted.

Cleanliness across the hotel is generally praised, reflecting well-maintained rooms and attentive housekeeping staff. Some inconsistencies in vacuuming and occasional oversights were mentioned, but the overall feedback on cleanliness is positive.

The staff at Dream Midtown are frequently commended for their exceptional service, welcoming demeanor and attentiveness. Particular individuals like Yofi, Brian and Lauren receive special mention for going above and beyond, enhancing the overall guest experience. Minor negative interactions were reported but did not overshadow the general sentiment of excellent hospitality.

Wifi at the hotel has mixed reviews with some guests finding it sufficient while others experience inconsistent and slow connections. Improving the wifi quality could enhance the guest experience further. Parking poses a challenge with no on-site options and high costs at nearby garages, though the availability of discounted vouchers is a plus for some guests.

Nightlife at Dream Midtown is vibrant, centered around the rooftop bar praised for its atmosphere and city views. The hotel's location provides easy access to nearby bars and clubs, making it a desirable spot for nightlife enthusiasts, despite occasional noise and higher prices.

The beds at Dream Midtown receive overwhelmingly positive feedback for comfort, contributing to restful stays with guests frequently highlighting the soft, spacious bedding. This aspect stands out as a major positive in guest reviews.

Despite mixed feedback regarding its four-star rating with some guests feeling the hotel falls short of expectations, Dream Midtown offers a well-rounded experience with notable strengths in its location, staff service and comfortable accommodations. Minor areas for improvement include breakfast variety, room size and wifi quality. The hotel also makes efforts to accommodate guests with accessibility needs, ensuring a welcoming and safe environment for all visitors.
Categories
Historic
Health & Safety
Dog Friendly
The High Line Hotel main photo
The High Line Hotel
6.5 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.9
Good
From $404
$
Historic
The High Line Hotel is situated in a portion of the General Theological Seminary, a Federal Historic Landmark dating back to the mid-1800s. The collegiate gothic-style architecture and serene grounds provide a unique and inspiring atmosphere. The hotel blends historic details with modern amenities, creating a distinct sense of place.
JW Marriott Essex House New York main photo
JW Marriott Essex House New York
6.6 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $643
$
Historic
For over 70 years, the JW Marriott Essex House has been an oasis of elegance on Central Park South. Its Art Deco design, luxurious amenities, and stunning views of Central Park and the New York skyline have made it a preferred destination for discerning travelers seeking a blend of history and luxury.
The Chatwal, The Unbound Collection by Hyatt main photo
The Chatwal, The Unbound Collection by Hyatt
6.7 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $612
$
Historic
Before becoming The Chatwal New York, this iconic building had been the epicenter of American theater for the 20th century. Built in 1905 by Stanford White and renovated over time, this jewel is located in the heart of New York.
The Plaza main photo
The Plaza
6.8 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $899
$
Historic
Opened in 1907, The Plaza is a New York City landmark renowned for its French Renaissance style and opulent interiors. It has been the site of many significant cultural events, including Truman Capote's Black and White Ball, and featured in numerous films and books. Designated an official landmark in 1969, it continues to represent the splendor of the Golden Age.
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
The Plaza is a stunning, iconic hotel with a rich sense of history and timelessness that guests can feel as soon as they step through the doors. Its historic and cinematic building captures the essence of a bygone era, complete with old world decor that is truly beautiful. Whether you're interested in the location history, arquitectura y decoración, or simply want to experience a piece of history, The Plaza is sure to leave a lasting impression. Unfortunately some guests have said that the current management doesn't really represent the hotel's legacy, but overall The Plaza remains a must-visit for anyone interested in experiencing the iconic and historic property.
The Algonquin Hotel Times Square, Autograph Collection main photo
The Algonquin Hotel Times Square, Autograph Collection
6.9 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $313
$
Historic
Opened in 1902, The Algonquin is known for its literary history, having been a favorite haunt of writers and artists for decades. Designated a New York City landmark, it offers a unique blend of history and culture in the heart of the Theater District. Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe wrote My Fair Lady in Lerner’s suite at the Algonquin in 1956.
Chelsea Pines Inn main photo
Chelsea Pines Inn
6.9 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.8
Good
From $259
$
Historic
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
Chelsea Pines Inn offers a nostalgic journey into the heart of historic New York, perfectly encapsulating the charm and character of the '60s. Guests are enchanted by its old New York ambiance with a design reminiscent of classic Hollywood's golden era. The hotel is housed in a beautifully maintained historic building, where each room lets you step back in time, themed around movie stars and adorned with vintage movie posters. This unique decor, blending fun and kitsch elements, provides an authentic experience that's both warm and charming.

