5-Star HotelJudge's Lodging offers a historic and luxurious experience with its elegant rooms, charming atmosphere, and central York location. Its blend of history and modern amenities makes it a unique and memorable choice.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' categoryJudge's Lodging in York presents itself as a five-star establishment but has received mixed reviews regarding its alignment with that prestigious classification. Guests generally appreciate the hotel’s great location, acknowledging its convenience despite some noise at night. However, there are several points of contention: many visitors feel the hotel falls short of five-star expectations, with some pointing out it seems more like a three-star experience. Concerns include the lack of a proper fridge in the rooms, inconsistent hygiene standards, and room images not matching those advertised online.
Despite these criticisms, numerous guests still express satisfaction and recommend the hotel to others, highlighting exceptional and wonderful experiences and valuing it as an excellent option for staying in York. While the property is old and there are challenges such as the absence of a lift or concierge service, the overall impression remains positive for many who have stayed. Although the luxury may be lacking for those expecting top-tier standards, the reasonable pricing compared to other five-star hotels and the charming experience outweigh the shortcomings for many guests. Ultimately, for its price range, Judge's Lodging is a place that guests have frequently recommended and shown willingness to return to.
Show moreRead review summaries for all categories