The quintessential New York charm of its location, combined with the hotel’s rich history and vintage decor, makes it an exceptional stay for those fascinated by the past. Its movie-inspired interiors and themed rooms honor legendary actors, creating a truly cinematic atmosphere throughout. Despite some elements feeling somewhat old-fashioned, the authentic character and style of the inn offer a delightful and quaint retreat, adding a special touch to the Chelsea neighborhood's historic allure.
Refinery Hotel - New York main photo
Refinery Hotel - New York
6.9 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.2
Very Good
From $403
$
Historic
Located in the Garment District, the Refinery Hotel occupies the Colony Arcade Building, a former hat factory from 1912. The hotel incorporates many of the building's original industrial features, such as high ceilings and distressed hardwood floors, blending them with modern luxury. The design cleverly integrates hat-making tools and sewing machines into the decor.
The St. Regis New York main photo
The St. Regis New York
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
From $825
$
Historic
The St. Regis is synonymous with timeless elegance and impeccable service. Since its opening in 1904, it has been a favorite among royalty, celebrities, and discerning travelers. Its Beaux-Arts design, luxurious amenities, and historical significance make it a top choice for those seeking a grand and sophisticated experience.
The Gregorian New York City main photo
The Gregorian New York City
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.1
Very Good
$
Historic
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
The Gregorian New York City stands out for its historical significance with guests appreciating its pre-war charm and distinctive character. Built in 1903 and recently refurbished, the hotel retains its original features, which add to its unique ambiance. Despite being an older establishment, it is well-maintained, offering an exquisite experience reminiscent of boutique European-style hotels. However, some guests noted the absence of on-site food and drink options and mentioned the need for further maintenance and renovation. Overall, the hotel's historical allure and preserved features provide a memorable stay for those who appreciate historic settings.
Candy Hill Harlem main photo
Candy Hill Harlem
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Bed & Breakfast in New York NYUS flag
7.5
Good
From $27
$
Info
Categories
Historic
Dog Friendly
Nightlife
Martinique New York on Broadway, Curio Collection by Hilton main photo
Martinique New York on Broadway, Curio Collection by Hilton
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.1
Very Good
From $296
$
Historic
Designed by Henry Hardenbergh, the same architect behind the Waldorf Astoria and The Plaza, the Martinique has reflected the rich history of its location for over a century. Its Beaux-Arts architecture and prime location on Broadway make it a significant historical landmark.
Omni Berkshire Place main photo
Omni Berkshire Place
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $364
$
Historic
Built in 1926, the Omni Berkshire Place has a long-standing tradition of providing luxurious accommodations and exceptional service. Its classic design and prime location in Midtown Manhattan make it a notable part of New York's hotel history.
The Townhouse Inn of Chelsea main photo
The Townhouse Inn of Chelsea
7.0 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $18
$
Info
Categories
Historic
Honeymoon
Family
Andaz 5th Avenue, By Hyatt main photo
Andaz 5th Avenue, By Hyatt
7.1 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $545
$
Historic
Sitting right at the heart of New York City, this historic hotel was built in 1916.
Lotte New York Palace main photo
Lotte New York Palace
7.1 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.9
Good
From $485
$
Historic
The Lotte New York Palace incorporates the historic Villard Houses, built in the 1880s, which are designated landmarks. The hotel blends these neo-Renaissance mansions with a modern skyscraper, creating a unique architectural contrast. The Gold Room, with its original gilded ceilings, is a breathtaking reminder of a bygone era.
Life Hotel New York main photo
Life Hotel New York
7.1 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $236
$
Historic
Housed in the former LIFE Magazine building, this hotel blends history with modern style. The building itself has many original details.
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
Situated in the heart of Manhattan, Life Hotel New York boasts an undeniably historic significance. Nestled within the old building of Life Magazine, this charming hotel has preserved many original details that add to its unique allure. The building has been meticulously restored with a lot of care, reflecting a blend of charming fixtures and historical updates. Guests consistently highlight the hotel's unique charm, stemming from its past as the former Life Magazine editorial office. Overall, Life Hotel New York is a beautiful property steeped in history, offering a uniquely historic experience in a prime location.
Robert Treat Hotel main photo
Robert Treat Hotel
7.2 km from East Rutherford
Hotel in Newark NJUS flag
7.1
Good
From $134
$
Historic
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
Nestled within walking distance of Rutgers University and the New Jersey Institute of Technology, the Robert Treat Hotel offers guests a rich historical experience. Established in 1917, this beautiful historic hotel has retained its historic charm and design. The architecture and building exude a timeless elegance, providing a peaceful and quiet retreat for its visitors.

The atrium, reminiscent of a bygone era, further enhances the hotel's historic ambiance. Guests have recognized the hotel's long and illustrious history, which even includes connections to notable figures such as Einstein. The historic design and picturesque park in front of the hotel contribute to its serene atmosphere, making it a noteworthy stay for those exploring nearby iconic places.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 44 hotels in and around East Rutherford
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities